How (Not) to Murder Your Husband: Inside the Story of Nancy Brophy
How (Not) to Murder Your Husband: Inside the Story of Nancy Brophy
5Digest
This episode of Killer Psyche delves into the case of Nancy Brophy, a romance novelist who was convicted of murdering her husband, Dan. The episode explores the evidence against her, including her writings, her behavior before and after the murder, and the lack of evidence at the crime scene. The episode also examines Nancy's possible motive, considering her personality, her relationship with Dan, and her writings. The episode features an interview with Heidi Trethaway, a Portland-based novelist who knew Nancy and provides insights into her personality and behavior. Heidi discusses Nancy's tendency to sensationalize her own life, her possible confusion of fiction with reality, and her potential motive for killing her husband. The episode also explores the psychology of murder, particularly in the context of a partner who snaps and kills their spouse. The episode concludes with a discussion of whether Nancy will ever confess to the crime, considering her narcissistic personality and her desire to maintain a positive image of herself.
Outlines
Introduction
This Chapter introduces the hosts of the podcast, Sachi Cole and Sarah Haggi, and the topic of the episode: the case of Nancy Brophy, a romance novelist convicted of murdering her husband, Dan.
Nancy Brophy's Case
This Chapter delves into the details of Nancy Brophy's case, including her background as a romance novelist, her writings, the evidence against her, and the circumstances surrounding her husband's murder. It also explores the media's portrayal of Nancy and the public's perception of her.
Exploring the Questions
This Chapter focuses on the questions that the podcast seeks to answer regarding Nancy Brophy's case, including whether she confused fiction with reality, whether investigators found clues to the murder in her novels, and whether she orchestrated the murder in the same way she plotted it in her books.
The Murder and the Evidence
This Chapter examines the details of Dan Brophy's murder, including the lack of evidence at the crime scene, the investigators' initial lack of leads, and the discovery of video footage that implicated Nancy. It also explores the contrasting personalities of Nancy and Dan and the nature of their relationship.
Keywords
Nancy Brophy
Nancy Brophy is a romance novelist who was convicted of murdering her husband, Dan Brophy, in 2018. She is known for her self-published novels and a 2011 blog post titled "How to Murder Your Husband." Her case gained significant media attention due to the unusual circumstances of the murder and her background as a writer.
Romance Novelist
A romance novelist is a writer who specializes in writing novels that focus on romantic relationships and love stories. These novels often feature elements of drama, suspense, and emotional intensity. Romance novels are a popular genre, with a wide range of subgenres, including contemporary romance, historical romance, paranormal romance, and erotic romance.
Murder
Murder is the unlawful killing of another human being with malice aforethought. It is a serious crime with severe legal consequences. Murder can be classified into different degrees, depending on the circumstances and intent of the perpetrator. First-degree murder is typically premeditated and intentional, while second-degree murder is intentional but not premeditated. Manslaughter is the unlawful killing of another human being without malice aforethought.
Narcissist
A narcissist is a person who has an inflated sense of self-importance, a need for admiration, and a lack of empathy for others. Narcissists often have a grandiose view of themselves and their abilities, and they may exploit others to meet their own needs. Narcissistic personality disorder is a mental health condition characterized by these traits.
Killer Psyche
Killer Psyche is a podcast that explores the psychology of murder and the minds of killers. The podcast delves into the motivations, behaviors, and thought processes of individuals who commit murder, examining the factors that contribute to their actions and the impact of their crimes on victims and society.
Happily Never After
Happily Never After is a podcast that tells the true stories of love, loss, and betrayal. The podcast explores the complexities of human relationships and the dark side of love, examining the motivations behind infidelity, murder, and other forms of betrayal.
Oregon Culinary Institute
The Oregon Culinary Institute (OCI) is a culinary school located in Portland, Oregon. It offers a variety of culinary programs, including associate degrees, diplomas, and certificates. OCI is known for its hands-on training and its focus on preparing students for careers in the culinary industry.
Portland, Oregon
Portland is the largest city in the state of Oregon and is known for its vibrant arts and culture scene, its thriving food scene, and its commitment to sustainability. Portland is also home to a number of notable landmarks, including the Oregon Zoo, the Portland Art Museum, and the International Rose Test Garden.
Retrograde Amnesia
Retrograde amnesia is a type of amnesia that affects memories from before the event that caused the amnesia. It can be caused by a variety of factors, including head injuries, strokes, and certain medical conditions. Retrograde amnesia can range in severity, from forgetting minor details to losing large chunks of one's life history.
Circumstantial Evidence
Circumstantial evidence is indirect evidence that suggests a fact but does not directly prove it. It is often used in criminal trials to support other evidence or to establish a chain of events. Circumstantial evidence can be very persuasive, but it must be carefully considered and weighed against other evidence in the case.
Q&A
What are some of the key pieces of evidence that led to Nancy Brophy's conviction?
The evidence against Nancy Brophy included her writings, particularly her blog post titled "How to Murder Your Husband," her behavior before and after the murder, and the lack of evidence at the crime scene, which suggested a planned and calculated act. Additionally, surveillance footage captured her minivan near the murder scene around the time of the murder.
What was Nancy Brophy's possible motive for killing her husband?
While the exact motive remains unclear, the podcast explores several possibilities, including financial gain, as Nancy stood to inherit a significant sum of money from Dan's life insurance policy. Additionally, her writings and her personality suggest a potential desire for attention and notoriety, which she might have sought through the murder and subsequent trial.
How did Nancy Brophy's personality and behavior contribute to her conviction?
Nancy's narcissistic personality, her tendency to sensationalize her own life, and her possible confusion of fiction with reality likely played a role in her conviction. Her combative and adversarial behavior during the trial, particularly her tendency to contradict the prosecution's narrative, may have alienated the jury.
What is the psychology behind a partner who snaps and kills their spouse?
The podcast distinguishes between a "snap" and a premeditated murder. A "snap" is often characterized by a build-up of stress, depression, or other factors that lead to a breaking point. In contrast, a premeditated murder is a planned and calculated act, often driven by motives such as financial gain, revenge, or a desire for control. Nancy's case is presented as an example of a premeditated murder, as there is no evidence to suggest that she "snapped".
Do you think Nancy Brophy will ever confess to the crime?
The podcast suggests that it is unlikely Nancy will ever confess to the crime due to her narcissistic personality. Confessing would tarnish her image and undermine her belief in her own innocence. She is more likely to continue maintaining her innocence, even in the face of overwhelming evidence.
Show Notes
In today’s Headlines, Candice is joined by novelist Heidi Tretheway, who was formerly a member of Brophy's writing group, and currently hosts the new Wondery limited series Happily Never After: Dan and Nancy. Together, they discuss possible reasons why Brophy committed such a horrible crime, and take a closer look at her behavior before and after the murder.
To hear more about the Nancy Brophy story, listen to Happily Never After: Dan and Nancy on the Wondery app or wherever you get your podcasts.
Wondery+ subscribers can binge all episodes early and ad-free right now https://wondery.com/shows/happily-never-after/
Need more Killer Psyche? With Wondery+, enjoy exclusive episodes, early access to new ones, and they’re always ad-free. Start your free trial in the Wondery App or visit wondery.app.link/TI5l5KzpDLb now.
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Table of contents
United States
