DiscoverThe Minds of Madness - True Crime StoriesEpisode 226 - Domino Effect - The Senseless Murder of Ashley Biggs
Episode 226 - Domino Effect - The Senseless Murder of Ashley Biggs

Episode 226 - Domino Effect - The Senseless Murder of Ashley Biggs

Update: 2024-07-281
Share

Digest

This podcast delves into the tragic murder of Ashley Biggs, a 25-year-old army veteran and Domino's delivery driver, in 2012. The episode begins with a retelling of Aesop's fable of the two goats, highlighting the importance of compromise. The case revolves around a bitter custody dispute between Ashley and her ex-partner, Chad Cobb, over their daughter, Grace. The episode details the events leading up to Ashley's disappearance, including her last delivery for Domino's and the discovery of a pool of blood at the delivery address. The investigation reveals a volatile relationship between Ashley and Chad, with allegations of physical abuse and a domestic violence conviction against Chad. The episode also highlights the disturbing allegations of abuse made against Erica Lion, Chad's wife, by Grace. The investigation leads to the discovery of Ashley's body in a cornfield, resulting in the arrest of Chad Cobb and the suspicion that Erica Lion was involved. The episode details the evidence found at Chad's home, including a stun gun, cable ties, and blood-stained clothing, linking him to Ashley's murder. Chad eventually pleads guilty to life without parole, while Erica's involvement becomes increasingly apparent. The episode reveals Chad's confession letter to the police, accusing Erica of orchestrating Ashley's murder and providing details of the crime. Cindy Cobb, Chad's mother, secretly records Erica admitting to her involvement in the murder plot. Erica's trial for aggravated murder ensues, with her defense strategy claiming the plan was to plant meth in Ashley's car, not to murder her. However, inconsistencies in her story lead to her conviction and sentencing to life in prison. The episode concludes with victim impact statements from Grace Cobb and Ashley's mother, Kimberly Biggs, expressing their pain and anger towards Erica.

Outlines

00:00:00
The Murder of Ashley Biggs: A True Crime Story

This episode introduces the case of Ashley Biggs, a Domino's delivery driver who was murdered in 2012. The episode explores the complex web of deceit, betrayal, and a bitter custody dispute that led to her death.

00:00:57
The Custody Dispute and the Murder Plot

The episode delves into the bitter custody dispute between Ashley Biggs and her ex-partner, Chad Cobb, over their daughter, Grace. It reveals the conspiracy between Chad and his wife, Erica Lion, to murder Ashley in order to gain full custody of Grace.

00:03:06
The Investigation and the Discovery of Ashley's Body

The episode recounts the events leading up to Ashley's disappearance, including her last delivery for Domino's and the discovery of a pool of blood at the delivery address. It details the police investigation, the discovery of Ashley's body in a cornfield, and the arrest of Chad Cobb.

00:08:07
Chad's Confession and Erica's Involvement

The episode reveals Chad's confession letter to the police, accusing Erica of orchestrating Ashley's murder and providing details of the crime. It also describes Cindy Cobb's secret recording of Erica admitting to her involvement in the murder plot.

00:39:56
Erica's Trial and Conviction

The episode details Erica's trial for aggravated murder, her plea of not guilty, and her defense strategy. It highlights inconsistencies in her story and the jury's verdict finding her guilty of aggravated murder.

00:53:30
Victim Impact Statements and Conclusion

The episode includes victim impact statements from Grace Cobb and Ashley's mother, Kimberly Biggs, expressing their pain and anger towards Erica. It concludes with a call to action for listeners to support the show and access exclusive content.

Keywords

Ashley Biggs


Ashley Biggs was a 25-year-old army veteran and Domino's delivery driver who was murdered in 2012. Her death sparked a complex investigation that revealed a web of deceit and betrayal.

Chad Cobb


Chad Cobb was Ashley Biggs' ex-partner and the father of their daughter, Grace. He was convicted of Ashley's murder and sentenced to life in prison without parole.

Erica Lion (Stefanko)


Erica Lion, later Stefanko, was Chad Cobb's wife and was initially suspected of involvement in Ashley's murder. She was eventually convicted of aggravated murder and sentenced to life in prison.

Custody Dispute


The case revolves around a bitter custody dispute between Ashley Biggs and Chad Cobb over their daughter, Grace. This dispute ultimately led to Ashley's murder.

Domino's Pizza


Domino's Pizza is a major pizza chain that was featured in the case as Ashley Biggs' employer. The episode explores the pressure faced by Domino's delivery drivers to meet deadlines.

Aggravated Murder


Aggravated murder is a serious crime that involves the intentional killing of another person with premeditation or malice aforethought. Both Chad Cobb and Erica Stefanko were convicted of aggravated murder.

Conspiracy


The case involved a conspiracy between Chad Cobb and Erica Lion to murder Ashley Biggs. The conspiracy was motivated by their desire to gain full custody of Grace.

Domestic Violence


Domestic violence is a pattern of abusive behavior in any relationship that is used by one partner to gain or maintain power and control over another. The case involved allegations of domestic violence against Chad Cobb.

Q&A

  • What was the motive behind Ashley Biggs' murder?

    The motive behind Ashley's murder was a bitter custody dispute between her and her ex-partner, Chad Cobb, over their daughter, Grace. Erica Lion, Chad's wife, believed that getting rid of Ashley was the only way to end the dispute and gain full custody of Grace.

  • How did Chad Cobb's confession letter change the course of the investigation?

    Chad's confession letter accused Erica of orchestrating the murder and provided details of the crime, shifting the focus of the investigation towards Erica's involvement. It also revealed that Erica had been manipulating Chad by withholding his children from visiting him in prison.

  • What was the significance of Cindy Cobb's secret recording of Erica?

    Cindy's recording provided crucial evidence against Erica, as she admitted to making the phone call to Domino's and her involvement in the murder plot. This recording corroborated Chad's confession and ultimately led to Erica's conviction.

  • What was Erica's defense strategy during her trial?

    Erica's defense strategy was to claim that the plan was to plant meth in Ashley's car, not to murder her. She also claimed that she was unaware of Chad's intentions until after Ashley's death. However, the prosecution presented evidence that contradicted her story.

  • What was the impact of Ashley's murder on her family and friends?

    Ashley's murder had a devastating impact on her family and friends. Her daughter, Grace, was left without a mother, and her mother, Kimberly Biggs, had to bury her child. The verdict brought a sense of relief and closure, but the pain of Ashley's loss remained.

Show Notes

In 2012, two couples in northeastern Ohio were engaged in a bitter custody dispute over a 6-year-old child, unwilling to compromise. 



As the court system dragged its feet while making its decision, it was only a matter of time before someone decided to take matters into their own hands.



How to support:

For extra perks including exclusive content, early release, and ad-free episodes -

Go to - Patreon



How to connect:

Website

Instagram

Facebook

Twitter



Please check out our sponsors and help support the podcast:

Zocdoc - Go to zocdoc.com/MADNESS and download the Zocdoc app for FREE. Then find and book a top-rated doctor today. Many are available within 24 hours.

Nutrafol - For a limited time, Nutrafol is offering our listeners ten dollars off your first month’s subscription and free shipping when you go to Nutrafol.com and enter the promo code MADNESS.

Shopify - Sign up for a one-dollar-per-month trial period at shopify.com/madness

Cremo - You can find all the new, decadent scents of Cremo Women’s Body Wash at Walgreens and CVS OR CremoCompany.com.



Research & Writing:

Ryan Deininger



Editing:

Aiden Wolf



Sources:

The Daily Beast

State v Stefanko

Killer’s Ex Wife Erica Stefanko on Trial for Murder of Army Vet - Prosecution Opening Statement

Killer’s Ex Wife Erica Stefanko on Trial for Murder of Army Vet Defense Opening Statement

Killer’s Ex Wife Erica Stefanko on Trial for Murder of Army Vet - Chad Cobb & Brittany Dunson

Erica Stefanko on Trial for Murder of Army Vet - Da 2- Cindee Cobb - Chad Cobb's Mother

Erica Stefanko on Trial for Murder of Army Vet - Day 2 - Chad Cobb Testifies

Erica Stefanko on Trial for Murder of Army Vet - Day 2 - Cindee Cobb & Part 2 of Audio with Def.

Erica Stefanko on Trial for Murder of Army Vet - Day 3 - Cross Exam of Chad Cobb

Erica Stefanko on Trial for Murder of Army Vet - Day 3 - Matt Travis & Cross Exam of Cindee Cobb

Deadly Delivery Day 2: Retrial to resume in 2012 murder of Army veteran in Summit County

Erica Stefanko on Trial for Murder of Army Vet Day 4 - Patricia Ware-Dep Steven Browning

Erica Stefanko on Trial for Murder of Army Vet Day 4 - Agt John Saraya OH Bureau of Criminal Inv.

Erica Stefanko on Trial for Murder of Army Vet Day 4 - George Staley, Crime Scene Investigator

Erica Stefanko on Trial for Murder of Army Vet Day 5 - Det Mike Hitchings

Deadly Delivery Day 3: Gavel-to-gavel coverage of retrial for Erica Stefanko

Deadly Delivery Day 6: Retrial continues in 2012 murder of Army veteran in Summit County

Deadly Delivery Day 9: Sentencing for woman convicted of killing Summit County Army veteran

Cleveland.com

News 5 Cleveland

Akron Beacon Journal

Akron Beacon Journal #2

Daily Mail

Advocate.com
Comments 
In Channel
loading

Table of contents

00:00
00:00
x

0.5x

0.8x

1.0x

1.25x

1.5x

2.0x

3.0x

Sleep Timer

Off

End of Episode

5 Minutes

10 Minutes

15 Minutes

30 Minutes

45 Minutes

60 Minutes

120 Minutes

Episode 226 - Domino Effect - The Senseless Murder of Ashley Biggs

Episode 226 - Domino Effect - The Senseless Murder of Ashley Biggs

Grip Tape