The episode kicks off with the hosts and guest Moosejaw diving into recent MLB playoff performances. Moosejaw highlights the incredible rookie pitching of Trejasiewicz and the offensive explosion from Dalton Varsho, both of whom absolutely dominated their recent games. Rooster, on the other hand, is channeling the ghosts of Yankees past, hoping Billy Martin can inject some life into manager Aaron Boone and Reggie Jackson can spark Aaron Judge. The conversation then shifts to college football, where Arch Manning's early struggles at quarterback are a hot topic, with some hosts suggesting he needs more time in college to develop.

NFL Week 5 observations are next on the agenda, with a focus on "overreaction Monday." The hosts discuss the surprising losses of the Bills and Eagles, attributing the latter's defeat to a questionable offensive game plan that neglected Saquon Barkley. They also touch on the disappointing Baltimore Ravens and the quietly strong performances of the Colts, Lions, and 49ers. The segment wraps up with a look at the Chargers' recent struggles, the Dolphins' epic fourth-quarter collapse, and a quick shout-out to the resurgent Baker Mayfield and Sam Darnold, proving that a change of scenery and good coaching can make all the difference for talented quarterbacks

Finally, the bizarre incident involving former NFL quarterback Mark Sanchez, who was charged with a felony after a confrontation with a 69-year-old man, sparked a debate about his behavior and the need for more information. This story highlights the challenges public figures face when their personal lives intersect with legal issues, and the importance of due process before making judgments. The incident also serves as a reminder that even seemingly successful post-playing careers can be derailed by unexpected events.