How NAFTA Broke American Politics
18Digest
This podcast delves into the complex history and consequences of the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), focusing on its impact on American politics. The episode begins by tracing the origins of NAFTA back to the 1970s, examining the debate surrounding its passage in 1993, and analyzing the consequences of the trade deal, including job losses in manufacturing, the rise of income inequality, and the shift in political power dynamics. The podcast then delves into the personal story of Chancey Adams, a Milwaukee worker who experienced the devastating impact of NAFTA firsthand. Chancey's journey highlights the human cost of job losses and factory closures in the Rust Belt, as well as the political realignment that followed. The episode concludes by examining the lasting legacy of NAFTA and its impact on American politics. It discusses how the trade deal contributed to the rise of economic nationalism and the realignment of both the Democratic and Republican parties. The podcast highlights the complex and multifaceted legacy of NAFTA, emphasizing the need for trade policies that prioritize worker rights and economic fairness.
Outlines
NAFTA: The Trade Deal that Shaped American Politics
This episode explores the impact of the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) on American politics, specifically its role in the realignment of the Democratic and Republican parties. The episode traces the origins of NAFTA back to the 1970s and examines the debate surrounding its passage in 1993. It then analyzes the consequences of NAFTA, including job losses in manufacturing, the rise of income inequality, and the shift in political power dynamics.
The Human Cost of NAFTA: A Milwaukee Story
The episode delves into the personal story of Chancey Adams, a Milwaukee worker who experienced the impact of NAFTA firsthand. Chancey's journey highlights the devastating consequences of job losses and factory closures in the Rust Belt, as well as the political realignment that followed.
The Lasting Legacy of NAFTA
The episode concludes by examining the lasting legacy of NAFTA and its impact on American politics. It discusses how the trade deal contributed to the rise of economic nationalism and the realignment of both the Democratic and Republican parties.
Keywords
NAFTA
The North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) is a trade agreement signed by Canada, Mexico, and the United States in 1993. It aimed to eliminate tariffs and other trade barriers between the three countries, promoting free trade and economic integration.
Deindustrialization
The process of decline in industrial activity in a region or country, often characterized by factory closures, job losses, and economic decline.
Rust Belt
A region in the northeastern and midwestern United States that was once heavily industrialized but has experienced significant economic decline due to factors such as deindustrialization and globalization.
Economic Nationalism
A political ideology that emphasizes the importance of national economic self-sufficiency and protectionism, often advocating for policies that restrict foreign trade and investment.
Working Class
A social class composed of people who perform manual labor or work in blue-collar jobs, often characterized by lower wages and less job security compared to higher-income earners.
Globalization
The process of increasing interconnectedness and interdependence among nations, driven by factors such as trade, technology, and cultural exchange.
Income Inequality
The uneven distribution of income within a society, often measured by the gap between the richest and poorest individuals or households.
Q&A
How did NAFTA contribute to the realignment of the Democratic and Republican parties?
NAFTA led to a shift in the Democratic Party's focus away from its traditional working-class base towards a more professional and wealthier constituency. This created an opening for the Republican Party to embrace a working-class rhetoric, even though their policies often did not align with those promises.
What were the main arguments for and against NAFTA during the 1992 presidential campaign?
Supporters of NAFTA argued that it would boost exports, create jobs, and increase economic growth. Opponents argued that it would lead to job losses in manufacturing, lower wages, and exploitation of workers in Mexico.
How did the passage of NAFTA impact Chancey Adams' life and career?
Chancey Adams, a Milwaukee worker, experienced the consequences of NAFTA firsthand. He lost his job at Master Lock when the plant closed after decades of operation. He was forced to take on multiple jobs to make ends meet, highlighting the human cost of trade deals that prioritize economic growth over worker well-being.
What is the lasting legacy of NAFTA on American politics?
NAFTA's legacy is complex and multifaceted. It contributed to the rise of economic nationalism, the realignment of both major political parties, and the growing divide between the working class and the elite. It also highlighted the need for trade policies that prioritize worker rights and economic fairness.
Show Notes
On the campaign trail, Donald Trump and Kamala Harris are constantly talking about trade, tariffs and domestic manufacturing.
In many ways, these talking points stem from a single trade deal that transformed the U.S. economy and remade both parties’ relationship with the working class.
Dan Kaufman, a contributing writer for The New York Times Magazine, explains how the North American Free Trade Agreement broke American politics.
Guest: Dan Kaufman, the author of “The Fall of Wisconsin,” and a contributing writer for The New York Times Magazine.
Background reading:
- How NAFTA broke American politics.
- Both Democrats and Republicans are expressing support for tariffs to protect American industry, reversing decades of trade thinking in Washington.
For more information on today’s episode, visit nytimes.com/thedaily. Transcripts of each episode will be made available by the next workday.
Unlock full access to New York Times podcasts and explore everything from politics to pop culture. Subscribe today at nytimes.com/podcasts or on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.
Table of contents
United States
