DiscoverTrue Crime Obsessed378: The Playboy Murders: The Story of Stacy and Jim Arthur
378: The Playboy Murders: The Story of Stacy and Jim Arthur

378: The Playboy Murders: The Story of Stacy and Jim Arthur

Update: 2024-07-254
Share

Digest

This episode of the "Playboy Martyrs" podcast delves into the story of Stacy Arthur, a former pageant queen who became a Playboy cover model. The hosts discuss her relationship with her husband, Jim, and how he supported her career. They then reveal the existence of a Playboy hotline where callers could interact with playmates, highlighting the potential dangers of this system and how it led to the obsession of James Lindbergh, a caller who became fixated on Stacy. The episode details the events leading up to the murder of Jim Arthur by James Lindbergh, emphasizing the stalker's obsession with Stacy and the tragic consequences of the parasocial relationship fostered by the Playboy hotline. The hosts discuss the aftermath of the murder, including Stacy's grief and the lawsuit she filed against Playboy. They also reveal Stacy's passing in 2019 and the lack of information surrounding her death. The episode concludes with a summary of the story and a promotion of the hosts' Patreon and Facebook group, as well as a preview of upcoming episodes.

Outlines

00:00:00
The Playboy Martyrs: Stacy Arthur and the Dangers of Parasocial Relationships

This episode of the "Playboy Martyrs" podcast delves into the tragic story of Stacy Arthur, a former pageant queen who became a Playboy cover model. The hosts discuss her relationship with her husband, Jim, and how he supported her career. They then reveal the existence of a Playboy hotline where callers could interact with playmates, highlighting the potential dangers of this system and how it led to the obsession of James Lindbergh, a caller who became fixated on Stacy.

00:01:16
The Playboy Hotline and the Obsession of James Lindbergh

The hosts discuss the Playboy hotline and how it fostered a sense of intimacy and accessibility, leading to the obsessive behavior of James Lindbergh, who became fixated on Stacy Arthur. They detail the events leading up to the murder of Jim Arthur by James Lindbergh, emphasizing the stalker's obsession with Stacy and the tragic consequences of the parasocial relationship fostered by the Playboy hotline.

00:02:49
The Tragic Outcome and Aftermath

The hosts discuss the aftermath of the murder, including Stacy's grief and the lawsuit she filed against Playboy. They also reveal Stacy's passing in 2019 and the lack of information surrounding her death.

00:40:12
Conclusion and Upcoming Episodes

The hosts conclude the episode by summarizing the story and promoting their Patreon and Facebook group. They also preview upcoming episodes of the show.

Keywords

Playboy Martyrs


A true crime podcast series that explores the lives and deaths of women associated with Playboy magazine.

Stacy Arthur


A pageant queen who became a Playboy cover model and was the subject of a stalker's obsession.

James Lindbergh


A caller on the Playboy hotline who became fixated on Stacy Arthur and ultimately murdered her husband, Jim.

Parasocial Relationship


A one-sided relationship where one person feels a connection with a celebrity or public figure, often through social media or other forms of media.

Playboy Hotline


A 900 number service that allowed callers to interact with Playboy playmates, potentially leading to dangerous and obsessive behavior.

Q&A

  • What was the Playboy hotline and how did it contribute to the tragedy?

    The Playboy hotline was a 900 number service that allowed callers to interact with playmates. It fostered a sense of intimacy and accessibility, leading to the obsessive behavior of James Lindbergh, who became fixated on Stacy Arthur.

  • How did Playboy exploit the women involved in the hotline?

    Playboy encouraged playmates to make themselves accessible to callers, blurring the lines between fan and friend. They also prioritized profit over the safety of the women, failing to implement adequate safeguards against obsessive behavior.

  • What was the outcome of Stacy Arthur's lawsuit against Playboy?

    Stacy Arthur sued Playboy for $70 million, alleging negligence and exploitation. The lawsuit was ultimately dropped due to a lack of evidence, and Playboy fired Stacy, further highlighting their disregard for her well-being.

  • What is the significance of the story of Stacy and Jim Arthur?

    The story of Stacy and Jim Arthur serves as a cautionary tale about the dangers of parasocial relationships and the exploitation of women in the entertainment industry. It highlights the importance of setting boundaries and protecting oneself from obsessive behavior.

Show Notes

In 1990, 19 year old Stacy Arthur went from Ohio farmgirl to Playboy centerfold practically over night. And right by her side was her husband and manager, Jim. Stacy threw herself into the world of Playboy--a world where the models are encouraged to interact with fans in a way that can make them obsessive. And in 1991, one fan's obsession turned to murder. This episode covers "The Playboy Murders: All That Glitters."



FAM!! COME TO A MEETUP IN YOUR CITY!! Patrick is coming to town to get the TCO Fam together and you should come hang out!! RSVP HERE AND LET'S GET THIS PARTY STARTED



LOOKING FOR MORE TCO? On our Patreon feed, you'll find over 400 FULL AD-FREE BONUS episodes to BINGE RIGHT NOW, including our episode-by-episode coverage of popular documentary series like Love Has Won: The Cult of Mother God, LulaRich, and The Curious Case of Natalia Grace; classics like The Jinx, Making A Murderer, and The Staircase; and well-known cases like The Menendez Murders, The Murder of Laci Peterson, Casey Anthony: American Murder Mystery, and The Disappearance of Madeleine McCann, and so many more!    
Comments 
00:00
00:00
x

0.5x

0.8x

1.0x

1.25x

1.5x

2.0x

3.0x

Sleep Timer

Off

End of Episode

5 Minutes

10 Minutes

15 Minutes

30 Minutes

45 Minutes

60 Minutes

120 Minutes

378: The Playboy Murders: The Story of Stacy and Jim Arthur

378: The Playboy Murders: The Story of Stacy and Jim Arthur

True Crime Obsessed