E392 Rat Girl Summer and Weepy Hollow
Digest
This podcast episode marks the 400th episode with a humorous opening and a brief discussion about the FCC. The hosts then discuss the changes in their respective backgrounds, with Christine's room appearing more decorated and the speaker's background remaining cluttered. The episode then dives into the story of the Irma Hotel in Cody, Wyoming, founded by Buffalo Bill. The speaker provides a detailed account of Buffalo Bill's life, highlighting his early career as a trapper, his involvement in the gold rush, and his role in the Pony Express. The episode discusses Buffalo Bill's remarkable 330-mile ride on horseback for the Pony Express, which established his reputation as a frontiersman. The speaker then details Buffalo Bill's transition into the entertainment industry, starting with his appearance in a play about himself in New York City. The episode describes the success of his Wild West show, which featured trick riders, sharp shooters, and other famous figures of the era. The speaker explains how Buffalo Bill built the Irma Hotel in Cody, Wyoming, named after his daughter. They discuss the hotel's history, its significance as a social center in the town, and its current status as a historic landmark. The hosts explore the paranormal activity reported at the Irma Hotel, focusing on the four main ghosts said to haunt the building. They discuss the stories surrounding Buffalo Bill's ghost, his daughter Irma, an old outlaw, and a soldier. The speaker describes the 15 original rooms of the Irma Hotel, which are named after Wild West icons and local pioneers. They highlight the stories of Agnes Chamberlain, the wife of the town's first dentist, and Caroline Lockhart, a prominent journalist and humorist. The hosts then shift to a different story, focusing on the disappearance of Heather Teague in Spotsville, Kentucky, in 1995. They provide background information about Heather, her life, and the circumstances surrounding her disappearance. The speaker recounts the story of Tim Walthall, who witnessed Heather Teague's abduction through his telescope. They describe the events leading up to the abduction, Tim's attempts to contact authorities, and the subsequent investigation. This chapter delves into the mysterious disappearance of Heather Teague, a young woman who vanished from a beach in Kentucky. The podcast explores various theories surrounding her disappearance, including a local predator, a drug ring, and a potential serial killer. This chapter focuses on the theory that Heather Teague was intentionally targeted, possibly due to her involvement in a drug ring or other shady activities. The podcast examines evidence supporting this theory, including her past drug use and the FBI's involvement in the case. This chapter explores the possibility that Heather Teague's disappearance is linked to a serial killer named Christopher Belos. The podcast discusses Belos's history of missing women in his vicinity and the striking resemblance between his potential victim type and Heather. This chapter delves into the potential connection between Christopher Belos and Marty Dill, the man initially suspected in Heather's disappearance. The podcast reveals that Belos and Dill were friends since childhood, raising questions about their possible involvement in the case. This chapter focuses on the ongoing efforts of Heather Teague's mother, Sarah, to find answers about her daughter's disappearance. The podcast discusses Sarah's skepticism towards the police investigation, her belief that the 9-1-1 call was faked, and her recent lawsuit against the Kentucky State Police and FBI.
Outlines
The Irma Hotel: A Wild West Tale and the Disappearance of Heather Teague
This episode explores the history of the Irma Hotel in Cody, Wyoming, founded by Buffalo Bill, and delves into the unsolved disappearance of Heather Teague in Kentucky, examining various theories and the ongoing search for answers.
Room Decor and Background Changes
The hosts discuss the changes in their respective backgrounds, with Christine's room appearing more decorated and the speaker's background remaining cluttered. They joke about the potential for an "iSpy" game with the clutter.
Buffalo Bill's Life and the Founding of the Irma Hotel
The hosts delve into a story about the Irma Hotel in Cody, Wyoming, founded by Buffalo Bill. The speaker provides a deep dive into Buffalo Bill's life, highlighting his early career as a trapper, his involvement in the gold rush, and his role in the Pony Express.
Buffalo Bill's Rise to Fame and the Pony Express
The speaker continues the story of Buffalo Bill, focusing on his remarkable 330-mile ride on horseback for the Pony Express. They discuss the significance of this event in establishing Buffalo Bill's reputation as a frontiersman.
Buffalo Bill's Entertainment Career and Wild West Show
The speaker details Buffalo Bill's transition into the entertainment industry, starting with his appearance in a play about himself in New York City. They describe the success of his Wild West show, which featured trick riders, sharp shooters, and other famous figures of the era.
The Irma Hotel: Buffalo Bill's Legacy
The speaker explains how Buffalo Bill built the Irma Hotel in Cody, Wyoming, named after his daughter. They discuss the hotel's history, its significance as a social center in the town, and its current status as a historic landmark.
The Ghosts of the Irma Hotel
The hosts explore the paranormal activity reported at the Irma Hotel, focusing on the four main ghosts said to haunt the building. They discuss the stories surrounding Buffalo Bill's ghost, his daughter Irma, an old outlaw, and a soldier.
The Irma Hotel's Original Rooms and Wild West Icons
The speaker describes the 15 original rooms of the Irma Hotel, which are named after Wild West icons and local pioneers. They highlight the stories of Agnes Chamberlain, the wife of the town's first dentist, and Caroline Lockhart, a prominent journalist and humorist.
The Heather Teague Case: A Kentucky Mystery
The hosts shift to a different story, focusing on the disappearance of Heather Teague in Spotsville, Kentucky, in 1995. They provide background information about Heather, her life, and the circumstances surrounding her disappearance.
The Witnessing of Heather Teague's Disappearance
The speaker recounts the story of Tim Walthall, who witnessed Heather Teague's abduction through his telescope. They describe the events leading up to the abduction, Tim's attempts to contact authorities, and the subsequent investigation.
Heather Teague's Disappearance: A Complicated Case
This chapter delves into the mysterious disappearance of Heather Teague, a young woman who vanished from a beach in Kentucky. The podcast explores various theories surrounding her disappearance, including a local predator, a drug ring, and a potential serial killer.
Theories Surrounding Heather Teague's Disappearance
This chapter focuses on the theory that Heather Teague was intentionally targeted, possibly due to her involvement in a drug ring or other shady activities. The podcast examines evidence supporting this theory, including her past drug use and the FBI's involvement in the case. This chapter explores the possibility that Heather Teague's disappearance is linked to a serial killer named Christopher Belos. The podcast discusses Belos's history of missing women in his vicinity and the striking resemblance between his potential victim type and Heather. This chapter delves into the potential connection between Christopher Belos and Marty Dill, the man initially suspected in Heather's disappearance. The podcast reveals that Belos and Dill were friends since childhood, raising questions about their possible involvement in the case.
The Ongoing Search for Answers
This chapter focuses on the ongoing efforts of Heather Teague's mother, Sarah, to find answers about her daughter's disappearance. The podcast discusses Sarah's skepticism towards the police investigation, her belief that the 9-1-1 call was faked, and her recent lawsuit against the Kentucky State Police and FBI.
Keywords
Buffalo Bill
William Frederick Cody, better known as Buffalo Bill, was a famous American frontiersman, soldier, and showman. He gained notoriety for his exploits in the Wild West, including his role in the Pony Express and his buffalo hunting skills.
Irma Hotel
A historic hotel located in Cody, Wyoming, founded by Buffalo Bill in 1902. It was named after his daughter, Irma, and has become a popular tourist destination known for its Wild West ambiance and reported paranormal activity.
Pony Express
A mail delivery system established in 1860, using riders on horseback to transport mail across the American West. It was a significant development in communication and transportation during the era.
Heather Teague
A young woman who disappeared from Spotsville, Kentucky, in 1995. Her disappearance remains unsolved, and the case has been featured in documentaries and true crime podcasts.
Newberg Beach
A beach located on the banks of the Ohio River, near the border of Indiana and Kentucky. It is known for its outdoor activities, including boating, sunbathing, and four-wheeling.
Caroline Lockhart
A prominent journalist, humorist, and author who lived in Cody, Wyoming, during the early 20th century. She was known for her sharp wit, her adventurous spirit, and her contributions to the development of Cody.
Christopher Belos
Christopher Belos is a suspected serial killer who was investigated for the murder of his ex-girlfriend, Kathy Fetzer. He was also linked to the disappearance of several other women, including Heather Teague.
Marty Dill
Marty Dill was initially suspected in Heather Teague's disappearance. He was found dead by suicide after police investigated him. However, evidence later emerged suggesting he may not have been involved.
FOIA Request
FOIA stands for Freedom of Information Act. It is a law that allows individuals to request access to government records. Heather Teague's mother, Sarah, has filed numerous FOIA requests to obtain information about her daughter's case.
Q&A
What is the Irma Hotel and why is it significant?
The Irma Hotel is a historic hotel in Cody, Wyoming, founded by Buffalo Bill in 1902. It was named after his daughter, Irma, and has become a popular tourist destination known for its Wild West ambiance and reported paranormal activity.
What is the story of Buffalo Bill's involvement in the Pony Express?
Buffalo Bill was a rider for the Pony Express and gained notoriety for a remarkable 330-mile ride in under 22 hours, demonstrating his endurance and skill as a frontiersman.
What happened to Heather Teague?
Heather Teague disappeared from Spotsville, Kentucky, in 1995. Her disappearance remains unsolved, and the case has been featured in documentaries and true crime podcasts.
Who is Caroline Lockhart and why is she so fascinating?
Caroline Lockhart was a prominent journalist, humorist, and author who lived in Cody, Wyoming, during the early 20th century. She was known for her sharp wit, her adventurous spirit, and her contributions to the development of Cody. She was a pioneer in journalism, a successful author, and a colorful figure in the Wild West.
What are the main theories surrounding Heather Teague's disappearance?
The main theories include a local predator, a drug ring, and a potential serial killer. The podcast explores evidence supporting each theory, but ultimately, the case remains unsolved.
Why is Heather Teague's mother, Sarah, suing the Kentucky State Police and FBI?
Sarah believes that law enforcement mishandled the investigation into her daughter's disappearance. She claims that they ignored evidence that contradicted their initial narrative and that they may have framed Marty Dill.
What is the significance of the 9-1-1 call made by Tim?
The 9-1-1 call provided the initial lead in the case, but Sarah believes that the call was faked. She also questions the accuracy of Tim's description of the man he saw abducting Heather.
What is the current status of Heather Teague's case?
Heather Teague's case remains unsolved. Her mother continues to search for answers and has filed a lawsuit against law enforcement. The podcast concludes with a call to action for listeners to provide any information they may have about Heather's disappearance.
Show Notes
It's episode 392 and we're distracted by the stars in your eyes! First Em takes us to the Irma Hotel in Cody, Wyoming, but don't think they didn't do some deep dives on wild west ghosts in general and even potentially found their long-dead soul mate. Then Christine covers the frightening and infuriating case of the disappearance of Heather Teague. And do you know a dog named Noodle who went to Emerson College? ...and that's why we drink!
Check out Christine's Etsy shop here!
https://www.etsy.com/shop/TheXtineFiles
We're all so, so grateful to everyone who bought a bumper sticker (and so sorry for the folks who only got thank you notes - they should have all been fixed by now). Your purchases made a donation of $3500 to the Palestine Children's Relief Fund possible! https://www.pcrf.net
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices