DiscoverGood GuysJesse Metcalfe Stole Josh's Girlfriend
Jesse Metcalfe Stole Josh's Girlfriend

Jesse Metcalfe Stole Josh's Girlfriend

Update: 2026-03-12
Share

Digest

The podcast begins by discussing dining etiquette, particularly the debate around who orders for the table and the importance of personal food preferences regardless of who pays. Hosts explore the nuances of ordering, eating for fuel versus pleasure, and the benefits of home cooking. They share favorite home-cooked meals and discuss decision fatigue, partner preferences, and meal planning strategies like using freezer meals. The conversation touches on the inconvenience of not defrosting meat and evolves into a detailed discussion on food safety, especially concerning raw chicken handling and the evolution of these practices. The episode then introduces guest Jesse Metcalfe, discussing his acting career, iconic roles, and the challenges of public perception. Metcalfe also promotes his new skincare line, "Neutral," highlighting its clean ingredients and collagen-boosting properties, and shares anecdotes about his career and encounters with tabloid media. The latter part of the podcast features "weird news" segments, including bizarre food products like Reese's peanut butter cup toothpaste and a debate on fluoride in toothpaste. A pet peeve about people claiming not to be "dessert people" is discussed, followed by a segment on Shia LaBeouf's public image. The episode concludes with a call to action for listeners to rate the podcast and a reading of a positive listener review.

Outlines

00:00:00
Dining Etiquette, Food Preferences, and Home Cooking

The podcast opens with a discussion on dining etiquette, focusing on who orders for the table and the importance of personal food choices. Hosts explore the concept of eating for fuel versus pleasure, the advantages of home cooking, and share favorite home-cooked meals. They also touch upon decision fatigue, partner preferences in dining, and meal planning strategies like utilizing freezer meals.

00:06:50
Food Safety and Evolving Practices

The conversation shifts to food safety, specifically the meticulous handling of raw chicken due to E. coli concerns. Hosts discuss how food safety practices have become more stringent over time, moving from basic handwashing to more elaborate precautions.

00:08:47
Guest Introduction: Jesse Metcalfe and Sponsor Segment

The hosts introduce actor Jesse Metcalfe, expressing admiration and hinting at his new skincare line. The podcast also features a sponsor segment for IM8 Health, a daily essentials drink.

00:11:30
Jesse Metcalfe's Career, Roles, and Public Perception

Jesse Metcalfe discusses his acting career, including notable roles in "Desperate Housewives" and "John Tucker Must Die," and how these characters shaped his public image. He addresses the recurring theme of playing characters named "John" and the transition from soap operas to primetime television.

00:15:16
Physique Pressure, Supplements, and Skincare Line "Neutral"

Metcalfe shares insights into the pressure to maintain a physique for on-screen roles and openly discusses his use of supplements, TRT, and peptides. The focus then shifts to his skincare line, "Neutral," highlighting its clean ingredients, collagen-boosting properties, and positive reception.

00:19:16
Humorous Anecdotes and Media Scrutiny

A humorous anecdote about Jesse Metcalfe's past nickname and a serendipitous reunion on a plane are shared. Metcalfe discusses shedding public personas, the rise of online tabloid media, and the psychology behind believing negative press, expressing his skepticism towards media portrayals.

00:26:25
Brand Collaboration and "Weird News" Segments

Jesse Metcalfe announces a collaboration between Sprit Society and Kiehl's. The podcast then delves into "weird news," including a new banana pudding creation and Reese's peanut butter cup toothpaste. A debate on fluoride in toothpaste and a pet peeve about people not liking dessert are also discussed.

00:46:10
"What Do You Know It's Moment" and Listener Engagement

The "What Do You Know It's Moment" segment focuses on the public perception of Shia LaBeouf. The hosts encourage listeners to rate the podcast and read a positive listener review.

Keywords

Dining Etiquette


Rules and customs for polite behavior during meals, including ordering and table manners.

Decision Fatigue


Mental exhaustion from making too many choices, leading to avoidance or poor decisions.

Food Safety


Practices to prevent foodborne illnesses, covering handling, storage, and preparation.

Skincare Line


A range of products for skin care, often targeting aging or specific skin concerns.

Tabloid Media


Sensationalized news and gossip focusing on celebrities, often prioritizing clicks over accuracy.

Fluoride in Toothpaste


The use of fluoride in dental hygiene products to prevent cavities and strengthen enamel.

Brand Collaboration


Partnerships between brands to create joint products or marketing campaigns.

Jesse Metcalfe


Actor known for roles in "Desperate Housewives" and "John Tucker Must Die," and creator of the skincare line "Neutral."

Home Cooking


Preparing meals at home, often discussed in contrast to dining out for health and cost benefits.

Food Safety Practices


Evolving methods for handling food safely, particularly raw chicken, to prevent contamination.

Q&A

  • What is the main point of contention regarding ordering food at a restaurant?

    The main point of contention is whether it's acceptable for one person to order for the entire table, or if individuals should have the autonomy to choose and order their own meals, regardless of who is paying.

  • How has the approach to food safety, particularly with raw chicken, evolved?

    Food safety practices have become more stringent, moving from basic handwashing to more elaborate precautions like using gloves and designated preparation areas to prevent contamination.

  • What is Jesse Metcalfe's stance on supplements and TRT?

    Jesse Metcalfe openly discusses his use of supplements, TRT, and peptides as part of his fitness regimen at 46, emphasizing transparency about his health practices.

  • What is the significance of the "Neutral" skincare line?

    The "Neutral" skincare line, developed by Jesse Metcalfe, focuses on clean, simple, and effective products, including collagen-boosting serums, designed to simplify skincare routines.

  • What are the hosts' main gripes in the "What-Ya-Nuts" segment?

    The hosts express frustration with people who claim not to be "dessert people," arguing that everyone enjoys dessert and that such a claim indicates a lack of common ground.

  • What is the key takeaway regarding Shia LaBeouf's public perception?

    The hosts argue against the notion that Shia LaBeouf is "about that life," emphasizing his background as a theater kid and actor from shows like "Even Stevens" and "Transformers."

Show Notes

He might’ve been one of Hollywood’s most infamous bad boys on screen, but today we’re finding out who Jesse Metcalfe really is. This week, we sit down with the man behind John Tucker Must Die to talk early-2000s fame, tabloid chaos, questionable restaurant habits, and his new skincare line. Plus, Josh tells the unbelievable story of the time Jesse unknowingly stole his girlfriend - and the two finally clear the air years later. What are ya nuts?! 




Check out Nutrl Skin HERE


Follow Jesse on Instagram




Follow us on Instagram and TikTok




Sponsors:




For a limited time, Home Chef is offering my listeners FIFTY PERCENT OFF and free shipping for your first box PLUS free dessert for life! Go to HomeChef.com/goodguys 




Give your body what it deserves with IM8! Go to IM8HEALTH.com/GOODGUYS and use code GOODGUYS for a Free Welcome Kit, five free travel sachets plus ten percent off your order.




If you like your money, Mint Mobile is for you. Shop plans at MINTMOBILE.com/goodguys 




Start building your credit the easy way. Go to Super.com/credit right now to see how Super+ can help you boost your credit score.




To get simple, online access to personalized, affordable care for ED, Hair Loss, Weight Loss, and more, visit Hims.com/GOODGUYS 




Please note that this episode may contain paid endorsements and advertisements for products and services. Individuals on the show may have a direct or indirect financial interest in products or services referred to in this episode.




Produced by Dear Media.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Comments 
00:00
00:00
x

0.5x

0.8x

1.0x

1.25x

1.5x

2.0x

3.0x

Sleep Timer

Off

End of Episode

5 Minutes

10 Minutes

15 Minutes

30 Minutes

45 Minutes

60 Minutes

120 Minutes

Jesse Metcalfe Stole Josh's Girlfriend

Jesse Metcalfe Stole Josh's Girlfriend

Dear Media