The Ultimate Debate: Alien vs. Aliens — A Definitive Franchise Ranking

Welcome back to the podcast for an epic, feature-length deep-dive! We are tackling one of the most beloved, yet most divisive, sci-fi/horror sagas in history: the Alien Franchise. Therefore, we aren't just grazing the surface this week. We're heading down to Hadley’s Hope to settle a debate that has torn fans apart for decades.

Alien vs. Aliens: Horror Masterpiece or Action Spectacle?

The core question remains: Alien vs. Aliens—which film is truly the superior masterpiece? Consequently, we meticulously compare and contrast Ridley Scott’s 1979 original. That film was a claustrophobic, slow-burn horror experience; it perfected the "haunted house in space" trope. In contrast, James Cameron's 1986 follow-up was a pulse-pounding, action-packed thrill ride. Furthermore, it completely redefined the term "sequel" and introduced the iconic Colonial Marines.

We debate the merits of Sigourney Weaver’s groundbreaking performance as Ripley in both films. We look at how the Xenomorph evolved from a solitary symbol of terror to a swarm-based military threat. Is your loyalty with the suspense of the Nostromo, or the explosive mayhem of Acheron? Finally, we lay out the case for both sides, leading to our definitive winner in the Alien vs. Aliens showdown.

Ranking the Full Saga: From Alien 3 to Covenant

However, the debate doesn't end with the classics. After all, we continue our journey by tackling the rest of the saga. Admittedly, the franchise started incredibly high, but at times, it went disappointingly low. We fearlessly dive into the most controversial entries. For instance, we discuss the bleak, flawed genius of Alien 3 and the highly stylized, sometimes ridiculous nature of Alien: Resurrection. Moreover, we tackle the complex, philosophical messiness of the prequels, Prometheus and Alien: Covenant. Did the prequels successfully connect to the original films? Or did they only succeed in raising questions no one wanted answered? We analyze why these later entries failed to capture the primal terror of the originals.

Hope for the Future: Romulus and the Blomkamp Files

Finally, we look ahead and reflect on what could have been. We share our tentative hopes and fears for Fede Álvarez’s upcoming film, Alien: Romulus. We discuss whether this new, standalone effort can recapture the magic and dread that defined the early films. In addition, we pull back the curtain on the great canceled sequel, Neil Blomkamp's proposed Alien 5. This project aimed to retcon the timeline after Aliens. We dissect the concept art and reveal why the project ultimately fizzled out. Ultimately, we ask what it would have taken to create a sequel that successfully erased Alien 3 and Resurrection from the timeline.

If you’re a fan of the Xenomorph or just great sci-fi horror, then this is a must-listen episode. Where does your favorite film land? Tune in now to hear our final, unforgiving ranking!

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.