Digest

This episode of the podcast delves into the tragic case of Beverly Carter, a successful real estate agent who was kidnapped and murdered in 2014. The hosts, Mike Ferguson and Mike Gibson, meticulously unravel the events leading up to the crime, the investigation, and the subsequent trial of the perpetrators, Aaron Lewis and his wife, Crystal Lowry. The episode begins with a detailed account of Beverly Carter's life and career, highlighting her dedication to her family and her profession. The hosts then delve into the investigation, focusing on the identification of Aaron Lewis as a suspect and the discovery of Beverly's body. They discuss Aaron Lewis's criminal history, his arrest, and the charges against him, as well as the role of his wife, Crystal Lowry, in the case. The episode explores the evidence presented at trial, including cell phone data, text messages, and witness testimonies. The hosts analyze the defense's strategy, which included discrediting Beverly Carter and claiming her death was accidental. They also discuss the prosecution's evidence, which ultimately led to the conviction of Aaron Lewis for capital murder and kidnapping. The episode concludes with a discussion of the impact of Beverly Carter's murder on realtor safety and the changes that have been implemented to improve safety practices in the industry. The hosts also discuss the couple's motives for committing the crime and the senselessness of Beverly Carter's death.

Outlines

00:00:10

The Kidnapping and Murder of Beverly Carter

This episode investigates the kidnapping and murder of Beverly Carter, a successful real estate agent, by Aaron Lewis and Crystal Lowry. The hosts discuss the circumstances of her disappearance, the investigation, and the arrest of the suspects.

00:05:21

Beverly Carter's Life and the Investigation

The hosts provide background information on Beverly Carter, including her family, her career as a real estate agent, and her life in Arkansas. They also detail the investigation into her disappearance, focusing on the identification of Aaron Lewis as a suspect and the subsequent discovery of her body.

00:10:15

Aaron Lewis's Criminal History and the Trial

The hosts discuss Aaron Lewis's criminal history, his arrest, and the charges against him. They also explore the role of his wife, Crystal Lowry, in the case and detail the evidence presented at trial, including cell phone data, text messages, and witness testimonies.

00:26:11

The Verdict and Sentencing

The hosts describe the verdict and sentencing of Aaron Lewis, who was found guilty of capital murder and kidnapping and sentenced to life in prison without parole. They also discuss Crystal Lowry's plea deal and her subsequent sentence.

00:31:11

The Defense's Arguments and the Victim's Portrayal

The hosts discuss the defense's arguments, which included claiming that Beverly Carter was not abducted and that her death was accidental. They also criticize the defense's portrayal of the victim and analyze the prosecution's evidence, which ultimately led to the conviction of Aaron Lewis.

00:42:09

The Murder of Beverly Carter and the Aftermath

The hosts describe the murder of Beverly Carter, including the details of her death and the couple's actions after the crime. They discuss the couple's decision to kill Beverly Carter and Crystal Lowry's role in the crime.

01:00:41

The Impact of Beverly Carter's Murder

The hosts discuss the impact of Beverly Carter's murder on realtor safety and the changes that have been implemented to improve safety practices in the industry. They also discuss the couple's motives for committing the crime and the senselessness of Beverly Carter's death.

01:09:56

Conclusion and Voicemails

The hosts conclude the episode by discussing the senselessness of Beverly Carter's death and the couple's motives for committing the crime. They also play voicemails from listeners.

Keywords

Q&A

• What were the circumstances surrounding Beverly Carter's disappearance and murder?

  Beverly Carter was a successful real estate agent who was kidnapped and murdered in 2014. She was lured to a rural property under the pretense of meeting a married couple interested in buying a house. The couple, Aaron Lewis and Crystal Lowry, had planned to kidnap her for ransom, but their plan went awry, and she was ultimately killed.

• What evidence led to the arrest of Aaron Lewis and Crystal Lowry?

  The investigation revealed that Aaron Lewis had a history of criminal activity and was a person of interest in the case. Cell phone data and text messages linked him to Beverly Carter's disappearance, and his car was found to contain evidence of the crime. Crystal Lowry was also implicated in the crime through phone records and text messages.

• What was the defense's strategy in Aaron Lewis's trial?

  The defense attempted to discredit Beverly Carter by claiming that she was not abducted and that her death was accidental. They also suggested that she was having an affair with Aaron Lewis and that her death occurred during a sexual encounter with Crystal Lowry.

• What was the outcome of Aaron Lewis's trial?

  Aaron Lewis was found guilty of capital murder and kidnapping and sentenced to life in prison without parole. Crystal Lowry pleaded guilty to a lesser charge of first-degree murder and was sentenced to 30 years in prison.

• What impact did Beverly Carter's murder have on realtor safety?

  Beverly Carter's murder brought attention to the dangers of the real estate industry, particularly for women working alone. The Arkansas Realtors Association and other organizations have implemented safety recommendations for agents, including using a buddy system, meeting clients at an office, and making copies of client driver's licenses.

• What is the current status of Aaron Lewis and Crystal Lowry?

  Aaron Lewis, now Anastasia Nicole Kimberley, is currently incarcerated in a federal penitentiary in Tucson. Crystal Lowry is also incarcerated and has filed an appeal challenging her guilty plea.

Show Notes