DiscoverWrong StationGeary Pond (by Shannon Farrell) | Decade of Dread #28
Geary Pond (by Shannon Farrell) | Decade of Dread #28

Geary Pond (by Shannon Farrell) | Decade of Dread #28

Update: 2025-10-291
Share

Digest

This podcast delves into the historical mystery surrounding Phineas Cartwright, a wealthy horse breeder who vanished in 1912 from his estate at Geary Conservation Area. Diver Lori Stoneman is tasked with exploring the area's pond for artifacts. She discovers evidence of a former settlement, including numerous horseshoes, leading to a dramatic underwater discovery: a mass graveyard of petrified horses and a carriage containing Cartwright's petrified body. The podcast also includes advertisements for Indeed and appeals for listener support for "The Wrong Station" podcast.

Outlines

00:00:00
The Mystery of Phineas Cartwright and the Geary Conservation Area Dive

The podcast explores the disappearance of Phineas Cartwright from his estate at Geary Conservation Area in 1912. Diver Lori Stoneman investigates the area's pond, uncovering clues like numerous horseshoes that suggest parts of the settlement may have sunk into the water. Her dive leads to the discovery of a mass graveyard of petrified horses and a carriage containing Cartwright's petrified body, solving the historical mystery.

00:00:30
Advertisements and Podcast Support

This section includes an advertisement for Indeed, a platform for hiring qualified candidates quickly, and an appeal for listener support for "The Wrong Station" podcast on Patreon, detailing benefits for patrons and providing production credits.

Keywords

Phineas Cartwright


The central figure of the historical mystery, a wealthy horse breeder who disappeared in 1912. His petrified body was found in a carriage at the bottom of a pond.

Geary Conservation Area


The location of the historical mystery, formerly Phineas Cartwright's estate and settlement, now a conservation area where a dive uncovers artifacts.

Diver


Lori Stoneman, the professional diver who explored the pond and made the significant discoveries related to Phineas Cartwright and the horses.

Petrifaction


The process by which organic matter turns to stone, observed in the petrified horses and Phineas Cartwright found underwater.

Historical Mystery


The unexplained disappearance of Phineas Cartwright and his horses, investigated through an underwater dive.

Artifacts


Objects of historical interest found during the dive, including horseshoes, a horse bridle, a carriage, and the petrified remains.

Indeed


An advertisement for a hiring platform that helps employers find candidates quickly through sponsored jobs.

The Wrong Station Podcast


The podcast series, which is seeking listener support on Patreon and provides production and music credits.

Q&A

  • Who was Phineas Cartwright and what happened to him?

    Phineas Cartwright was a wealthy horse breeder and former mayor of the area now known as Geary Conservation Area. He mysteriously disappeared in 1912, along with all his horses. His petrified body was later found in a carriage at the bottom of the pond.

  • What was discovered at the bottom of the pond in Geary Conservation Area?

    At the bottom of the pond, the diver discovered a mass graveyard of approximately 100 petrified horses, all fastened together by bridles. In the center was a carriage containing the petrified body of Phineas Cartwright.

  • Why was the diver, Lori Stoneman, sent to Geary Conservation Area?

    Lori Stoneman, a professional diver, was sent to Geary Conservation Area to investigate the pond for artifacts from the old settlement. The discovery of over 200 horseshoes along the bank suggested that parts of the settlement might have sunk into the water.

  • What is the significance of the horseshoes found at Geary Conservation Area?

    The discovery of over 200 horseshoes along a specific bank of the pond is significant because it provides a clue that parts of the settlement, possibly including stables or other structures, may have washed into the pond over time.

Show Notes

Enjoy 31 episodes in 31 days as Wrong Station celebrates a “Decade of Dread”.


// SOME HISTORY IS BEST LEFT BENEATH THE SURFACE.


// BUT WHAT'S BEST FOR US DOES NOT ALWAYS SATISFY.


// NOT PRIDE, NOR NEED FOR COLD CALM.




"Geary Pond," a dive into the murk you may regret. Written and performed by Shannon Farrell.


Celebrate 10 seasons of Wrong Station by subscribing to our Patreon atwww.patreon.com/thewrongstation⁠. Explore brand new benefits, hundreds of hours of bonus content, and help ensure Wrong Station stays on the air for another 10 years.




The Wrong Station contains explicit content and mature themes. Episode-specific warnings can be found at ⁠www.wrongstation.com/c-w.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Comments 
00:00
00:00
x

0.5x

0.8x

1.0x

1.25x

1.5x

2.0x

3.0x

Sleep Timer

Off

End of Episode

5 Minutes

10 Minutes

15 Minutes

30 Minutes

45 Minutes

60 Minutes

120 Minutes

Geary Pond (by Shannon Farrell) | Decade of Dread #28

Geary Pond (by Shannon Farrell) | Decade of Dread #28

The Wrong Station