775: How to Motivate Younger Employees, with David Yeager
1Digest
This podcast explores the generational divide in motivation, challenging the notion that younger generations are inherently less driven. It introduces David Yeager's research on motivating youth, highlighting that complaints about younger generations are a historical pattern often rooted in adult perception. While young people are attuned to cultural and economic shifts, leaders face the \"mentor's dilemma\": balancing criticism for growth with support to avoid demotivation. The solution lies in \"wise feedback\" and a \"mentor mindset\" (high demand, high support), underpinned by psychological safety, which allows for risk-taking without fear of judgment. This contrasts with \"enforcer\" and \"protector\" mindsets. Wise feedback requires transparency about high standards and belief in potential. Crucially, young people need status and respect, fundamental needs that, when met, unlock motivation. This \"mentor mindset\" is applicable even beyond adolescence when individuals feel their status is threatened. The podcast concludes by emphasizing the power of \"do-overs\" and relationship repair for continuous growth.
Outlines
Understanding Generational Differences in Motivation
The podcast addresses the common perception of younger generations lacking motivation, introducing expert David Yeager and his research. It challenges this view by exploring historical patterns of intergenerational complaints and how youth are genuinely attuned to cultural and economic changes, which adults may misinterpret.
The Mentor's Dilemma and Wise Feedback
Leaders face the challenge of providing critical feedback without demotivating individuals. This \"mentor's dilemma\" is resolved through \"wise feedback,\" which combines high standards with high support, clearly communicating belief in the person's potential and offering commitment to their growth.
Psychological Safety and Leadership Styles
Psychological safety is defined as an environment where individuals can take risks and learn without fear of judgment for temporary failures. This is contrasted with \"enforcer\" (high demand, low support) and \"protector\" (low demand, high support) leadership styles, advocating for the \"mentor\" (high demand, high support) approach.
The Mechanics of Wise Feedback and Core Needs
Wise feedback involves transparently communicating high standards and belief in capability. The podcast emphasizes that status and respect are fundamental needs for young people, akin to basic survival needs, and meeting these needs is key to unlocking motivation.
Universal Application and Continuous Growth
The \"mentor mindset\" is applicable beyond chronological adolescence, extending to any individual feeling threatened in their status. The importance of \"do-overs\" and repairing missteps is highlighted as a powerful tool for ongoing growth and relationship building.
Keywords
Mentor's Dilemma
The challenge leaders face in balancing criticism with support to foster growth without demotivation.
Wise Feedback
A leadership technique combining high standards with high support and belief in potential.
Psychological Safety
An environment enabling risk-taking and learning by removing fear of judgment for failures.
Mentor Mindset
A leadership approach characterized by high demand and high support for employee development.
Enforcer Mindset
Leadership style with high demands but low support, often leading to fear.
Protector Mindset
Leadership style with high support but low demands, potentially hindering growth.
Status and Respect
Fundamental psychological needs for young people that significantly impact motivation and behavior.
Generational Differences
Perceptions and realities of motivation and behavior across different age groups.
Youth Motivation
Strategies and psychological factors influencing the drive and engagement of young people.
Leadership Styles
Different approaches leaders take to manage and motivate their teams.
Q&A
Why do older generations often complain about younger generations lacking motivation?
This is a recurring historical pattern. While there are real cultural and economic shifts influencing youth, much of the complaint stems from adults' own developmental stage and perception, comparing their past youthful indiscretions to current youth behaviors.
What is the \"mentor's dilemma\" and how can it be resolved?
The mentor's dilemma is the difficulty of criticizing someone to help them improve without demotivating them. It's resolved by adopting a \"mentor mindset\" which combines high standards with high support, clearly communicating belief in their potential and offering help.
How does psychological safety relate to motivating young people?
Psychological safety is crucial because it assures young people they won't be judged or punished for temporary failures. This safety allows them to take risks and explore, which is essential for learning and growth, rather than fearing negative consequences.
What are the three leadership styles discussed, and which is most effective?
The three styles are: Enforcer (high demand, low support), Protector (low demand, high support), and Mentor (high demand, high support). The Mentor mindset is presented as the most effective for motivating and developing young people.
Why are status and respect so critical for young people?
Status and respect are core needs for young people, driving their behavior. When these are threatened, they can lead to negative outcomes. Conversely, ensuring they feel respected and have status can unlock significant motivation and positive behavior.
Show Notes
David Yeager: 10 to 25
David Yeager is a professor of psychology at the University of Texas at Austin and the cofounder of the Texas Behavioral Science and Policy Institute. He is best known for his research conducted with Carol Dweck, Angela Duckworth, and Greg Walton on short but powerful interventions that influence adolescent behaviors such as motivation, engagement, healthy eating, bullying, stress, mental health, and more. He is the author of 10 to 25: The Science of Motivating Young People (Amazon, Bookshop)*.
Older generations have been complaining about younger generations for all of recorded history. Today is no different, and I often hear how leaders are struggling with motivating their younger employees. In this conversation, David and I explore the most recent research and practice for what actually works.
Key Points
- Older generations have been complaining about younger generations for all of recorded history. Often, our complaints are the result of our own past experiences.
- Many leaders experience the mentor’s dilemma: being nice and putting up with poor performance, or being critical and demanding higher performance.
- Status and respect for a young person are as critical as food and sleep to a baby. When satisfied, they can open up much better motivation and behavior.
- The mentor mindset embraces both high standards and high support for the young person you wish to motivate. Because this is a mindset, you can absolutely get better at it.
- When giving feedback to a young person, acknowledge the high standard you are setting and also tell the young person that you believe they can meet that standard.
- Young people have often experienced a lot of “enforcing” behavior from parents, teachers, and coaches. They assume this in the workplace if you don’t make a point to say otherwise.
Resources Mentioned
- 10 to 25: The Science of Motivating Young People by David Yeager (Amazon, Bookshop)*
- The Power of Mindset (Masterclass)
Interview Notes
Download my interview notes in PDF format (free membership required).
Related Episodes
- How to Challenge Directly and Care Personally, with Kim Scott (episode 302)
- How to Reduce Drama With Kids, with Tina Payne Bryson (episode 310)
- How to Solve the Toughest Problems, with Wendy Smith (episode 612)
Discover More
Activate your free membership for full access to the entire library of interviews since 2011, searchable by topic. To accelerate your learning, uncover more inside Coaching for Leaders Plus.
Table of contents
United States
