DiscoverCasefile True CrimeCase 120: Bill McGuire
Case 120: Bill McGuire

Case 120: Bill McGuire

Update: 2019-08-1098


It was a dark green suitcase. Given its proximity to the bridge, the men assumed it must have blown off the luggage rack of a vehicle driving above and hauled it onboard...

Episode narrated by the Anonymous Host
Episode researched by Flossie Arend
Episode written by Flossie Arend, Elsha McGill, and Milly Raso

This episode's sponsors:
Never Thought I'd Say This – New parenting podcast from Audioboom starring Jodie Sweetin and Celia Behar

Quip – Get your first refill pack FREE with a QUIP electric toothbrush

Grove – get FREE Mrs. Meyer’s Set worth $30 with your first order of $20 or more

Calm – Get 25% off Calm Premium subscription

For all credits and sources please visit
Comments (8)

Emily Healy

I thought this case sounded familiar to me when the suitcase was mentioned. As soon as the host said "New Jersey" I knew exactly which murder this was! This case was one I heard about a lot growing up, I lived for most of my childhood in the neighborhood right next to the one Melanie McGuire moved into after selling the Asbury home. Ever since I heard this story I'd been afraid that I was going to find a dead body, and kickstarted my interest in true crime. I wasn't even sure if this was a true story until now, it's crazy hearing this from someone who didn't live in that specific part of Brick! It's also really interesting to hear all the facts, and not the gossip

Aug 12th
Reply (1)


40 caliber 9mm. really??

Aug 12th
Reply (2)

Ryan McKinless

Got to be honest, the movie trailer delivery is getting harder to listen to week on week. Listened back to the Silk Road episodes and much preferred the freer vocal style from back then

Aug 10th
Reply (1)

Dahlia Myers


Aug 10th
Download from Google Play
Download from App Store








Case 120: Bill McGuire

Case 120: Bill McGuire

Casefile Presents