DiscoverPlanet MoneyHow to fix a housing shortage
How to fix a housing shortage

How to fix a housing shortage

Update: 2024-08-308
Share

Digest

This episode of Planet Money delves into the complexities of building new housing in Minneapolis, a city grappling with a significant housing shortage. The episode introduces the concept of "Missing Middle" housing, which refers to small to mid-size apartment buildings often overlooked in development. These buildings are crucial for addressing affordability and providing more efficient housing options than single-family homes or large apartment complexes. The episode follows Cody Fisher, a real estate developer passionate about building energy-efficient, carbon-smart housing, as he navigates the challenges of constructing "Missing Middle" housing in Minneapolis. The city's 2040 plan, which aims to eliminate single-family zoning and promote denser housing, is a key factor in this effort. However, the plan faces opposition from NIMBYs (Not In My Backyard) who fear the impact of new development on their neighborhoods. The episode highlights the conflict between YIMBYs (Yes In My Backyard), who advocate for increased housing density, and NIMBYs, who often oppose new development. The episode showcases a new four-story apartment building in Minneapolis, a prime example of the "Missing Middle" housing the city is trying to encourage. However, this building faced significant opposition from neighbors concerned about its impact on their neighborhood. The episode explores the limitations of local government in addressing the housing crisis, highlighting the need for a more regional approach. The episode also examines the generational divide in environmentalism, with older generations often viewing development as harmful to the environment, while younger generations prioritize climate change mitigation through denser housing. The episode concludes with Cody Fisher's renewed efforts to build his apartment building, emphasizing the ongoing challenges and the need for continued progress in addressing the housing shortage. The episode highlights the importance of state intervention in limiting legal challenges to the city's housing plan, emphasizing the need for a more regional approach to addressing the housing crisis.

Outlines

00:00:00
Building New Housing in Minneapolis

This episode explores the challenges of building new housing in Minneapolis, a city with ambitious plans to address its housing shortage. The episode introduces the concept of "Missing Middle" housing, which refers to small to mid-size apartment buildings that are often overlooked in housing development.

00:03:53
The "Missing Middle" Housing Debate

The episode delves into the "Missing Middle" housing concept, highlighting its importance in addressing housing shortages and providing more affordable options than single-family homes. The episode also discusses the challenges of building this type of housing, including opposition from NIMBYs and the need for more regional solutions.

00:08:05
YIMBYs vs. NIMBYs: The Housing Development Conflict

The episode explores the clash between YIMBYs (Yes In My Backyard) and NIMBYs (Not In My Backyard) in the context of housing development. The episode highlights the challenges of balancing local residents' concerns with the need for more housing, and the role of local and state governments in addressing the housing crisis.

00:15:48
Environmental Concerns and the Future of Housing

The episode examines the environmental challenges and concerns surrounding housing development, highlighting the generational divide in environmentalism and the need for a more sustainable approach to housing. The episode also discusses the role of state intervention in addressing the housing crisis and the need for a more regional approach.

Keywords

Missing Middle Housing


Housing types between single-family homes and large apartment buildings, like duplexes, triplexes, and small apartment buildings. Often overlooked in development, but crucial for addressing housing shortages.

YIMBY


"Yes In My Backyard" movement advocating for increased housing density and development to address affordability and housing shortages.

NIMBY


"Not In My Backyard" movement opposing new development in their neighborhoods, often citing concerns about traffic, noise, and property values.

Infill Development


Redeveloping existing urban areas with new housing, often replacing older structures with denser housing to increase housing supply.

Housing Density


The number of housing units per unit of land. Higher density can reduce sprawl, improve access to amenities, and reduce carbon emissions.

Climate Change Mitigation


Actions taken to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and limit the effects of climate change. Denser housing can contribute to climate change mitigation by reducing transportation needs and energy consumption.

Local Government


Government at the city or county level, responsible for zoning, planning, and development approvals. Often face challenges in balancing local concerns with regional needs.

State Government


Government at the state level, responsible for setting broader policies and regulations. Can play a role in addressing regional issues like housing shortages.

Q&A

  • What is "Missing Middle" housing and why is it important?

    "Missing Middle" housing refers to small to mid-size apartment buildings that are often overlooked in development. These types of housing are crucial for addressing housing shortages because they provide more affordable options than single-family homes and are more efficient than large apartment buildings.

  • How does the Minneapolis 2040 plan aim to address the city's housing shortage?

    The Minneapolis 2040 plan aims to address the city's housing shortage by eliminating single-family zoning, promoting denser housing, and streamlining development approvals. The plan also includes policies to address racial justice and climate change.

  • What are the challenges of balancing local residents' concerns with the need for more housing?

    Balancing local residents' concerns with the need for more housing is a complex issue. Local residents often oppose new development due to concerns about traffic, noise, and property values. However, the need for more housing is a regional issue that affects everyone, not just those living in the immediate vicinity of new development.

  • How does the generational divide in environmentalism affect housing development?

    Older generations often view development as harmful to the environment, while younger generations prioritize climate change mitigation through denser housing. This generational divide can create conflict over housing development, as older generations may oppose new development while younger generations see it as a way to address climate change.

  • What role can state governments play in addressing the housing crisis?

    State governments can play a significant role in addressing the housing crisis by setting broader policies and regulations that encourage more housing development. State governments can also provide funding and resources to support local governments in their efforts to address housing shortages.

Show Notes

When Cody Fischer decided to get into real estate development, he had a vision. He wanted to build affordable, energy efficient apartments in Minneapolis, not far from where he grew up.

His vision was well-timed because, in 2019, Minneapolis's city council passed one of the most ambitious housing plans in the nation. One aim of that plan was to alleviate the city's housing shortage by encouraging developers like Cody to build, build, build.

But when Cody tried to build, he ran into problems. The kinds of problems that arise all over the country when cities confront a short supply of housing, and try to build their way out.

Today on the show, NIMBYism, YIMBYism and why it's so hard to fix the housing shortage. Told through the story of two apartment buildings in Minneapolis.

This episode was hosted by Amanda Aronczyk and Kenny Malone. It was produced by Emma Peaslee and Sofia Shchukina, and edited by Molly Messick. It was engineered by James Willets and fact-checked by Sierra Juarez. Alex Goldmark is Planet Money's executive producer.

Help support
Planet Money and hear our bonus episodes by subscribing to Planet Money+ in Apple Podcasts or at plus.npr.org/planetmoney.

Learn more about sponsor message choices: podcastchoices.com/adchoices

NPR Privacy Policy
Comments (1)

Michelle Griswold

let me guess the people that don't want the new building are Boomers.

Sep 2nd
Reply
00:00
00:00
x

0.5x

0.8x

1.0x

1.25x

1.5x

2.0x

3.0x

Sleep Timer

Off

End of Episode

5 Minutes

10 Minutes

15 Minutes

30 Minutes

45 Minutes

60 Minutes

120 Minutes

How to fix a housing shortage

How to fix a housing shortage