DiscoverBad On Paper2025 Debut Author Anthology
2025 Debut Author Anthology

2025 Debut Author Anthology

Update: 2025-10-22
Share

Digest

Becca and Olivia of Bad on Paper welcome listeners and share their weekly highs and lows. The podcast then delves into the surprising aspects of debuting as an author, with both hosts sharing their personal experiences. This is followed by interviews with four debut authors: Natalie Guerrero ("My Train Leaves at Three"), Laura Leflerr ("Tell Them You Lied"), Ayesha Muharar ("Loved One"), and Katie Yee ("Maggie, or a man and a woman walking to a bar"). Each author discusses their novel, their writing process, and unique challenges and joys of being a debut author. The episode also includes sponsorships for BetterHelp, Uncommon Goods, and Audible. It concludes with discussions on weekly obsessions, recent reads, and the October book club pick.

Outlines

00:00:18
Introduction, Weekly Highs & Lows, and Sponsorships

Becca and Olivia welcome listeners, share their personal highs and lows of the week, and introduce sponsored segments for BetterHelp and Uncommon Goods.

00:09:15
The Surprising Debut Author Experience

Becca and Olivia discuss the unexpected aspects of debuting as an author, with Becca finding it more enjoyable than anticipated and Olivia highlighting the shift from a "big fish" to a "small fish" and reconnecting with past acquaintances.

00:18:40
Author Interview: Natalie Guerrero

Natalie Guerrero, author of "My Train Leaves at Three," discusses her novel about grief and dreams, the rapid pace of the publishing industry, and the distinction between being a writer and an author.

00:28:41
Author Interview: Laura Leflerr

Laura Leflerr, author of "Tell Them You Lied," shares insights into her 9/11-themed novel, publisher pushback, and the unexpected generosity of authors in providing blurbs.

00:40:02
Author Interview: Ayesha Muharar

Ayesha Muharar, author of "Loved One," talks about her novel, the differences between screenwriting and novel writing, and the continuous "debut" moments as new readers discover her work.

00:48:30
Author Interview: Katie Yee

Katie Yee, author of "Maggie, or a man and a woman walking to a bar," discusses her novel, reader vulnerability, and the strong sense of community at book events.

00:58:06
Sponsorship and Closing Remarks

A sponsorship for Audible's thriller "The Room Next Door" is presented, followed by discussions on weekly obsessions, recent reads, the October book club pick, and closing remarks.

Keywords

Debut Author Experience


The journey and emotional landscape of first-time authors releasing their inaugural book, including the publishing process, reader reception, and self-doubt.

Grief and Loss in Literature


Exploring themes of mourning, bereavement, and coping mechanisms within fictional narratives, focusing on character development centered around loss.

Publishing Industry Dynamics


The business and creative processes involved in bringing a book to market, encompassing agent relationships, editorial processes, and marketing strategies.

Literary Fiction


A genre of fiction characterized by its artistic merit, focus on character development, thematic depth, and sophisticated prose, exploring complex human emotions and societal issues.

Psychological Thriller


A genre that blends suspense and psychological elements, featuring unreliable narrators, intricate plots, and a focus on characters' mental states and motivations.

Book Marketing and Promotion


Strategies and tactics used to promote books and reach potential readers, including blurbs, author tours, and social media engagement.

Author-Reader Connection


The relationship and interaction between authors and their readers, manifesting through book events, social media, and shared experiences inspired by the author's work.

Mental Health Resources


Information and promotion of online therapy platforms like BetterHelp, emphasizing the importance of mental health support.

Unique Gift Ideas


Highlighting handcrafted and unique gifts available from retailers like Uncommon Goods, suitable for various recipients and occasions.

Audible Originals


Promotion of exclusive audio content, such as the psychological thriller "The Room Next Door," available on the Audible platform.

Q&A

  • What are some surprising aspects of the debut author experience?

    Debut authors are often surprised by the emotional highs and lows, the shift in perspective from being a "big fish" to a "small fish" in the author pond, and the unexpected connections they make with readers and people from their past.

  • How do authors navigate the challenges of the publishing industry?

    Authors face challenges like industry speed, potential pushback on sensitive topics (e.g., 9/11), and the "blurb economy." They often rely on agent support, personal resilience, and a strong belief in their story.

  • What is the distinction between a "writer" and an "author"?

    A writer focuses on the craft of writing, often in solitude, while an author engages with the public-facing aspects of publishing, including book tours, promotion, and reader interaction. The speed of the publishing machine can highlight this difference.

  • How do authors perceive reader interpretations of their work?

    Authors are often surprised by how readers bring their own experiences and biases to a book, leading to interpretations that may differ from the author's original intent. This can be both beautiful and challenging.

  • What role do blurbs play in a debut author's experience?

    Blurbs from established authors can be a significant confidence boost and a source of validation for debut authors. The process of obtaining them can be nerve-wracking, but the generosity of established writers is often heartening.

Show Notes

This week, we're chatting with 4 debut authors about their experience bringing a book into the world in 2025! They share the pitch for their book and what surprised them about their debut experience.

 

Our debut authors & their books! 

Katie Yee - Maggie; Or A Man and A Woman Walk Into A Bar

Natalie Guerrero - My Train Leaves at Three

Laura Leffler  - Tell Them You Lied

Aisha Muharrar - Loved One

 

Obsessions

Olivia - Not wearing mascara 

Becca - Leopard Coat from Mango

 

What we read this week

Becca- The Ten Year Affair by Erin Somers

Olivia - Take Me Apart by Sara Sligar

 

This Month's Book Club Pick - Heart The Lover by Lily King (have thoughts about this book you want to share? Call in at 843-405-3157 or email us a voice memo at badonpaperpodcast@gmail.com)

 

Sponsors

Better Help - get 10% off your first month at BetterHelp.com/BADONPAPER

Uncommon Goods - get 15% off your next gift at uncommmongoods.com/bop

Room Next Door - Don't miss Wendy Walker's new Audible Original The Room Next Door. Go to Audible dot com

 

Join our Facebook group for amazing book recs & more! 

Buy our Merch!

Join our Geneva!

Preorder Olivia's Book, Little One, and order Such a Bad Influence!

Subscribe to Olivia's Newsletter!

Order Becca's Book, The Christmas Orphans Club!

Subscribe to Becca's Newsletter! 

Follow us on Instagram @badonpaperpodcast. Follow Olivia on Instagram @oliviamuenter and Becca @beccamfreeman.

 

 

Comments 
In Channel
Hidden Gem Reads Redux

Hidden Gem Reads Redux

2026-04-2252:45

April 2026 Three Things

April 2026 Three Things

2026-04-1501:22:37

2026 Publishing Trends

2026 Publishing Trends

2026-04-0801:13:03

The 8th Anniversary Episode

The 8th Anniversary Episode

2026-04-0101:47:17

So Old, So Young Book Club

So Old, So Young Book Club

2026-03-2501:18:26

March 2026 Three Things

March 2026 Three Things

2026-03-1101:14:24

Little One Book Club

Little One Book Club

2026-02-2501:27:07

February 2026 Three Things

February 2026 Three Things

2026-02-1801:24:19

Obscure Erotica 2026

Obscure Erotica 2026

2026-02-1152:20

The Heated Rivalry Episode

The Heated Rivalry Episode

2026-02-0401:44:48

2026 Reading Preview

2026 Reading Preview

2026-01-2101:19:41

January 2026 Three Things

January 2026 Three Things

2026-01-1401:17:49

2026 Goals

2026 Goals

2026-01-0701:32:33

Best Books of 2025

Best Books of 2025

2025-12-1701:10:30

A Very Festive Three Things

A Very Festive Three Things

2025-12-1001:07:23

Best of 2025

Best of 2025

2025-12-0301:19:37

loading

Table of contents

00:00
00:00
x

0.5x

0.8x

1.0x

1.25x

1.5x

2.0x

3.0x

Sleep Timer

Off

End of Episode

5 Minutes

10 Minutes

15 Minutes

30 Minutes

45 Minutes

60 Minutes

120 Minutes

2025 Debut Author Anthology

2025 Debut Author Anthology

Becca Freeman & Olivia Muenter