492 - The Moors Murders
1Digest
This podcast delves into the disturbing lives and crimes of Ian Brady and Myra Hindley, the perpetrators of the infamous Moors murders. It meticulously traces their early lives, marked by difficult childhoods and developing criminal tendencies. The narrative highlights how Ian Brady, exhibiting sociopathic traits and a fascination with Nazism, systematically indoctrinated Myra Hindley into his nihilistic worldview. Their relationship escalated from infatuation to a shared descent into cruelty, culminating in the abduction, rape, torture, and murder of at least five children between 1963 and 1965. The podcast details the planning of these heinous crimes, the murders of Pauline Reed, John Kilbride, Leslie Ann Downey, and Edward Evans, and the eventual involvement of David Smith, whose testimony proved crucial. The investigation, marked by the discovery of key evidence like the torture tape and items from suitcases, led to their arrests and convictions. The episode also covers their prison lives, subsequent confessions, the ongoing search for Keith Bennett's remains, and their eventual deaths, leaving behind a legacy of profound evil and unanswered questions.
Outlines
Introduction to Ian Brady and Myra Hindley
The podcast introduces Ian Brady and Myra Hindley, the perpetrators of the infamous Moors murders. It highlights their brutal crimes against children and sets the stage for a deep dive into their lives and the events leading up to their capture.
Host Introduction and Announcements
The host, Michael McDonald, welcomes listeners to "Time Suck" and "Cult of the Curious." He makes announcements, including details about the "Crime Wave Cruise" in February 2027, offering discounts and exclusive access.
Ian Brady's Early Life and Criminal Beginnings
This chapter details Ian Brady's birth in Scotland, his early childhood, and his developing behaviors, including petty crimes and cruelty to animals. His teenage years were marked by further petty crimes, an interest in Nazism, and early sexual sadism. His young adulthood saw continued criminality, employment struggles, and hardening resolve.
Myra Hindley's Early Life and Developing Personality
The podcast shifts focus to Myra Hindley's upbringing in Manchester, describing her difficult childhood, strained family relationships, and early experiences with violence and emotional neglect. Her teenage years involved misbehavior, developing a tough personality, and early athletic and academic talents. Her childhood and teenage petty crimes and early relationships are also detailed.
The Meeting and Developing Relationship of Ian Brady and Myra Hindley
This chapter focuses on the pivotal moment when Myra Hindley and Ian Brady meet, Myra's intense infatuation, and her escalating obsession with Ian. Their early relationship involved shared dates and the development of their shared beliefs, with Ian influencing Myra's nihilistic views and fascination with Nazism. Myra became fully indoctrinated into Ian's belief system, leading to their shared descent into cruelty and violence.
Manipulation, Complicity, and the "Perfect Murder" Plan
This chapter explores Ian Brady's manipulation of Myra Hindley, including drugging her and threatening her family, highlighting her willing participation in their increasingly dark and violent activities. Ian details his plan for a "perfect murder" involving the abduction, rape, and murder of a child, with Myra aware of his serious intentions and choosing to help him despite her fear.
Fear, Failed Escape, and Domestic Abuse
Myra writes a letter to her friend indicating her fear, and attempts to escape Ian by applying for a job in Germany, but his threats prevent her. The narrator questions Myra's choices, and the transcript details Ian's physical and sexual abuse of Myra.
Legal Troubles, Disturbing Habits, and Early Crimes
Ian and Myra face legal charges after a motorcycle accident. Ian begins spending more nights at Myra's, and they engage in disturbing activities, including discussing and filming sexual acts with children. The narrative also shifts to David Smith's troubled childhood, marked by abuse and neglect, and his early criminal behavior, including assaults and theft.
Planning and Executing the First Murders
Ian and Myra actively scout for victims, creating a detailed "master list" for their criminal activities and securing a van. They finalize plans for their first abduction and murder of 16-year-old Pauline Reed on Saddleworth Moor. They then target and murder 12-year-old John Kilbride, detailing their methodical planning and disposal of evidence.
The Murder of Keith Bennett and Recruitment of David Smith
Ian and Myra abduct and murder 12-year-old Keith Bennett on Saddleworth Moor. Following this, they attempt to involve David Smith in their crimes and befriend a 12-year-old girl, Pat Hodges.
David Smith's Legal Troubles and Exploitation
David Smith faces another assault charge, and his daughter dies. Ian and Myra exploit David's grief to involve him in their plans, manipulating him and testing his willingness to commit murder.
The Murder of Edward Evans and David Smith's Testimony
Ian and Myra abduct and murder 17-year-old Edward Evans. David Smith is present and witnesses the brutal attack, leading to his decision to go to the police. David later testifies about the murder and makes a deal with a newspaper for financial gain.
Arrests, Evidence Disposal, and Legal Proceedings
Ian and Myra are arrested following David's confession. Myra attempts to destroy incriminating evidence, but police find crucial items linking them to the crimes. Ian is charged with murder, while Myra is charged as an accessory, and investigations into other disappearances continue.
Prison Letters, Interrogations, and Discovery of Evidence
Ian writes to Myra from prison, and both are interrogated. The investigation uncovers more evidence, including John Kilbride's name in Ian's notebook. Police discover incriminating evidence, including luggage tickets and suitcases, at Myra's house and Victoria Station.
Pandora's Box: Suitcase Contents and the Torture Tape
Opening the suitcases revealed pornographic materials and disturbing photos of Leslie Ann Downey. Police found an audio tape of Myra and Ian torturing Leslie Ann, confirming their role in her disappearance and likely murder.
Discovery of Bodies and Further Interrogations
A police officer discovers Leslie Ann Downey's decomposed body on the moors. Ian and Myra are questioned again and charged with Leslie Ann's murder. A search based on a photo leads to the discovery of another body, potentially Keith Bennett or John Kilbride.
Questioning, Trial Preparations, and Verdicts
Ian is questioned about the John Kilbride case, and Myra attempts to blame David Smith. Myra and Ian face a committal hearing for multiple murders. The criminal trial begins, with Ian found guilty of three murders and Myra of two, receiving life sentences.
Prison Life, Escape Plans, and Shifting Dynamics
Over six years, Myra and Ian correspond using coded language. Ian goes on hunger strikes, while Myra rededicates herself to Catholicism and plans an escape with a prison guard, which is ultimately foiled.
Legal Battles, Confessions, and Public Admissions
Myra begins a legal battle for release, while Ian never applies for parole. In 1985, Ian confesses to killing Keith Bennett. In 1986, Myra makes a public confession, and Ian reveals Myra's greater role in the murders of Pauline Reed and Keith Bennett. Myra formally confesses to participating in all five murders.
Discovery of Pauline Reed's Body and Ian's Confession
Pauline Reed's body is found, and Ian makes a formal confession, agreeing to help police locate Keith Bennett's burial site, though the body is not recovered.
Ian's Hunger Strike and Myra's Death
Ian begins a hunger strike demanding the right to die. Myra Hindley dies of bronchial pneumonia at age 60, the longest-serving British woman in prison. Before her death, she revealed feelings of hate and accusations against Ian.
Search for Keith Bennett's Body Ends
Police formally give up their search for Keith Bennett's body. His mother passed away in 2012 without knowing his final resting place.
Ian's Appeal and Final Years
Ian appeals to be transferred back to jail, claiming he was lying about his mental illness to starve himself to death. He loses his appeal and dies in 2017 at Ashworth psychiatric hospital.
Ian Brady's Briefcases and Unanswered Questions
Before his death, Ian ordered two locked briefcases to be handed to his solicitor. Police sought a court order to open them for information about Keith Bennett's remains, but the application was denied.
Childhood Influences and Psychological Analysis
The podcast explores Ian Brady's childhood, noting a lack of abuse allegations, and questions if he was "born broken." Myra's abusive childhood is also discussed, but the podcast emphasizes these factors do not justify their crimes.
Myra and Ian's Ruthlessness and Conclusion
The podcast concludes that Myra was as ruthless as Ian, agreeing with Ian's assessment that she was in tune with him from the beginning.
Time Suck Top Five Takeaways
Key takeaways include Myra and Ian's relationship, the Moors Murders, the murder of Edward Evans, their life sentences, and recent developments in the search for Keith Bennett's remains.
Moors Murders Source Material and Credits
The podcast acknowledges the source material for the episode and thanks the production team, researchers, and moderators for their contributions.
Time Sucker Updates and Documentary Promotion
Updates include a promotion for an ultra-running documentary and a personal story about a mother's breast cancer diagnosis and mastectomy, with a humorous greeting card request.
Shout Out to a Husband and Corvette Owner
A listener requests a shout-out for her husband, Darius, who survived a serious car accident and is a dedicated Corvette enthusiast. The host humorously declines to give a personal shout-out due to time constraints.
Silly Update and Truck's Language
A father shares a humorous anecdote about his daughter scolding his truck for using "naughty language," leading to a discussion about the host's clean language.
Final Thoughts and Listener Advice
The host reflects on the importance of not succumbing to despair and urges listeners to be kind and get their lives together, referencing the dark themes discussed in the episode.
The Infamous Shit-Eating Contest
The host teases a graphic and disturbing story about a "shit-eating contest" but ultimately decides not to detail it, assuring listeners they've "dodged a bullet."
Keywords
Moors Murders
A series of child murders committed by Ian Brady and Myra Hindley in the Manchester area of England between 1963 and 1965. The crimes involved rape, torture, and murder, shocking the nation and leading to their notoriety.
Serial Killer
An individual who commits a series of murders, often with a psychological compulsion. Brady and Hindley are infamous examples in the UK.
Ian Brady
The male perpetrator of the Moors Murders. Known for his sadistic tendencies and manipulation, he indoctrinated his partner, Myra Hindley, into his criminal activities.
Myra Hindley
The female perpetrator of the Moors Murders. Initially influenced by Ian Brady, she became a willing participant in the horrific crimes, earning the title "most evil woman in Britain."
Saddleworth Moor
A desolate area of moorland in Greater Manchester, England, where Ian Brady and Myra Hindley buried their victims. The moors became a focal point of the search for the missing children.
Indoctrination
The process of teaching someone to accept a set of beliefs uncritically. Ian Brady systematically indoctrinated Myra Hindley into his nihilistic and violent worldview, leading to her complicity in his crimes.
Sociopathy
A personality disorder characterized by a lack of empathy, disregard for social norms, and manipulative behavior. Ian Brady exhibited strong sociopathic traits, influencing Myra Hindley and contributing to their horrific crimes.
Sadism
The tendency to derive pleasure, especially sexual gratification, from inflicting pain, suffering, or humiliation on others. Both Ian Brady and Myra Hindley displayed sadistic tendencies, which were central to the Moors murders.
Child Abduction
The unlawful taking away of a child against their will. This was a key element in the crimes committed by Brady and Hindley.
Torture Tape
An audio recording made by Ian Brady and Myra Hindley documenting the torture of their victim, Leslie Ann Downey. Listening to this tape deeply affected the investigators and was key evidence in the trial.
Q&A
Who were Ian Brady and Myra Hindley?
Ian Brady and Myra Hindley were a British couple responsible for the Moors murders, a series of child murders committed between 1963 and 1965. They targeted children in the Manchester area, subjecting them to rape, torture, and murder.
What were the key psychological factors that contributed to their crimes?
Ian Brady exhibited strong sociopathic traits and a fascination with Nazism, espousing a belief in relativist morality and a lack of empathy. He systematically indoctrinated Myra Hindley into his violent worldview, exploiting her difficult childhood and desire for acceptance.
How did Ian Brady influence Myra Hindley?
Ian Brady exerted a significant influence over Myra Hindley, gradually indoctrinating her into his nihilistic and violent beliefs. He manipulated her, shared his disturbing fantasies, and encouraged her to suppress her emotions and disregard consequences, leading to her willing participation in their crimes.
What was the nature of the Moors murders?
The Moors murders involved the abduction, rape, torture, and murder of at least five children. The crimes were characterized by extreme brutality and sadism, with the victims often buried in shallow graves on Saddleworth Moor.
How did the police eventually apprehend Ian Brady and Myra Hindley?
The investigation gained momentum after David Smith, who had been coerced into witnessing and assisting in the murder of Edward Evans, went to the police. Evidence found at Myra Hindley's house, including Ian Brady's wallet with his "master list," and later confessions and discoveries on Saddleworth Moor, led to their convictions.
What was the significance of Ian Brady's "master list"?
The "master list" was a detailed plan created by Ian Brady, outlining procedures for various criminal activities, including theft and murder. It was a testament to his meticulous planning and desire for control.
What were the outcomes of the trial for Ian Brady and Myra Hindley?
Ian Brady was found guilty of three murders and sentenced to life imprisonment. Myra Hindley was found guilty of two murders and harboring Ian, receiving two concurrent life terms plus seven years.
Did Ian Brady and Myra Hindley ever confess to all their crimes?
Yes, over time, both Ian Brady and Myra Hindley made confessions. Myra eventually confessed to participating in all five murders, though she attempted to minimize her direct involvement. Ian also confessed to killing Keith Bennett and revealed Myra's greater role in other murders.
What happened to Keith Bennett's remains?
Despite confessions and searches, Keith Bennett's body has never been officially recovered. His mother passed away without knowing where her son was buried.
What psychological factors might have contributed to Ian Brady and Myra Hindley's actions?
The podcast explores Ian Brady's childhood, noting a lack of abuse allegations, and questions if he was "born broken." Myra Hindley had a physically abusive childhood. However, the podcast emphasizes that these factors do not justify their horrific crimes.
Show Notes
From 1963 to 1965, Ian Brady and Myra Hindley carried out one of the most disturbing crime sprees in British history, abducting, torturing, and murdering children in and around Manchester before burying them out on the bleak, desolate moors. We break down the psychology, partnership, and pure moral rot behind the Moors Murders—and examine how two people fed each other’s darkness until it consumed innocent lives and horrified an entire nation.
Merch and more: www.badmagicproductions.com
Timesuck Discord! https://discord.gg/tqzH89v
Want to join the Cult of the Curious PrivateFacebook Group? Go directly to Facebook and search for "Cult of the Curious" to locate whatever happens to be our most current page :)
For all merch-related questions/problems: store@badmagicproductions.com (copy and paste)
Please rate and subscribe on Apple Podcasts and elsewhere and follow the suck on social media!! @timesuckpodcast on IG and http://www.facebook.com/timesuckpodcast
Wanna become a Space Lizard? Click here: https://www.patreon.com/timesuckpodcast.
Sign up through Patreon, and for $5 a month, you get access to the entire Secret Suck catalog (295 episodes) PLUS the entire catalog of Timesuck, AD FREE. You'll also get 20% off of all regular Timesuck merch PLUS access to exclusive Space Lizard merch.
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
Table of contents
United States
