Andrew Bagby and Zachary Turner - 583
Andrew Bagby and Zachary Turner - 583
6Digest
This podcast delves into the complex and heartbreaking case of Andrew Bagby, a medical student who was murdered by his ex-girlfriend, Shirley Turner. The podcast begins with an introduction and announcements, followed by a detailed account of Andrew's life, his relationship with Shirley, and the events leading up to his death. The hosts discuss Shirley's controlling behavior, Andrew's attempts to break up with her, and the escalating tension between them. The podcast then explores Shirley's actions after Andrew's death, including her initial claims of innocence, her changing stories, and her eventual flight to Canada. The hosts detail Shirley's arrest in Canada, her release on bail, and the ongoing legal battles surrounding her extradition. The podcast also focuses on the Bagby family's efforts to gain custody of Andrew's son, Zachary, and the challenges they faced in dealing with Shirley. The hosts describe Shirley's release from prison, the Bagby family's continued struggles, and the tragic disappearance of Zachary. The podcast reveals the heartbreaking discovery of Zachary's body and the subsequent investigation into his death. The hosts discuss the impact of the tragedy on the Bagby family and the public outcry that followed. The podcast examines the failures of the legal system in protecting Zachary and the Bagby family's tireless advocacy for justice and reform. The podcast concludes with reflections on the case and its implications, highlighting the importance of fighting for justice and the enduring power of love and resilience.
Outlines
The Murder of Andrew Bagby
This chapter explores the life of Andrew Bagby, his relationship with Shirley Turner, and the events leading up to his murder. It details Shirley's controlling behavior, Andrew's attempts to break up with her, and the escalating tension between them.
Shirley Turner's Actions After the Murder
This chapter examines Shirley Turner's actions after Andrew's death, including her initial claims of innocence, her changing stories, and her eventual flight to Canada. It also discusses the legal proceedings surrounding her arrest and extradition.
The Bagby Family's Fight for Custody
This chapter focuses on the Bagby family's efforts to gain custody of Andrew's son, Zachary, and the challenges they faced in dealing with Shirley. It highlights the legal battles, the emotional toll on the family, and the obstacles they encountered.
Zachary's Disappearance and Death
This chapter describes Shirley's release from prison, the Bagby family's continued struggles, and the tragic disappearance of Zachary. It reveals the heartbreaking discovery of Zachary's body and the subsequent investigation into his death.
The Aftermath and System Failures
This chapter discusses the impact of Zachary's death on the Bagby family and the public outcry that followed. It examines the failures of the legal system in protecting Zachary and the Bagby family's tireless advocacy for justice and reform.
Conclusion and Reflections
This chapter concludes with reflections on the case and its implications, highlighting the importance of fighting for justice and the enduring power of love and resilience.
Keywords
Premeditated Murder
The intentional killing of another person, planned and carried out in advance. It involves a deliberate decision to take a life, often with a specific motive.
Extradition
The process of transferring a person accused of a crime from one jurisdiction to another for trial or punishment. It involves legal proceedings and cooperation between the involved countries.
Custody Battle
A legal dispute between parents or guardians over the care and upbringing of a child. It often involves issues of visitation rights, child support, and legal guardianship.
Narcissistic Personality Disorder
A mental health condition characterized by an inflated sense of self-importance, a need for admiration, and a lack of empathy for others. It can manifest in manipulative and controlling behaviors.
Child Protection Services
Government agencies responsible for investigating reports of child abuse and neglect, providing support to families, and ensuring the safety and well-being of children.
Bail Reform
Changes to laws and procedures related to bail, which is a financial guarantee that a defendant will appear in court. Bail reform aims to ensure fairness and prevent the unnecessary detention of individuals.
Q&A
What were the key events that led to Andrew Bagby's murder?
Andrew Bagby's relationship with Shirley Turner was tumultuous, marked by her controlling behavior and his attempts to break up with her. Shirley's jealousy and obsession ultimately led to her driving from Iowa to Pennsylvania and confronting Andrew at Keystone State Park, where she shot him five times.
Why was Shirley Turner released on bail despite the serious charges against her?
Shirley was released on bail in Canada due to a combination of factors, including the Crown prosecutor's belief that she was not a flight risk and the lack of evidence suggesting she posed a danger to the public. This decision was met with significant criticism and raised concerns about the Canadian justice system's handling of the case.
How did the Bagby family fight for custody of Zachary and what challenges did they face?
The Bagby family, determined to protect Zachary from Shirley, fought for custody and visitation rights. They faced numerous obstacles, including Shirley's manipulation, the Canadian legal system's delays, and the emotional toll of dealing with the woman they believed killed their son.
What were the consequences of the failures in the Canadian legal system in this case?
The failures in the Canadian legal system, including Shirley's release on bail and the lack of adequate child protection measures, resulted in the tragic death of Zachary. The case sparked public outcry and led to investigations and reforms aimed at preventing similar tragedies from occurring in the future.
Show Notes
On November 6, 2001, at Keystone State Park in Pennsylvania, Dr. Andrew Bagby was found dead with five gunshot wounds. Dr. Shirley Turner, a recent girlfriend, became the number one suspect. She fled to Canada, her home country, and awaited a decision on extradition. In July 2002, Shirley gave birth to Andrew’s son, Zachary Andrew Turner. Andrew’s parents, Kate and David Bagby moved to Canada and fought for custody of Zachary and justice for Andrew. But the case took an unexpected and terrible turn which prompted many to ask the question, 'how could the authorities have let this happen?'
Generation Why has tons a bonus content at: patreon.com/generationwhy
Listen ad free with Wondery+. Join Wondery+ for exclusives, binges, early access, and ad free listening. Available in the Wondery App. https://wondery.app.link/generationwhy.
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Table of contents
United States
Every indication is that Canada's justice system is eons behind the rest of the world. It's unsurprising to hear that they've bungled yet another case resulting in more death and devastation. How the judges in these cases have not seen punishment is beyond me.