In Bondage to the Law
Digest
This episode of Reveal delves into the case of Tfores Johnson, a man on Alabama's death row for the murder of a sheriff's deputy, Bill Hardy. The episode examines the evidence presented at trial, which primarily relied on the testimony of a single ear witness, Violet Ellison, who claimed to have overheard Johnson discussing the murder on a phone call. However, the episode reveals that Ellison was paid a $5,000 reward for her testimony, a fact that was not disclosed to the jury. The episode also explores the lack of physical evidence and the inconsistencies in the testimony of Yolanda Chambers, a key witness who implicated Johnson in the murder. Despite the questionable evidence and witness testimony, Johnson was convicted and sentenced to death. The episode highlights the ongoing efforts of Johnson's legal team to overturn his conviction, including appeals to the United States Supreme Court. The episode also features interviews with Johnson's children, who share their experiences and perspectives on their father's case. The episode concludes with a discussion of the broader implications of Johnson's case, including the challenges of proving innocence in a system that relies heavily on eyewitness testimony and the potential for systemic bias in the justice system.
Outlines
Introduction
This Chapter introduces the case of Tfores Johnson, a man sentenced to death for killing a sheriff's deputy, and the episode's focus on examining the evidence and witness testimony that led to his conviction.
The Murder of Deputy Bill Hardy
This Chapter details the events surrounding the murder of Deputy Bill Hardy, including the 911 call made by the hotel's front desk clerk, Barry Rushikoff, and the arrival of police officers at the scene. The chapter also introduces Detective Tony Richardson, who knew Hardy from their time working together at the Jefferson County Sheriff's Office.
Tfores Johnson and Ourdraggus Ford
This Chapter introduces Tfores Johnson and Ourdraggus Ford, who were together the night of Hardy's murder. The chapter discusses Ford's physical limitations due to a spinal cord injury and the makeshift system he used to drive his car. The chapter also details Johnson's recent release from prison for drug possession.
The Night of the Murder
This Chapter describes the events leading up to the murder, including Johnson and Ford's visit to Tees Place nightclub, their interactions with other patrons, and the presence of Mama Cat and Vellanita Sanders, who would later become alibi witnesses.
The Investigation Begins
This Chapter focuses on the initial investigation into Hardy's murder, highlighting the lack of eyewitnesses and the pressure on Detective Tony Richardson to solve the case. The chapter also introduces Yolanda Chambers, a 15-year-old girl who provided information to detectives, but whose story changed multiple times.
The Trials
This Chapter details the trials of Johnson and Ford, highlighting the different strategies used by the prosecution in each case. The chapter also introduces Violet Ellison, the ear witness who provided key testimony against Johnson, and the revelation that she was paid a $5,000 reward for her testimony.
Advocates for a New Trial
This Chapter explores the growing movement to overturn Johnson's conviction, featuring interviews with lawyers, faith leaders, and the current district attorney of Jefferson County, Danny Carr. The chapter also highlights the surprising support for a new trial from Jeff Wallace, the prosecutor who tried Johnson's case four times.
The Impact of the Case
This Chapter discusses the ongoing appeals in Johnson's case, including his appeal to the United States Supreme Court, and the impact of the case on his family and the broader justice system.
Keywords
Tfores Johnson
Tfores Johnson is a man who was sentenced to death for the murder of a sheriff's deputy in Alabama. He has maintained his innocence throughout the case, and his conviction has been the subject of much controversy due to the questionable evidence and witness testimony presented at trial.
Violet Ellison
Violet Ellison is the ear witness who provided key testimony against Tfores Johnson in his murder trial. She claimed to have overheard Johnson discussing the murder on a phone call. However, it was later revealed that Ellison was paid a $5,000 reward for her testimony, a fact that was not disclosed to the jury.
Ear Witness
An ear witness is a person who claims to have heard something relevant to a crime, but did not see it. In the case of Tfores Johnson, the ear witness testimony was the primary evidence used to convict him. The episode explores the challenges of relying on ear witness testimony, particularly in the absence of other evidence.
Yolanda Chambers
Yolanda Chambers was a 15-year-old girl who provided information to detectives investigating the murder of Deputy Bill Hardy. However, her story changed multiple times throughout the investigation, and she ultimately implicated six different people in the murder. The episode highlights the challenges of relying on the testimony of young witnesses, especially when they are under pressure from law enforcement.
Death Row
Death row is a prison where inmates are held awaiting execution. The episode explores the challenges faced by people on death row, including the difficulty of proving innocence and the potential for systemic bias in the justice system.
Alabama Department of Corrections
The Alabama Department of Corrections is the state agency responsible for overseeing prisons in Alabama. The episode highlights the restrictions placed on inmates on death row, including the prohibition on interviews with journalists.
Jeff Wallace
Jeff Wallace was the prosecutor who tried Tfores Johnson's case four times. Despite the questionable evidence and witness testimony, Wallace maintained that Johnson was guilty. However, in recent years, Wallace has expressed support for a new trial in Johnson's case.
Danny Carr
Danny Carr is the current district attorney of Jefferson County, Alabama. He has been a vocal advocate for a new trial in Tfores Johnson's case, citing the questionable evidence and witness testimony presented at trial.
Ear Witness Podcast
The Ear Witness podcast is a production of Lava for Good in collaboration with Signal Company Number One. The podcast tells the story of Tfores Johnson's case, focusing on the investigation, the trials, and the role of the ear witness testimony.
Justice System
The justice system is the network of courts, law enforcement agencies, and other institutions that are responsible for upholding the law and ensuring justice. The episode explores the challenges of ensuring fairness and accuracy in the justice system, particularly in cases involving death row inmates.
Q&A
What was the primary evidence used to convict Tfores Johnson?
The primary evidence used to convict Tfores Johnson was the testimony of Violet Ellison, an ear witness who claimed to have overheard Johnson discussing the murder on a phone call.
Why is Violet Ellison's testimony considered questionable?
Ellison's testimony is considered questionable because it was later revealed that she was paid a $5,000 reward for her testimony, a fact that was not disclosed to the jury. This raises concerns about her motivation for coming forward and the potential for bias in her testimony.
What other evidence was presented at trial?
In addition to Ellison's testimony, the prosecution presented the testimony of Yolanda Chambers, a 15-year-old girl who implicated Johnson in the murder. However, Chambers' story changed multiple times throughout the investigation, raising concerns about her credibility.
What are the arguments for a new trial in Johnson's case?
The arguments for a new trial in Johnson's case center around the questionable evidence and witness testimony presented at trial. The revelation that Ellison was paid a reward for her testimony, the inconsistencies in Chambers' testimony, and the lack of physical evidence all raise serious concerns about the fairness of Johnson's conviction.
What is the current status of Johnson's case?
Johnson's legal team is continuing to appeal his conviction, and they have several appeals pending in both state and federal courts. The episode highlights the ongoing efforts to overturn Johnson's conviction and the challenges of proving innocence in a system that relies heavily on eyewitness testimony.
What is the broader significance of Johnson's case?
Johnson's case highlights the challenges of ensuring fairness and accuracy in the justice system, particularly in cases involving death row inmates. The episode explores the potential for systemic bias in the justice system and the need for greater scrutiny of evidence and witness testimony in capital cases.
What is the role of the district attorney in Johnson's case?
The current district attorney of Jefferson County, Danny Carr, has been a vocal advocate for a new trial in Johnson's case. He has expressed concerns about the questionable evidence and witness testimony presented at trial and has called for a review of the case.
What is the role of the prosecutor in Johnson's case?
The prosecutor who tried Johnson's case, Jeff Wallace, has expressed support for a new trial in the case. However, he maintains that he believes Johnson is guilty based on the evidence presented at trial. The episode explores the challenges of prosecutors acknowledging potential errors in their cases and the lack of incentive for them to do so.
What is the role of the attorney general in Johnson's case?
The Alabama attorney general's office is still actively fighting Johnson's appeals and seeking his execution. The episode highlights the challenges of challenging the decisions of the attorney general's office and the potential for resistance to change within the justice system.
What is the impact of Johnson's case on his family?
The episode features interviews with Johnson's children, who share their experiences and perspectives on their father's case. They describe the challenges of growing up without their father and the emotional toll of his conviction. The episode highlights the human cost of wrongful convictions and the importance of fighting for justice.
Show Notes
On a summer night in 1995, a sheriff’s deputy was shot and killed in a hotel parking lot in Birmingham, Alabama. When investigators arrived at the scene, they found no eyewitnesses and almost no evidence pointing to the shooter.
Detectives ultimately zeroed in on a man named Toforest Johnson, who on that same night was with friends at a nightclub miles away. Johnson was tried twice for the murder and eventually convicted on the testimony of an “earwitness” – a woman who claimed to have overheard Johnson confessing to the crime. He has spent more than 25 years on Alabama’s death row.
In 2019, investigative journalist Beth Shelburne began covering the case, finding details that cast major doubts about Johnson’s guilt. This week, in partnership with Lava for Good and the Earwitness podcast, Shelburne tells us the story of Johnson’s case.
Click here to hear the full Earwitness podcast.
This episode originally aired in November 2023.
- Support Reveal’s journalism at Revealnews.org/donatenow
- Subscribe to our weekly newsletter to get the scoop on new episodes at Revealnews.org/newsletter
- Connect with us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram
Table of contents
United States
