Episode 172 - Who Has Two Thumbs and is Totally Encouraged?
Digest
This podcast episode delves into various aspects of the Duggar family's life, starting with an anecdote about an "umbrella of authority" and legal updates concerning Josh and Joe Duggar. A significant portion recaps an episode titled "Kittens and Construction," detailing the acquisition and care of new kittens, including their discovery at the Stony Brook property and rescue efforts by Josiah. The narrative highlights the children's involvement in naming and caring for the kittens, contrasting Janna's view of animals as blessings with Joe's more pragmatic stance. The discussion also touches upon the family's beliefs regarding young people staying with parents until marriage and critiques the use of "child labor" in projects like tire recycling. A substantial part of the podcast critically examines the teachings of the Institute in Basic Life Principles (IBLP), particularly concerning "discouragement." The hosts explain IBLP's view of discouragement as a serious spiritual state and a weapon of Satan, outlining steps to conquer it, such as repentance, using the "shield of faith" (reciting God's truth), and encouraging the heart through Psalms. The podcast questions Joe Duggar's application of these principles, suggesting he uses scripture, like Psalm 54, as an escape mechanism to avoid accountability and deny reality, rather than as a genuine coping strategy. The teachings on suppressing emotions and avoiding decisions are also critiqued for promoting denial and detachment. The episode concludes with personal updates, including nostalgic reflections on childhood passions for science and space exploration, referencing the Artemis 2 mission, and reminiscing about early 2000s music like Good Charlotte and Blink-182.
Outlines
Introduction to Belief Systems and Early Anecdotes
The podcast opens with a discussion on belief systems and the concept of an "umbrella of authority," illustrated by an anecdote about insensitivity at a campsite. Legal updates regarding Josh and Joe Duggar's court dates are provided, alongside a personal story about a pet and singing.
Episode Recap: Kittens, Construction, and Family Life
The episode "Kittens and Construction" is recapped, focusing on children's outdoor activities, Jackson's bike repair skills, and the acquisition of two kittens, Ellie and Mia, for the Duggar "hideout." Michelle's initial hesitation and the naming process are discussed, along with humorous childhood poems about pets.
Kitten Care Challenges and Discoveries
Michelle's standards for living things are mentioned, leading into the challenges of caring for the new kittens, including litter box duty. More kittens are found at the Stony Brook property, with Josiah rescuing some from attic walls, prompting commentary on his concern for animals.
Perspectives on Family Growth and Kitten Care Methods
Janna likens acquiring more animals to having more children, calling them a blessing, while Joe expresses a more pragmatic view. A questionable method of keeping kittens warm in a drink pitcher is discussed, contrasting with veterinary advice. Children begin naming kittens, and Baby Cannon explains feeding and burping responsibilities.
Property Renovation and Independence Beliefs
Another kitten, Roger, is found at the Stony Brook property. The ongoing renovation and the help of friends are mentioned. John's land-cleaning project leads to a discussion about the Duggar belief in young people staying with parents until marriage for protection and financial reasons.
Veterinary Care and Kitten Recovery
The kittens are taken to the vet, where Stubby, a kitten with a short tail, is examined. The vet determines the injury may have been caused by the mother or an accident, but the kitten is expected to recover.
Property Projects and Child Labor Critique
Old tires on the Stony Brook property are being recycled for money. The $400 earned is discussed in the context of it being achieved through "free child labor," a critique of the Duggar family's practices.
Ongoing Kitten Care and Jessa's Commentary
The family makes another vet visit for all five kittens, noting the diligence in care. The children discuss their responsibilities, and Jessa makes a comment about "suffering" through the process, interpreted as a veiled criticism of their upbringing. Jessa's consistent annoyance with her father is also noted.
Podcast Topic Struggles and IBLP's Discouragement Teachings
The speaker discusses challenges in choosing a podcast topic, with inspiration drawn from Joe and Kendra's phone calls. The podcast then delves into IBLP's teachings on discouragement, defining it as a serious "state of the soul" and a weapon of Satan, outlining its stages.
Causes and Steps to Conquer Discouragement (IBLP)
The primary causes of discouragement according to IBLP—lies from Satan and abandoning faith—are discussed. The three steps to conquer discouragement are presented: removing guilt, taking up the shield of faith, and encouraging the heart through Psalms.
Critiques of IBLP's Approach to Guilt and Faith
The speaker argues that Joe needs to feel guilt, contrary to IBLP's advice to remove it to avoid discouragement. The importance of the "shield of faith" and verbally responding to lies with God's truth is emphasized, along with communing with God through Psalms.
Joe's Interpretation of Scripture and Perceived Denial
Joe's focus on the "enemy attacks" aspect of Psalms 54 is analyzed as a way to alleviate personal accountability. The speaker expresses a feeling of disconnection from the individuals in the calls, suggesting potential coded language.
Kendra's Struggles and Joe's Scriptural Deflection
Kendra's deteriorating state is contrasted with Joe's persistent monologues about scripture, seen as an escape from reality. Joe's response to legal paperwork by deflecting to scripture is interpreted as denial.
IBLP's Emphasis on Emotional Suppression and Denial
The discussion highlights IBLP's teachings on suppressing emotions and thoughts, leading to denial and detachment from reality, exemplified by Joe's behavior. Further IBLP steps, like avoiding decisions and overcoming pride, are critiqued.
IBLP's Vision Fulfillment and Joe's Ingrained Mindset
The final IBLP step, the "birth, death, and fulfillment of a vision," is discussed, framing Joe's imprisonment as a "death of a vision." The speaker concludes that Joe's actions demonstrate how deeply ingrained IBLP teachings are, leading him to naturally deny reality.
Personal Updates and Nostalgic Reflections
Hosts share personal updates, including a humorous anecdote about a t-shirt and discussions about childhood passions for science and space exploration, linking to the Artemis 2 mission. Nostalgic music from the early 2000s, like Good Charlotte and Blink-182, and associated memories are shared.
Keywords
Umbrella of Authority
A concept representing a hierarchical belief system or structure where authority figures or doctrines provide a framework for understanding and decision-making.
IBLP (Institute in Basic Life Principles)
A religious organization founded by Bill Gothard, promoting a strict code of conduct, family values, and a hierarchical view of authority, influencing the Duggar family's lifestyle.
Discouragement (IBLP context)
Within IBLP, discouragement is viewed as a serious "state of the soul" and a weapon of Satan, to be actively avoided and concealed.
Shield of Faith
A spiritual defense mechanism involving countering negative thoughts with God's truth to protect oneself from spiritual attack and discouragement.
"Encouragement" as a Lexicon
The frequent use of "encouragement" in conversations signifies support and spiritual upliftment, potentially to counteract perceived discouragement.
Child Labor (Duggar context)
The podcast critiques the Duggar family's use of children for labor in projects, framed as a way for Jim Bob to profit.
Psalms as Spiritual Resource
Joe Duggar frequently turns to the Book of Psalms for spiritual guidance and encouragement during difficult times.
Scripture as an Escape Mechanism
Using religious texts to avoid confronting difficult realities, emotions, or responsibilities, manifesting as deflection or denial.
Denial and Emotional Suppression
Psychological defense mechanisms where individuals refuse to accept reality or acknowledge painful feelings, often taught within IBLP as spiritual strength.
Artemis 2 Mission
NASA's planned crewed mission of the Artemis program, highlighted as a positive scientific achievement and inspiration.
Q&A
What is the significance of the "umbrella of authority" in the context of the podcast?
The "umbrella of authority" represents a belief system where individuals are guided and protected by established doctrines or figures, reflecting the Duggar family's structured approach to life.
How does IBLP define "discouragement," and why is it considered so serious?
IBLP defines discouragement as a "state of the soul" and a weapon of Satan, serious because admitting to it implies succumbing to Satan's lies or abandoning faith.
What are the main causes of discouragement according to IBLP teachings?
The two main causes are lies from Satan and "putting down the shield of faith," meaning believing falsehoods or losing spiritual protection.
Why does Joe Duggar frequently mention Psalms, especially Psalm 54, during his phone calls?
Joe uses Psalms, particularly Psalm 54, to find encouragement and frame his situation as being attacked by "enemies," potentially alleviating personal accountability.
What is the "shield of faith," and how is it used within IBLP?
The "shield of faith" is a spiritual defense against Satan's lies, activated by verbally reciting God's truth in response to negative thoughts.
How does Jessa Duggar's comment about "suffering" to learn relate to the family's upbringing?
Jessa's comment is interpreted as a veiled criticism of the Duggar children's upbringing, suggesting their experiences are akin to "suffering" rather than just learning.
What are the three steps outlined by IBLP to conquer discouragement?
The steps are: 1. Remove guilt through repentance. 2. Take up the shield of faith. 3. Encourage the heart through Psalms.
How does Joe Duggar appear to be using scripture in his conversations with Kendra?
Joe repeatedly directs Kendra to scripture as an escape from reality and to avoid confronting the consequences of his actions, rather than for genuine comfort.
What are the core teachings of IBLP regarding emotions and discouragement?
IBLP teachings emphasize suppressing emotions and thoughts, viewing discouragement as a lie from Satan, and promoting denial as spiritual strength.
How does the podcast differentiate between healthy coping and denial in the context of IBLP teachings?
The podcast argues that IBLP promotes denial by teaching individuals to suppress feelings and escape reality, contrasting with healthy coping that involves acknowledging and processing emotions.
What is the significance of the Artemis 2 mission discussed in the podcast?
The Artemis 2 mission is highlighted as a positive scientific achievement and inspiration, symbolizing progress and expanded opportunities in STEM fields.
What personal nostalgic memories are shared by the hosts?
The hosts share nostalgic memories tied to early 2000s music, like Good Charlotte and Blink-182, and associated experiences from their youth.
Show Notes
It's safe to say that we are thrilled with the number of felines in this episode. Not to mention the lack of Josh compared to last week. The brood is silly with cats! They found two kittens, named them, and then found three more. Even the electrician working on one of their houses found a kitten.
In our Dig, Whit explores the IBLP teachings on Discouragement. This came up due to Joe's released phone calls from jail. He goes on and on about reading the book of Psalms and how it makes him feel encouraged. Discouragement is something to be avoided at all costs, thus why "encouragement" carries such meaning in their cult, much like "character".
If you would like to support the work that we do, head on over to www.buymeacoffee.com/diggingupthedug where you can buy us a coffee, if you would just like to support us in a one-off fashion. Or you can support us monthly by becoming a member and then you will get access to our ad-free episodes and bonus content like Pickle episodes, Mildred Mondays, recipes, and two new types of posts; Tell Us Tuesdays and Foodie Fridays . We have a lot of fun over there with our community of Pickle People.
We have Merp, I mean Merch! over at
https://digging-up-the-duggars.dashery.com
Take a peek at our episode visuals and Mildred related contact at instagram.com/digginguptheduggarspod
Table of contents
United States
