DiscoverGoldman Sachs ExchangesCentral bank divergence: Why it's happening and why it matters
Central bank divergence: Why it's happening and why it matters

Central bank divergence: Why it's happening and why it matters

Update: 2024-06-041
Share

Digest

This episode of Goldman Sachs Exchanges explores the divergence of central bank policies, specifically focusing on the differing paths of the Fed and the ECB. Allison Nathan, the host, interviews three prominent economists: Jan Hatzius, Chief Global Economist at Goldman Sachs; Peter Praet, former Chief Economist of the European Central Bank; and Maurice Obstfeld, former Chief Economist of the IMF. The discussion centers around the reasons behind the divergence, the potential implications for economies and markets, and the role of the US dollar in this evolving landscape. Jan Hatzius highlights the differing economic conditions in the US and other G10 economies, suggesting that while the US economy is still stronger, it is showing signs of softening. He attributes this to a combination of factors, including a slower pace of disinflation in the US compared to other economies and a rebalancing of the labor market. Peter Praet, drawing on his experience at the ECB, emphasizes the historical precedent of the US leading the global financial cycle, with the ECB typically following suit. He acknowledges that the US is not entirely independent of global influences, and that there are spillovers in financial conditions between countries. He cites the Eurocrisis as an example of successful divergence, highlighting the importance of fundamental economic differences and the ability of central banks to manage these divergences. Maurice Obstfeld focuses on the potential impact of divergent policies on currencies, particularly the US dollar. He suggests that the dollar is likely to remain strong, given the Fed's expected hold on interest rates while other central banks cut rates. He also discusses the potential limits to dollar strength, emphasizing the potential for export industries to be adversely affected by a strong dollar. The episode concludes with a discussion of the potential for currency volatility and the implications of divergent policies for global markets.

Outlines

00:00:00
Central Bank Divergence: A Global Perspective

This Chapter begins with a discussion of the divergence of central bank policies, particularly between the Fed and the ECB. The podcast explores the reasons behind this divergence, the potential implications for economies and markets, and the role of the US dollar in this evolving landscape.

00:09:05
Historical Perspective on Central Bank Divergence

This Chapter delves into the historical precedent of the US leading the global financial cycle, with the ECB typically following suit. The discussion highlights the potential for spillovers in financial conditions between countries and the importance of fundamental economic differences in managing divergence. The Eurocrisis is cited as an example of successful divergence.

00:15:31
Currency Implications of Divergent Policies

This Chapter focuses on the potential impact of divergent policies on currencies, particularly the US dollar. The discussion explores the factors driving dollar strength, the potential limits to this strength, and the implications for export industries. The episode concludes with a discussion of the potential for currency volatility and the implications of divergent policies for global markets.

Keywords

Central Bank Divergence
Central bank divergence refers to the situation where different central banks adopt different monetary policies, often leading to variations in interest rates and other policy tools. This can occur due to differences in economic conditions, inflation rates, or other factors. Divergence can have significant implications for global economies and financial markets, potentially affecting exchange rates, capital flows, and economic growth.

Federal Reserve (Fed)
The Federal Reserve, often referred to as the Fed, is the central bank of the United States. It is responsible for setting monetary policy, regulating financial institutions, and providing financial services to the government and the banking system. The Fed's decisions on interest rates, reserve requirements, and other policy tools have a significant impact on the US economy and global financial markets.

European Central Bank (ECB)
The European Central Bank (ECB) is the central bank of the eurozone, the group of European countries that use the euro as their common currency. The ECB is responsible for setting monetary policy for the eurozone, aiming to maintain price stability and support economic growth. The ECB's decisions on interest rates, quantitative easing, and other policy tools have a significant impact on the eurozone economy and global financial markets.

US Dollar
The US dollar is the official currency of the United States and is widely used as a reserve currency in global financial markets. The dollar's strength or weakness can have significant implications for international trade, investment, and economic activity. Factors influencing the dollar's value include interest rate differentials, economic growth, and geopolitical events.

Global Financial Cycle
The global financial cycle refers to the cyclical pattern of expansion and contraction in global financial markets. This cycle is influenced by factors such as interest rates, credit availability, and investor sentiment. The global financial cycle can have significant implications for economic growth, asset prices, and financial stability.

Eurocrisis
The Eurocrisis was a period of financial instability in the eurozone that began in 2009 and intensified in 2010. The crisis was triggered by the global financial crisis and exacerbated by sovereign debt problems in several eurozone countries. The Eurocrisis led to significant economic and political challenges for the eurozone and highlighted the risks associated with a single currency.

Plaza Accord
The Plaza Accord was an agreement signed in 1985 by the finance ministers of five major industrialized countries (the United States, Japan, West Germany, France, and the United Kingdom). The accord aimed to depreciate the US dollar against other major currencies to reduce the US trade deficit. The Plaza Accord was considered a successful intervention in the foreign exchange market, leading to a significant decline in the dollar's value.

Monetary Policy
Monetary policy refers to the actions undertaken by a central bank to manage the money supply and credit conditions in an economy. Monetary policy tools include setting interest rates, adjusting reserve requirements, and conducting open market operations. The goal of monetary policy is typically to achieve price stability, full employment, and sustainable economic growth.

Disinflation
Disinflation refers to a slowdown in the rate of inflation. It occurs when the rate of price increases slows down, but prices are still rising. Disinflation is often a sign that economic growth is slowing or that central bank policies are having an effect on inflation.

Q&A

  • What are the key factors driving the divergence of central bank policies, particularly between the Fed and the ECB?

    The divergence is primarily driven by differences in economic conditions and inflation rates. The US economy is still relatively strong, but showing signs of softening, while other G10 economies, including the Eurozone, are experiencing weaker growth and faster disinflation. This leads to different policy needs, with the Fed potentially holding rates steady while the ECB cuts rates.

  • How unusual is the current sequence of events, with the ECB expected to cut rates while the Fed holds steady?

    While the US typically leads the global financial cycle, this sequence of events is somewhat unusual. Historically, the ECB has followed the Fed's lead, but the current divergence is driven by fundamental economic differences and the need for tailored policy responses.

  • What are the potential implications of central bank divergence for global economies and markets?

    Divergence can lead to currency volatility, as investors adjust their portfolios based on interest rate differentials. It can also affect capital flows and economic growth, as businesses and investors respond to changing monetary conditions. The impact of divergence can vary depending on the extent of the differences in policy and the underlying economic fundamentals.

  • What is the role of the US dollar in this evolving landscape of central bank divergence?

    The US dollar is likely to remain strong, given the Fed's expected hold on interest rates while other central banks cut rates. This could lead to further appreciation of the dollar, potentially impacting export industries and global trade. However, there are potential limits to dollar strength, as a very strong dollar could lead to calls for protectionist measures.

  • What are the potential risks associated with central bank divergence?

    While divergence can be managed, there are potential risks. Sharp and sudden moves in exchange rates can create market volatility and uncertainty. Additionally, divergence can exacerbate existing economic imbalances and create challenges for global coordination.

  • What are the lessons learned from past episodes of central bank divergence?

    Past episodes of divergence, such as the Eurocrisis, highlight the importance of fundamental economic differences and the ability of central banks to manage these divergences. However, they also underscore the potential for market volatility and the need for careful coordination between central banks.

  • What are the key takeaways from this episode of Goldman Sachs Exchanges?

    The episode highlights the importance of understanding the factors driving central bank divergence and its potential implications for global economies and markets. It emphasizes the need for careful monitoring of economic conditions and policy responses, as well as the importance of international cooperation in managing global financial stability.

Show Notes

The Federal Reserve has historically led a relatively synchronized monetary policy cycle across the major economies, but this cycle seems to be shaping up differently. Goldman Sachs' Chief Economist and Head of Goldman Sachs Research Jan Hatzius, Peter Praet, former chief economist of the European Central Bank, and Maurice Obstfeld, former chief economist of the IMF, discuss the implications of central bank divergence for economies and markets. This episode explores the latest Top of Mind report, Central Bank Divergence: Room to Run?

Comments 
loading
In Channel
loading

Table of contents

00:00
00:00
1.0x

0.5x

0.8x

1.0x

1.25x

1.5x

2.0x

3.0x

Sleep Timer

Off

End of Episode

5 Minutes

10 Minutes

15 Minutes

30 Minutes

45 Minutes

60 Minutes

120 Minutes

Central bank divergence: Why it's happening and why it matters

Central bank divergence: Why it's happening and why it matters

Goldman Sachs