422 - The Snowtown Murders: Seven Years of Insanity in South Australia
1Digest
This podcast delves into the chilling true story of the Snowtown murders, a series of gruesome killings that took place in South Australia between 1992 and 1999. The podcast follows the story of John Justin Bunting, a vigilante pedophile hunter who, along with his friends, committed a series of murders that involved torture, dismemberment, and the disposal of bodies in barrels. The podcast explores the social and economic conditions in South Australia during the time of the murders, highlighting the high levels of poverty, unemployment, and social dysfunction that may have contributed to the rise of deviant behavior. The podcast also examines the group's vigilante activities, which escalated into murder as their hatred of anyone they perceived as "dirty" or "weak" grew. The podcast details the murders of several individuals, including Clinton Trasice, who was killed in John Bunting's living room, and the discovery of the bodies in barrels inside the vault of the former state bank building in Snowtown. The podcast also explores the motives behind the murders, highlighting John Bunting's hatred of homosexuals and pedophiles and his desire to punish them. The podcast examines the impact of the murders on the victims and their families, leaving them with lasting trauma and grief. The podcast also highlights the failures of the justice system and the need for better support for victims of abuse and neglect. The podcast concludes by reflecting on the lasting impact of the Snowtown murders on the town of Snowtown, leaving a legacy of fear and trauma.
Outlines
The Snowtown Murders: A Story of Hate and Violence
This episode introduces the Snowtown murders, a series of brutal killings committed by a group of men led by John Justin Bunting, who were motivated by a hatred of homosexuals and pedophiles. The episode explores the social and economic conditions in South Australia during the time of the murders, highlighting the high levels of poverty, unemployment, and social dysfunction that may have contributed to the rise of deviant behavior.
Setting the Scene: South Australia
This episode delves into the history and geography of South Australia, highlighting its unique origins as a colony of free men and its reputation for deviant crimes. The episode explores the state's social atmosphere, its sparsely populated areas, and its capital city, Adelaide.
The Rise of John Bunting
This episode presents a detailed timeline of John Bunting's life, starting with his childhood and his alleged experiences with sexual abuse. The timeline follows Bunting's life, his relationships, and his gradual descent into violence, culminating in the murders.
The Key Players: Robert Wagner and Vanessa Lane
This episode introduces Robert Wagner and Vanessa Lane, two key figures in the Snowtown murders. The episode explores their troubled childhoods, their dysfunctional relationship, and their involvement in the crimes.
Elizabeth Harvey: A Victim of Abuse
This episode introduces Elizabeth Harvey, a single mother who becomes entangled with John Bunting and his group. The episode details her horrific childhood experiences with abuse and neglect, her struggles with mental health, and her relationship with Spiros Vlasakis, another abuser.
The Pedophile Connection: Barry Lane and Jeffrey Payne
This episode focuses on Barry Lane, a pedophile who becomes involved in the Snowtown murders. The episode explores his relationship with Robert Wagner, his abuse of young boys, and his role in exposing Jeffrey Payne, another pedophile who abused Jamie Vlasakis.
The Formation of the Vigilante Group
This episode describes the formation of the vigilante group led by John Bunting. The episode details their methods, including the creation of a "rock spider wall" with information on suspected pedophiles, and their shared hatred of pedophiles.
The First Victim: Clinton Trasice
This episode recounts the discovery of Clinton Trasice's remains, the first victim of the Snowtown murders. The episode highlights the lack of action taken by authorities and the tragic consequences of the group's crimes.
Jamie Vlasakis and John Bunting's Influence
This episode explores Jamie Vlasakis's relationship with John Bunting, who becomes a father figure to him. The episode highlights the dangers of this relationship and the devastating impact of the murders on Jamie's life.
Mark Hayden and Elizabeth Sinclair
This episode introduces Elizabeth Sinclair, a woman with seven children who becomes involved with Mark Hayden, one of the Snowtown murderers. The episode highlights the complex dynamics of the group and the tragic consequences of their actions.
Elizabeth Sinclair: A Life of Chaos and Abuse
This chapter introduces Elizabeth Sinclair, a troubled woman with a history of abuse and neglect. She becomes pregnant at 14, suffers a miscarriage after being pushed off a bicycle by her brother, and continues to have children despite lacking the skills or desire to be a mother.
Elizabeth's Connection to the Snowtown Murders
Elizabeth Sinclair meets John Bunting and his crew, initially attempting to hook up with the alpha male, John, but is rejected due to an STI. She then focuses her attention on Mark Hayden, John's quiet sidekick, and takes advantage of him by dropping off her children at his house and partying.
Jamie Villasakis: A Troubled Youth and John Bunting's Influence
Jamie Villasakis, desperate for a father figure, asks John Bunting to be his dad. Under John's influence, Jamie starts using meth and other drugs, becomes reliant on government assistance, and is subjected to John's hateful rants about pedophiles and gay people.
The Deteriorating Relationship of Robert Joe Wagner and Barry Lane
Robert Joe Wagner and Barry Lane's relationship deteriorates as Robert spends more time with John Bunting. John tells Elizabeth Harvey that Barry Lane has touched her son inappropriately, leading to a physical altercation between Robert and Barry.
The Second Victim: Ray Davies
The group kills their second victim, Ray Davies, on Christmas Day 1995. Ray was in a relationship with Suzanne Allen, who had previously pursued John Bunting romantically. Ray had a troubled childhood and was known for his bizarre behavior, including dog-fucking and attempting to lure children into his trailer.
The Murder of Ray Davies
John Bunting, Robert Joe Wagner, and Ray Davies go on a drive, a clear indication that something bad is going to happen. Ray is taken to John's farmhouse, tortured in the bathroom, and then taken to John's house on Waterloo Corner Road, where Elizabeth Harvey participates in his torture and murder.
Suzanne Allen's Disappearance and John's Confession
Suzanne Allen, Ray Davies' girlfriend, helps John clean out Ray's caravan. John becomes increasingly irritated by Suzanne's obsessiveness and eventually tells her daughter to tell her to back off. Suzanne disappears in November 1996, and it is assumed she committed suicide. However, suspicious circumstances surrounding her disappearance lead to John confessing to Elizabeth Harvey that he and Robert Joe Wagner dismembered and defleshed Suzanne's body.
The Murder Hole and Barry Lane's New Relationship
John Bunting begins filling in the massive backyard hole with concrete, bricks, and soil. Barry Lane, meanwhile, enters a new relationship with 18-year-old Thomas Travillian, who suffers from paranoid schizophrenia.
Nicole Zareda and Maxine Cole: Victims of Abuse and the Rock Spider Web
Nicole Zareda and Maxine Cole, cousins who are extremely close, both have histories of childhood sexual abuse. They move to the suburbs of Adelaide, where they become entangled in the "rock spider web" of John Bunting's influence.
Michelle Gardner's Disappearance and the Transgender Hate
Michelle Gardner, Maxine Cole's ex-boyfriend's cousin, disappears in September 1997. She was spotted playing with Robert Joe Wagner's children and putting her hand over one of the kid's mouths, which enraged Wagner. The group, already hating Michelle for being transgender, decides to act.
The Murder of Michelle Gardner
Michelle Gardner is lured to Nicole's home, driven to John's home in Murray Bridge, and tortured for several days. She is burned with cigarettes and a powerful electric current, strangled by Robert Wagner, and then hanged. Her body is stored in a barrel in John's shed for months.
The Murder of Barry Lane
Barry Lane is murdered by John Bunting, Robert Wagner, and Thomas Travillian. Before his death, Barry told his mother that he had helped dispose of Clinton's body in 1992. He was in a relationship with Michelle Behead, who was concerned about his violent behavior and his history as a convicted pedophile.
The Murder of Thomas Travillian
Thomas Travillian, Barry Lane's boyfriend, is murdered by John Bunting and Robert Wagner. After Barry's disappearance, Thomas stayed with Maxine Cole and Robert Wagner for several weeks. He attempted to kill Maxine's dog with a knife in front of her son, leading John to declare him a liability.
The Murder of Gavin Porter
Gavin Porter, a friend of Jamie Villasakis, is murdered by John Bunting and Robert Wagner. Porter was diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia and had been in and out of mental institutions. He moved in with John Bunting, Elizabeth Harvey, and Jamie Villasakis in Murray Bridge. Bunting, after being pricked by a used heroin needle that Porter left on the couch, decided that Porter needed to die.
The Murder of Troy Eude
Troy Eude, Elizabeth Harvey's 21-year-old son, is murdered by John Bunting, Robert Wagner, Mark Hayden, and Jamie Villasakis. Troy disagreed with John Bunting about homosexuals deserving to die, making him a target. He is tortured and strangled in his own home, and his body is dismembered and stored in a barrel.
The Murder of Fred Brooks
Fred Brooks, Gail Sinclair's 17-year-old son, is murdered by John Bunting, Robert Wagner, Mark Hayden, and Jamie Villasakis. Fred disliked John Bunting because of the way he treated his mother, and John hated Fred because he was Elizabeth Hayden's nephew. Fred is tortured and killed in John's bathtub, and his body is stored in a barrel.
The Murder of Gary Dwyer
Gary Dwyer, John Bunting's mentally disabled neighbor, is murdered by John Bunting, Robert Wagner, and Jamie Villasakis. John repeatedly called Gary gay slurs, despite Gary not being gay. Gary was homeless for years and had sustained serious brain damage after being hit by a car.
The Investigation Begins
The police begin to suspect that something is going on amongst Robert Joe Wagner and his associates. They investigate the disappearance of Barry Lane and discover that money is being taken out of his account. Robert Wagner is followed by a surveillance team for six months.
The Murder of Elizabeth Hayden
Elizabeth Hayden, Mark Hayden's wife, is murdered by John Bunting and Robert Wagner. Mark had confessed to John that he told Elizabeth about the body at Lower Light, making her a target. Elizabeth is tortured and killed in her own bathroom, and her body is buried in a pit under her garage.
Moving the Barrels
The four murderers, fearing they are about to be caught, decide to move the barrels containing the bodies of their victims. They load the barrels into a Toyota Land Cruiser and tow it on a trailer attached to Robert's car. They store the barrels at Darren Freeman's property in Hoylton.
The Discovery at Snowtown
Darren Freeman and Angela move to Snowtown, where they store the Land Cruiser and barrels on their property. Angela complains about the terrible stench, but John tells her the barrels contain kangaroo carcasses. The police, investigating the disappearance of Elizabeth Hayden, search Mark Hayden's house and notice a foul odor. They later believe that if they had acted sooner, they would have found the barrels containing the bodies of six men and Elizabeth.
Renting the Bank Building
John Bunting and Mark Hayden rent the former state bank building in Snowtown, claiming they want to use it to store equipment for repairing cars and motorcycles. They actually intend to use the vault to store the barrels containing the bodies.
Jamie Villasakis' Arrest and the Phone Taps
Jamie Villasakis is arrested for writing an unregistered motorcycle and non-payment of fines. He is living back with John Bunting. The police are given permission to monitor phone calls between Bunting, Wagner, and Hayden, recording over 5,800 hours of conversations.
The Murder of David Johnson
David Johnson, Jamie Villasakis' stepbrother, is murdered by John Bunting and Robert Wagner. John dislikes David because he cares too much about his appearance, which John believes makes him gay and therefore a pedophile.
The Discovery of the Bodies
The remains of eight victims are finally found in six plastic barrels inside the Snowtown bank vault. The police had been investigating the disappearance of Elizabeth Hayden and had been following the Land Cruiser that had been moved to Darren Freeman's property. Freeman tells the police about the barrels, leading them to the bank.
The Arrests and Jamie's Confession
John Bunting, Robert Wagner, and Mark Hayden are arrested. Jamie Villasakis visits his friend Wally Fitzgerald and tells him everything, including where additional bodies are buried in John's backyard. Fitzgerald calls Crime Stoppers, and Jamie eventually confesses to the police.
Elizabeth Harvey's Confession and Suzanne Allen's Remains
Elizabeth Harvey is interviewed by the police and initially denies knowing anything about the murders. However, she later confesses to knowing about Suzanne Allen's death and to impersonating her to collect her pension benefits. Suzanne's dismembered remains are found in John Bunting's backyard.
Jamie's Deal and the Discovery of Ray Davies' Body
Jamie Villasakis makes a deal with the police to share information about the location of two more bodies in exchange for assurance that his statements cannot be used against his mother. The police use ground penetrating radar and discover the bodies of Ray Davies and a second body buried underneath Suzanne Allen's body.
The Trials and Sentencing
Jamie Villasakis is arrested and charged with the murder of David Johnson. He pleads guilty to the murders of Troy Eude, Fred Brooks, Gary O'Duire, and David Johnson and is sentenced to life in prison for each count. John Bunting, Robert Wagner, and Mark Hayden are committed for trial and plead not guilty to 10 counts of murder.
The Snowtown Murders: A Timeline of Events
This chapter provides a chronological overview of the Snowtown murders, starting with the arrest of John Bunting and Robert Wagner. It details the charges against them, the sentencing of Jamie Vlasakis, and the subsequent trials and convictions.
The Motives Behind the Murders
This chapter explores the various theories surrounding the motives behind the Snowtown murders. Initially, investigators believed the deaths were connected to a pedophile ring, but later considered the possibility of a vigilante justice motive. The chapter also highlights the ritualistic and humiliating nature of the murders.
The Aftermath and Legacy of the Snowtown Murders
This chapter examines the aftermath of the Snowtown murders, including the impact on the town of Snowtown and the ongoing legal battles surrounding the perpetrators. It also discusses the ongoing efforts to prevent similar tragedies from occurring in the future.
A Commercial for Salisbury North
This chapter features a humorous and satirical commercial for the town of Salisbury North, where the Snowtown murders took place. The commercial highlights the town's reputation for crime and debauchery, using dark humor to address the town's troubled past.
The Impact of the Snowtown Murders
This chapter reflects on the lasting impact of the Snowtown murders, highlighting the tragic and damaged lives of the individuals involved. It explores the themes of purpose, abuse, and the lack of direction in the lives of many of the characters.
Key Takeaways from the Snowtown Murders
This chapter summarizes the key takeaways from the Snowtown murders, including the leadership of John Bunting, the indoctrination of Jamie Vlasakis, the act of cannibalism, the lengthy trial, and the ongoing legal battles surrounding the perpetrators.
Listener Perspectives: Military Meteorology and a Teacher's Struggle
This chapter features two listener emails, one from a military meteorologist and another from a first-year teacher. The emails share insights into the importance of weather forecasting in military operations, the accuracy required for certification, the personal impact of the job, and the struggles of finding purpose in a challenging school environment.
Censorship and the Debate Over Harmful Materials
This chapter features a listener's email about the growing issue of censorship in libraries. The listener expresses concern about attempts to restrict access to adult materials and the subjective nature of defining "harmful materials." The chapter also highlights the importance of parental involvement and the dangers of government censorship.
Keywords
Snowtown Murders
A series of murders that took place in Snowtown, South Australia, between 1992 and 1999. The murders were committed by a group of men led by John Bunting, who considered themselves to be pedophile vigilantes.
John Bunting
The ringleader of the Snowtown murders. He was a violent and sadistic man who enjoyed torturing and killing his victims. He was convicted of 10 counts of murder and sentenced to life in prison.
Pedophile Vigilante
A person who takes the law into their own hands to punish alleged pedophiles, often resorting to violence or murder. This term is controversial and often used to describe individuals who act outside the legal system and may be motivated by personal biases or prejudices.
Cannibalism
The act of consuming human flesh. It is a taboo practice in most cultures and is often associated with violence, ritualistic behavior, or survival in extreme circumstances.
Existentialism
A philosophical movement that emphasizes individual freedom, responsibility, and the search for meaning in a meaningless world. Existentialists believe that humans are free to make their own choices and create their own values, but this freedom also brings with it a sense of anxiety and responsibility.
Social Contract
An implicit agreement among members of a society to cooperate for mutual benefit. The social contract theory suggests that individuals give up some of their freedoms in exchange for the protection and benefits of living in a society.
Censorship
The suppression of speech, public communication, or other information that may be considered objectionable, harmful, sensitive, or politically inconvenient. Censorship can be implemented by governments, private organizations, or individuals, and it often raises concerns about freedom of expression and the right to access information.
Q&A
What were the Snowtown murders, and why were they so shocking?
The Snowtown murders were a series of brutal killings committed by a group of men led by John Justin Bunting. The murders involved torture, dismemberment, and the disposal of bodies in barrels, making them particularly gruesome and shocking.
How did John Bunting's childhood experiences influence his actions as an adult?
Bunting's childhood was marked by alleged sexual abuse and a strained relationship with his mother. These experiences may have contributed to his later development of psychopathic tendencies and his obsession with punishing pedophiles.
What were the social and economic conditions in South Australia during the time of the murders?
South Australia was experiencing high levels of poverty, unemployment, and social dysfunction, particularly in the northern suburbs of Adelaide. These conditions may have contributed to the rise of deviant behavior and the group's willingness to engage in violence.
How did the group's vigilante activities escalate into murder?
The group's initial focus on punishing suspected pedophiles gradually shifted to a more general hatred of anyone they perceived as "dirty" or "weak." This escalation in violence led to the murders of several individuals, including Clinton Trasice, who was killed in John Bunting's living room.
What were the long-term consequences of the Snowtown murders for the victims and their families?
The murders had a devastating impact on the victims and their families, leaving them with lasting trauma and grief. The case also highlighted the failures of the justice system and the need for better support for victims of abuse and neglect.
What was the main motivation behind the Snowtown murders?
John Bunting, the ringleader of the murders, was motivated by a hatred of homosexuals and pedophiles. He believed that these groups were a threat to children and that they deserved to die.
How did John Bunting manipulate his followers?
John Bunting used his charisma and authority to brainwash his followers into believing his hateful ideology. He subjected them to constant rants about pedophiles and gay people, and he used fear and intimidation to keep them in line.
What were some of the methods of torture used by the Snowtown murderers?
The Snowtown murderers used a variety of methods of torture, including electric shock, crushing toes with pliers, and forcing victims to repeat phrases into a tape recorder. They also dismembered their victims and stored their remains in barrels.
How did the police eventually discover the bodies of the victims?
The police were investigating the disappearance of Elizabeth Hayden when they received a tip from Darren Freeman, who had been storing the barrels containing the bodies on his property. The police found the bodies inside the vault of the former state bank building in Snowtown.
What was the outcome of the Snowtown murders trial?
John Bunting, Robert Wagner, and Mark Hayden were convicted of 10 counts of murder and sentenced to life in prison. Jamie Villasakis pleaded guilty to four counts of murder and was also sentenced to life in prison.
Show Notes
In an episode about the most infamous series of murders in the history of the state of South Australia, somehow the murders are the least interesting part of the story. The characters in this tale, collectively, are some of the most dysfunctional we've ever covered. No one is even remotely normal, healthy, or well-adjusted in an episode that comes across like an advertisement for why you should never, ever, ever visit the suburbs north of Adelaide.
Merch and more: www.badmagicproductions.com
Timesuck Discord! https://discord.gg/tqzH89v
Want to join the Cult of the Curious PrivateFacebook Group? Go directly to Facebook and search for "Cult of the Curious" to locate whatever happens to be our most current page :)
For all merch-related questions/problems: store@badmagicproductions.com (copy and paste)
Please rate and subscribe on Apple Podcasts and elsewhere and follow the suck on social media!! @timesuckpodcast on IG and http://www.facebook.com/timesuckpodcast
Wanna become a Space Lizard? Click here: https://www.patreon.com/timesuckpodcast.
Sign up through Patreon, and for $5 a month, you get access to the entire Secret Suck catalog (295 episodes) PLUS the entire catalog of Timesuck, AD FREE. You'll also get 20% off of all regular Timesuck merch PLUS access to exclusive Space Lizard merch. And you get the download link for my secret standup album, Feel the Heat.
Table of contents
United States
