Digest

This podcast delves into the chilling story of Sheila Lebar, a woman who used dating services to find vulnerable men, often with tragic consequences. The narrative begins with Stephen Martello, who encountered Sheila while hitchhiking and later discovered she was wanted for murder. Sheila's manipulative behavior and claims of wealth drew Stephen in, but his suspicions grew, leading him to escape her clutches. The story then shifts to Bill LaBar, a respected chiropractor who met Sheila through a personal ad. Despite their age difference, they began a relationship, but Sheila's controlling nature quickly became apparent. She isolated Bill from his family and friends, and her promiscuity became known throughout the community. Bill died at the age of 74, leaving Sheila a $2 million estate, raising questions about his death. Sheila's manipulative tendencies continued as she targeted Michael Delos, a vulnerable man with an intellectual disability, and Kenny County, a young man with a disability. She used psychological manipulation to control them, accusing them of being pedophiles and isolating them from their families. Both men disappeared, and their remains were later found on Sheila's farm. Sheila was eventually arrested and charged with the murders of Michael and Kenny. She pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity, claiming she was driven by delusions of being an avenging angel. However, the prosecution argued she was a psychopath who manipulated and murdered for her own pleasure. The jury found Sheila sane and guilty, sentencing her to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole. The case leaves many unanswered questions, including whether Sheila was a serial killer and the circumstances surrounding Bill LaBar's death. The discovery of human toes that did not belong to either victim raises further suspicion, leaving a chilling reminder of the darkness that can lurk beneath the surface of seemingly ordinary lives.

Outlines

00:01:02

Sheila Lebar's Dark Past and Early Victims

This chapter introduces Sheila Lebar and her history of manipulative behavior and violence. It details her encounters with Stephen Martello and other victims, highlighting her pattern of targeting vulnerable men.

00:07:28

Sheila's Relationship with Bill LaBar and His Death

This chapter focuses on Sheila's relationship with Bill LaBar, a respected chiropractor. It explores her controlling nature, her isolation of Bill from his family and friends, and the suspicious circumstances surrounding his death.

00:16:32

Sheila's Manipulation and Abuse of Michael Delos and Kenny County

This chapter details Sheila's manipulation and abuse of Michael Delos and Kenny County, both vulnerable men with disabilities. It highlights her pattern of isolating them, accusing them of being pedophiles, and ultimately leading to their disappearance.

00:29:40

Sheila's Arrest and the Evidence of Murder

This chapter describes Sheila's arrest and the discovery of evidence of murder on her farm. It details the gruesome bloodbath found inside the house and the human remains, including those of Kenny County and Michael Delos.

00:34:14

Sheila's Trial and Sentencing

This chapter covers Sheila's trial, her insanity defense, and the jury's verdict. It explores the arguments presented by both the prosecution and defense, and the ultimate outcome of Sheila's sentencing to life imprisonment.

00:39:51

Unanswered Questions and the Legacy of Sheila Lebar

This chapter reflects on the unanswered questions surrounding Sheila's case, including the possibility of her being a serial killer and the circumstances surrounding Bill LaBar's death. It highlights the chilling reminder of the darkness that can lurk beneath the surface of seemingly ordinary lives.

Keywords

Q&A

• What was Sheila Lebar's motive for killing Kenny County and Michael Delos?

  Sheila claimed she was driven by delusions, believing she was an avenging angel sent to rid the world of pedophiles. However, the prosecution argued she was a psychopath who manipulated and murdered for her own pleasure.

• How did Sheila manipulate her victims?

  Sheila targeted vulnerable men with disabilities, often isolating them from their families and friends. She would accuse them of being pedophiles, using psychological manipulation to control them.

• What evidence was found at Sheila's farm?

  Investigators found human remains, including those of Kenny County and Michael Delos, as well as blood stains throughout the house, indicating a gruesome bloodbath.

• What was the outcome of Sheila's trial?

  Sheila was found guilty of murder and sentenced to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole. The jury rejected her insanity defense, finding her sane at the time of the murders.

• What unanswered questions remain about Sheila Lebar's case?

  There are still questions about whether Sheila was a serial killer and the circumstances surrounding Bill LaBar's death. The discovery of human toes that did not belong to either victim raises further suspicion.

Show Notes