#774: Learnings from 1,000+ Near-Death Experiences — Dr. Bruce Greyson, University of Virginia

Update: 2024-10-22

Digest

This podcast episode features a conversation with Bruce Grayson, MD, a psychiatrist who has dedicated his career to studying near-death experiences (NDEs). Grayson recounts his journey into NDE research, starting with a pivotal experience during his internship where a seemingly unconscious patient described a conversation with her roommate, including details about a stain on his tie. This sparked Grayson's interest in the phenomenon, leading him to develop the NDE scale, a tool used to assess the common features of NDEs and distinguish between genuine experiences and false positives. Grayson shares numerous case studies, including a patient who encountered his deceased nurse in an NDE, complete with details about a red MGB the nurse had recently crashed, and another patient who witnessed a surgeon flapping his arms during surgery, a detail later corroborated by the surgeon himself. These cases highlight the difficulty of explaining such experiences through wishful thinking alone. Grayson addresses common skeptical explanations for NDEs, such as lack of oxygen or drug-induced effects, arguing that these explanations are insufficient and that the evidence suggests a more complex phenomenon. He discusses the prevalence of NDEs, emphasizing that they are more common than people realize, and explores the consistency of NDEs across cultures and over time, suggesting that the core features remain consistent despite cultural differences in the metaphors used to describe them. Grayson delves into the challenges of finding a materialist explanation for NDEs, acknowledging the ongoing search for a physiological explanation but emphasizing the limitations of promissory materialism. He explores the common after-effects of NDEs, including increased altruism, a sense of connectedness, and a decrease in suicidal ideation, and discusses the similarities in NDE reports between children and adults. Grayson discusses the potential of using brain imaging to study NDEs, acknowledging the challenges of conducting such research in a controlled setting and critiquing existing studies that have attempted to measure brain activity during cardiac arrest, highlighting their methodological flaws. He explores the possibility of simulating NDEs, acknowledging the ethical challenges of inducing death in research subjects and discussing the use of psychedelic drugs as a potential tool for approximating certain aspects of NDEs, but emphasizing the limitations of this approach. Grayson shares a personal experience with Salvia Divinorum, a psychedelic compound that induced an out-of-body experience, and discusses the implications of this experience for understanding the mind-brain problem, suggesting that the mind may be something separate from the brain. He discusses his evolving understanding of the mind-brain problem, rejecting the idea that the mind is simply a product of the brain and proposing that the brain acts as a filter, selectively processing information from a larger, non-physical consciousness. Grayson discusses the potential career costs associated with studying near-death experiences, particularly in the past when the field was less accepted, and explains his motivation for persisting in this research, driven by intellectual curiosity and a desire to help those affected by NDEs. He describes a genomics study of twins who report experiencing extraordinary communication, exploring the potential genetic basis for such phenomena and suggesting that similar genetic studies could be conducted to investigate the genetic underpinnings of near-death experiences. Grayson discusses the challenges of studying adipotic experiences, a type of out-of-body experience where individuals report seeing things accurately from a different location, highlighting the difficulty of replicating such experiences in controlled settings and the need for large-scale studies. He discusses the open questions in the field of near-death experiences, particularly the mind-brain problem, and explores the phenomenon of terminal lucidity, where individuals with dementia regain lucidity before death, as further evidence for a mind separate from the brain. The conversation explores the concept of time in near-death experiences, with many experiencers reporting a sense of timelessness or that everything was happening at once, challenging the linear perception of time we experience in everyday life. The discussion shifts to a study on auditory hallucinations after NDEs, comparing the experiences of NDE survivors who reported hearing voices with those of schizophrenic patients. The voices heard by NDE survivors were generally perceived as helpful and positive, while those experienced by schizophrenics were often terrifying and disruptive. The conversation delves into researchers who combine open-mindedness with rigorous skepticism in their approach to NDEs, mentioning several researchers who are conducting research in various aspects of NDEs. The concept of the "irreducible mind" is introduced, which refers to the idea that the mind is not simply a product of brain activity but can exist independently. The book "Irreducible Mind" explores various phenomena, including NDEs, exceptional genius, and psychosomatic experiences, to support this concept. The speaker recommends his most recent book, "After," as a starting point for those interested in learning more about NDEs, describing it as accessible to a general audience and written in a clear and engaging style. He highlights three key points about NDEs: they are common, not associated with mental illness, and can have profound and lasting after-effects. He encourages listeners to explore his website, BruceGrayson.com, for more information.

Outlines