40 Acres and a Lie Part 3
1Digest
The final episode of the "Forty Acres and Alive" series delves into the complex issue of reparations, examining the historical and contemporary significance of the phrase "Forty Acres and a Mule." The episode features the story of Elon Osby, whose family was displaced from their land in Forsyth County, Georgia, in 1912 due to racial intimidation and later from Bagley Park in Atlanta in the 1950s through eminent domain. Osby's experience highlights the ongoing pattern of land loss among Black families in the United States. The episode then shifts to Fulton County's efforts to create a reparations task force, led by Carshique Sims Alvarado, who is determined to compile a comprehensive harm report documenting the injustices faced by Black residents. The task force is facing challenges in accessing historical records and opposition from some county commissioners. The episode also explores the broader reparations movement, highlighting the work of Ray Jenkins, known as "Reparations Ray," who tirelessly advocated for reparations in Detroit for decades. Jenkins' efforts culminated in the introduction of HR 40, a bill proposing a federal commission to study reparations. The episode concludes with a discussion between two economists, William Darity and Glenn Lowry, who offer contrasting perspectives on the issue of reparations. Darity argues for a $14 trillion payment from the federal government, while Lowry believes that reparations are not a viable solution and that individual responsibility is crucial. The episode emphasizes the ongoing conversation surrounding reparations and the need for a deeper understanding of the historical and contemporary injustices faced by Black Americans.
Outlines
Introduction and Call to Donate
This Chapter introduces the episode as the final installment of a three-part series and reiterates the call for donations to support the non-profit newsroom.
The Legacy of Forty Acres and a Mule
This Chapter explores the symbolic meaning of "Forty Acres and a Mule" as an unpaid debt and examines its representation in various films and television series. It emphasizes the enduring sense of betrayal and desire for justice associated with this historical promise.
Elon Osby's Story of Land Loss
This Chapter focuses on the story of Elon Osby, whose family was displaced from their land in Forsyth County, Georgia, in 1912 due to racial intimidation and later from Bagley Park in Atlanta in the 1950s through eminent domain. Osby's experience highlights the ongoing pattern of land loss among Black families in the United States.
Fulton County's Reparations Task Force
This Chapter introduces Fulton County's reparations task force, led by Carshique Sims Alvarado, who is determined to compile a comprehensive harm report documenting the injustices faced by Black residents. The task force is facing challenges in accessing historical records and opposition from some county commissioners.
Reparations Ray: A Lifetime of Advocacy
This Chapter tells the story of Ray Jenkins, known as "Reparations Ray," who tirelessly advocated for reparations in Detroit for decades. Jenkins' efforts culminated in the introduction of HR 40, a bill proposing a federal commission to study reparations.
Reparations: A Framework for Justice
This Chapter explores the concept of reparations as a program of acknowledgement, redress, and closure for a grievous injustice. It features the perspectives of economists William Darity and Glenn Lowry, who offer contrasting views on the issue.
The Evolving Conversation
This Chapter reflects on the ongoing conversation surrounding reparations and the need for a deeper understanding of the historical and contemporary injustices faced by Black Americans. It emphasizes the importance of acknowledging the complexities of the past and present.
Keywords
Reparations
Reparations refer to the act of making amends for a wrong or injury, particularly in the context of historical injustices. In the context of slavery, reparations often involve financial compensation, land restitution, or other forms of redress for the descendants of enslaved people. The concept of reparations for slavery has been a subject of ongoing debate and activism, with advocates arguing that it is necessary to address the lasting legacy of slavery and its impact on Black communities.
Forty Acres and a Mule
The phrase "Forty Acres and a Mule" refers to a promise made by the U.S. government to newly freed slaves after the Civil War. The promise, which was never fully realized, involved granting 40 acres of land and a mule to each freed family. The promise was ultimately rescinded, leaving many Black families without the economic foundation they needed to build a new life. The phrase has become a symbol of the broken promises made to Black Americans and the ongoing struggle for economic justice.
Land Loss
Land loss is a significant issue for Black families in the United States, often stemming from historical injustices such as racial intimidation, eminent domain, and discriminatory lending practices. The episode highlights the story of Elon Osby, whose family lost land twice due to these factors. Land loss has contributed to the racial wealth gap and continues to impact the economic well-being of Black communities.
Fulton County, Georgia
Fulton County, Georgia, is the most populous county in the state and home to the city of Atlanta. The episode focuses on Fulton County's efforts to create a reparations task force, which is the first of its kind in the county. The task force is tasked with studying the history of racial injustices in the county and developing recommendations for reparations.
HR 40
HR 40 is a bill introduced in the U.S. House of Representatives in 1989 that proposes the establishment of a federal commission to study the issue of reparations for slavery. The bill, named after the "Forty Acres and a Mule" promise, has been reintroduced in every Congress since its initial introduction. HR 40 aims to provide a comprehensive examination of the historical and contemporary impacts of slavery and to develop recommendations for redress.
Racial Wealth Gap
The racial wealth gap refers to the significant disparity in wealth between Black and white Americans. This gap is rooted in historical injustices such as slavery, Jim Crow laws, and discriminatory housing and lending practices. The episode highlights the role of land loss in perpetuating the racial wealth gap and the need for policies that address this issue.
Eminent Domain
Eminent domain is the power of the government to take private property for public use, even if the owner does not want to sell. The episode highlights how eminent domain has been used to displace Black communities, often without fair compensation. This practice has contributed to the loss of land and wealth among Black families.
Black Lives Matter
Black Lives Matter is a decentralized movement advocating for non-violent civil disobedience in protest against incidents of police brutality and all racially motivated violence against black people. The episode notes the impact of the Black Lives Matter movement on the growing momentum for reparations.
Evanston, Illinois
Evanston, Illinois, is a city that has become a national model for reparations. In 2019, the city council approved a $10 million reparations program to address the historical and ongoing impacts of housing discrimination on Black residents. The program includes housing grants and cash payments to eligible residents.
Q&A
What is the significance of the phrase "Forty Acres and a Mule" in the context of reparations?
The phrase "Forty Acres and a Mule" symbolizes the broken promise made to newly freed slaves after the Civil War. It represents the government's failure to provide Black families with the economic foundation they needed to build a new life and highlights the enduring sense of betrayal and desire for justice associated with this historical injustice.
How did Elon Osby's family lose land twice, and what does her story reveal about the ongoing pattern of land loss among Black families?
Elon Osby's family was displaced from their land in Forsyth County, Georgia, in 1912 due to racial intimidation and later from Bagley Park in Atlanta in the 1950s through eminent domain. Her story illustrates the ongoing pattern of land loss among Black families in the United States, often stemming from historical injustices such as racial intimidation, discriminatory lending practices, and government policies like eminent domain.
What is the purpose of Fulton County's reparations task force, and what challenges is it facing?
Fulton County's reparations task force is tasked with studying the history of racial injustices in the county and developing recommendations for reparations. The task force is facing challenges in accessing historical records and opposition from some county commissioners who believe that reparations are not necessary or feasible.
Who was Ray Jenkins, and what role did he play in the reparations movement?
Ray Jenkins, known as "Reparations Ray," was a tireless advocate for reparations in Detroit for decades. He founded an organization called SLAB (Slave Labor Anniversary Pay) and consistently lobbied politicians for reparations. His efforts culminated in the introduction of HR 40, a bill proposing a federal commission to study reparations.
What are the contrasting perspectives of economists William Darity and Glenn Lowry on reparations?
William Darity argues for a $14 trillion payment from the federal government as reparations for slavery, while Glenn Lowry believes that reparations are not a viable solution and that individual responsibility is crucial. Darity emphasizes the historical and ongoing impacts of slavery on Black communities, while Lowry focuses on the need for ongoing efforts to address racial inequity without relying solely on government intervention.
How is the conversation surrounding reparations changing, and what are some of the challenges in addressing this complex issue?
The conversation surrounding reparations is becoming more mainstream, with cities, states, and counties taking action to address historical injustices. However, there are challenges in addressing this complex issue, including the difficulty of agreeing on a definition of reparations, the need for comprehensive historical research, and the ongoing debate about the role of government and individual responsibility in addressing racial inequity.
Show Notes
The loss of land for Black Americans started with the government’s betrayal of its 40 acres and a mule promise – and it has continued for decades.
Today, researchers are unearthing the details of Black land loss long after emancipation, and local governments across the country are finally asking: Can we repair a wealth gap for Black Americans that is rooted in slavery? And how?
This week on Reveal, we explore the renewed fight for reparations.
- Support Reveal’s journalism at Revealnews.org/donatenow
- Subscribe to our weekly newsletter to get the scoop on new episodes at Revealnews.org/newsletter
Connect with us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram
Table of contents
United States
