How Medicare fraud became Miami's vice
4Digest
This podcast delves into the phenomenon of Medicare fraud in Miami, exploring the factors that contribute to its prevalence. It begins by explaining the basics of Medicare, highlighting its vulnerability to fraud due to its size and reliance on faith. The episode then details various methods used to defraud Medicare, including exaggerating bills, faking treatments, and creating fake patients. The podcast investigates why Miami has become a hub for Medicare fraud, examining factors like the city's large elderly population, the presence of legitimate healthcare businesses, and the historical events that have shaped its culture. It highlights three major events in the 1970s and 1980s that significantly impacted Miami's culture and contributed to its reputation for fraud: a race riot, the rise of the cocaine trade, and a massive influx of Cuban migrants. The episode introduces the concept of an "overstory," a term coined by Malcolm Gladwell to describe the unspoken norms and rules that permeate a place. It argues that Miami has a particular overstory that influences the behavior of its residents, making them more susceptible to fraud. Finally, the podcast discusses the government's efforts to combat Medicare fraud, including the launch of a strike force in Miami in 2007. It also mentions the commutation of Philip S. Forms' sentence by former President Donald Trump, highlighting the complexities of addressing this issue.
Outlines
The Capital of Medicare Fraud
This episode explores the phenomenon of Medicare fraud in Miami, examining the factors that contribute to its prevalence. It delves into the history of the city, highlighting events that have shaped its culture and contributed to a climate conducive to fraud.
Understanding Medicare and its Vulnerability
This episode explains the basics of Medicare, the US's near-universal healthcare system for seniors and people with disabilities. It highlights the program's vast budget and its susceptibility to fraud due to its size and reliance on faith.
Methods of Medicare Fraud and Why Miami?
This episode details various methods used to defraud Medicare, including exaggerating bills, faking treatments, creating fake patients, and submitting invoices for non-existent medical equipment. It also discusses the creation of fake Medicare providers and the black market consultants who facilitate these schemes. The episode then investigates the reasons behind Miami's high rate of Medicare fraud, exploring factors like the city's large elderly population, the presence of legitimate healthcare businesses, and the historical events that have shaped its culture and created an environment conducive to fraud.
The Overstory of Miami and Government Efforts
This episode delves into the history of Miami, highlighting three major events in the 1970s and 1980s that significantly impacted the city's culture and contributed to its reputation for fraud. These events include a race riot, the rise of the cocaine trade, and a massive influx of Cuban migrants. The episode introduces the concept of an "overstory," a term coined by Malcolm Gladwell to describe the unspoken norms and rules that permeate a place. It argues that Miami has a particular overstory that influences the behavior of its residents, making them more susceptible to fraud. Finally, the episode discusses the government's efforts to combat Medicare fraud, including the launch of a strike force in Miami in 2007. It also mentions the commutation of Philip S. Forms' sentence by former President Donald Trump, highlighting the complexities of addressing this issue.
Keywords
Medicare Fraud
The illegal act of obtaining money or benefits from the Medicare program through deception, false claims, or other fraudulent means. It can involve various schemes, such as billing for services not provided, creating fake patients, or submitting invoices for non-existent medical equipment.
Overstory
A term coined by Malcolm Gladwell to describe the unspoken norms, rules, and cultural influences that permeate a place and shape the behavior of its residents. It refers to the collective understanding and shared assumptions that guide actions and interactions within a community.
Miami
A city in South Florida known for its vibrant culture, diverse population, and history of crime and corruption. It has been a hub for various illicit activities, including drug trafficking and Medicare fraud, due to factors such as its large elderly population, its history of social unrest, and its proximity to Latin America.
Cocaine Trade
The illegal trade of cocaine, a highly addictive stimulant drug. Miami became a major hub for the cocaine trade in the 1970s and 1980s, leading to widespread drug-related violence and corruption. This contributed to a climate of lawlessness and a disregard for ethical behavior, which may have facilitated the rise of Medicare fraud.
Cuban Migration
The influx of Cuban migrants to the United States, particularly to Miami, in the 1980s. This mass migration, often driven by political and economic instability in Cuba, led to significant social and economic changes in Miami, including an increase in crime rates. This influx of new residents, many of whom were unfamiliar with American laws and customs, may have created opportunities for fraudsters to exploit vulnerabilities in the system.
Q&A
What are some of the common methods used to defraud Medicare?
Medicare fraud can involve various schemes, such as exaggerating bills for services not provided, faking treatments, creating fake patients, and submitting invoices for non-existent medical equipment. It can also involve creating fake Medicare providers and using stolen provider identification numbers.
Why is Miami considered the capital of Medicare fraud?
Miami's high rate of Medicare fraud is attributed to factors such as its large elderly population, the presence of legitimate healthcare businesses, and its history of social unrest and corruption. The city's culture, shaped by events like the cocaine trade and Cuban migration, has created an environment conducive to fraud.
What is the "overstory" of Miami, and how does it contribute to fraud?
The "overstory" of Miami refers to the unspoken norms and rules that permeate the city and influence the behavior of its residents. It suggests that Miami has a culture that tolerates or even encourages certain types of unethical behavior, making it easier for fraudsters to operate.
What steps has the government taken to combat Medicare fraud?
The government has launched various initiatives to combat Medicare fraud, including the creation of strike forces in areas with high rates of fraud. However, the issue remains complex, and the government faces challenges in effectively policing the vast and intricate Medicare system.
Show Notes
Malcolm Gladwell was fascinated by this case and the prospect of a city changing a man. He covers this in his forthcoming book Revenge of the Tipping Point: Overstories, Superspreaders, and the Rise of Social Engineering.
Today on the show: How Miami became known as the capital of Medicare fraud. We learn what went wrong in South Florida and what it says about how places may change our behavior.
Related Episodes:
Book drama, NVIDIA hype, and private equity Football
How Pitbull got his name on a college football stadium
For sponsor-free episodes of The Indicator from Planet Money, subscribe to Planet Money+ via Apple Podcasts or at plus.npr.org.
Music by Drop Electric. Find us: TikTok, Instagram, Facebook, Newsletter.
Learn more about sponsor message choices: podcastchoices.com/adchoices
NPR Privacy Policy
Table of contents
United States
