Digest

The podcast "The Deck Investigates" returns for a new season, focusing on the case of Ada Herodine, the "Three of Clubs" from Indiana. The investigation began with a tip about a possible connection between the Darling Holes case and other unsolved cases in the area, referred to as the "Sheila Letters." These letters suggested a pattern based on the initials of the victims, leading Ashley to investigate Ada Herodine's case. Ashley received an email from McKenna Herodine, Ada's granddaughter, who expressed interest in the case and highlighted the similarities between Ada's disappearance and the Darling Holes case. McKenna offered to be a point of contact for the investigation. While Ashley initially concluded that the Darling Holes case and Ada's case are not connected, she emphasizes that the investigation into Ada's disappearance is a compelling story in its own right. The episode details Ada's life as a quiet woman who lived a fulfilling life as a wife and mother. On May 8, 1985, Ada disappeared after a day filled with routine activities and interactions with family and friends. The episode recounts the events following Ada's disappearance, including Jeff's discovery of the unlocked front door and Ada's absence, the initial search efforts by Ed, Susan, and Jeff, and the growing concern as Ada remains missing. The episode also highlights the family's hope for a ransom demand, but instead, they receive a silent phone call, further fueling their fears and anxieties. The season promises a deep dive into the mystery that has haunted a family for generations, exploring the events leading up to Ada's disappearance, the family's search efforts, and the unanswered questions surrounding her fate.

Outlines

00:00:00

The Case of Ada Herodine: A New Season of "The Deck Investigates"

Britt announces the new season of "The Deck Investigates" focusing on the case of Ada Herodine, the "Three of Clubs" from Indiana. She highlights the extensive investigation by Ashley and Nina and teases the intriguing details of the case.

00:02:20

The Sheila Letters and the Connection to Ada Herodine

Ashley discusses a tip she received about a possible connection between the Darling Holes case and other unsolved cases in the area. This tip, referred to as the "Sheila Letters," proposed a pattern based on the initials of the victims, leading Ashley to investigate the case of Ada Herodine.

00:07:38

Ada Herodine's Disappearance: A Deep Dive into the Mystery

Ashley formally introduces season two of "The Deck Investigates," focusing on the case of Ada Herodine. She sets the stage for the investigation, promising a deep dive into the mystery that has haunted a family for generations. The episode details Ada's life as a quiet woman who lived a fulfilling life as a wife and mother. On May 8, 1985, Ada disappeared after a day filled with routine activities and interactions with family and friends. The episode recounts the events following Ada's disappearance, including Jeff's discovery of the unlocked front door and Ada's absence, the initial search efforts by Ed, Susan, and Jeff, and the growing concern as Ada remains missing. The episode also highlights the family's hope for a ransom demand, but instead, they receive a silent phone call, further fueling their fears and anxieties.

Keywords

Q&A

• What is the connection between the Darling Holes case and Ada Herodine's case?

  While Ashley initially believes the cases are not connected, the investigation into Ada's disappearance reveals intriguing similarities and potential connections that will be explored throughout the season.

• Why did McKenna Herodine reach out to Ashley?

  McKenna, Ada's granddaughter, was a listener of "The Deck Investigates" and was struck by the similarities between her grandmother's case and the Darling Holes case. She reached out to Ashley, hoping to shed light on her grandmother's disappearance.

• What was the significance of the silent phone call received by Ed Herodine?

  The silent phone call, received after Ada's disappearance, added to the family's fear and uncertainty. It raised questions about the nature of the disappearance and whether Ada was still alive.

• What are some of the key details about Ada Herodine's life and disappearance?

  Ada was a quiet woman who lived a fulfilling life as a wife and mother. She disappeared on May 8, 1985, after a day filled with routine activities and interactions with family and friends. Her disappearance remains a mystery, with no clear explanation for her absence.

Show Notes