Not an Internet Error: How 404 Media Aims to Shake Up Online Journalism
Digest
This podcast delves into the world of worker-owned media outlets, using 404 Media as a case study. Samantha Cole, co-founder of 404 Media, discusses the outlet's origins, its worker-owned model, and its commitment to producing impactful journalism. She highlights the importance of avoiding outside investment and the benefits of a lean team. Cole details 404 Media's achievements in its first year, including breaking scoops, going viral, and influencing public policy. She highlights stories about AI-generated child sexual abuse material, NVIDIA's data scraping practices, and the MTA's security loophole. Cole discusses the challenges of AI-generated content and deepfakes, particularly in relation to Microsoft's AI text image generation tool and Facebook's monetization model. She explains how 404 Media combats AI-generated plagiarism and addresses the challenges of discoverability for new outlets. Cole also discusses the challenges and rewards of running a worker-owned media outlet, emphasizing the importance of community support and the benefits of direct control over content and finances. She explains 404 Media's revenue model, which relies on advertising and subscriptions, and shares the number of paid subscribers and the different subscription tiers. Cole discusses 404 Media's financial performance in its first year, including the initial investment and the gradual increase in revenue. She outlines plans for future investments, including commissioning stories and expanding the RSS feed. Cole discusses the challenges facing the media industry, including mass layoffs and the decline of traditional advertising models. She expresses optimism about the future of subscriber-led journalism and the potential for 404 Media to thrive in this evolving landscape. Cole acknowledges the potential for subscription fatigue in the news industry, but emphasizes the importance of providing high-quality content and direct reader feedback. She believes that 404 Media's model offers a sustainable path forward.
Outlines
Worker-Owned Media and 404 Media
This chapter introduces the concept of worker-owned media outlets, highlighting Helgate and Defector as examples. It discusses Danny Funt's article on the worker-owned model for the Columbia Journalism Review and introduces 404 Media, a worker-owned news outlet founded by former Motherboard reporters.
404 Media: A Worker-Owned News Outlet
Samantha Cole, co-founder of 404 Media, discusses the origins of the outlet, its worker-owned model, and its commitment to producing impactful journalism. She emphasizes the importance of avoiding outside investment and the benefits of a lean team.
404 Media's Impactful Journalism and AI Challenges
This chapter covers 404 Media's achievements in its first year, including breaking scoops, going viral, and influencing public policy. It highlights stories about AI-generated child sexual abuse material, NVIDIA's data scraping practices, and the MTA's security loophole. Cole discusses the challenges of AI-generated content and deepfakes, particularly in relation to Microsoft's AI text image generation tool and Facebook's monetization model.
Managing a Worker-Owned Media Outlet and the Future of News
This chapter discusses the challenges and rewards of running a worker-owned media outlet, emphasizing the importance of community support and the benefits of direct control over content and finances. Cole explains 404 Media's revenue model, which relies on advertising and subscriptions, and shares the number of paid subscribers and the different subscription tiers. She discusses 404 Media's financial performance in its first year, including the initial investment and the gradual increase in revenue. She outlines plans for future investments, including commissioning stories and expanding the RSS feed. Cole discusses the challenges facing the media industry, including mass layoffs and the decline of traditional advertising models. She expresses optimism about the future of subscriber-led journalism and the potential for 404 Media to thrive in this evolving landscape. Cole acknowledges the potential for subscription fatigue in the news industry, but emphasizes the importance of providing high-quality content and direct reader feedback. She believes that 404 Media's model offers a sustainable path forward.
Keywords
Worker-Owned Media
A media organization where journalists own and control the company, often with a focus on independent and ethical reporting.
AI-Generated Content
Text, images, or other media created using artificial intelligence algorithms, raising concerns about authenticity, plagiarism, and ethical implications.
Deepfakes
AI-generated videos or images that convincingly depict real people performing actions they did not actually perform, often used for malicious purposes.
Subscriber-Led Journalism
A model of journalism where revenue is primarily generated through subscriptions from readers, allowing for greater independence and control over content.
Discoverability
The ability for content to be easily found and accessed by users, a significant challenge for new media outlets competing with established platforms.
Subscription Fatigue
The phenomenon of consumers becoming overwhelmed by the number of subscription services they are required to pay for, potentially impacting the viability of new subscription-based media outlets.
404 Media
A worker-owned news outlet focused on producing impactful journalism, particularly in the areas of technology and culture.
Q&A
What inspired the creation of 404 Media?
The co-founders, former Motherboard reporters, wanted to create a worker-owned outlet that allowed them to produce impactful journalism without the constraints of corporate ownership.
How does 404 Media's worker-owned model differ from traditional media companies?
404 Media is owned and operated by its journalists, giving them direct control over content, finances, and editorial decisions, unlike traditional media companies with corporate structures and outside investors.
What are some of the challenges 404 Media has faced in its first year?
404 Media has faced challenges related to discoverability, AI-generated plagiarism, and the need to balance original reporting with business operations.
How does 404 Media address the issue of AI-generated content?
404 Media has implemented strategies to combat AI-generated plagiarism, including subscriber walls and a focus on producing high-quality, human-generated content.
What is 404 Media's vision for the future of news?
404 Media believes that subscriber-led journalism offers a sustainable model for the future of news, allowing for greater independence and direct engagement with readers.
Show Notes
Last summer, OTM host Micah Loewenger reported a piece about the rise of worker-owned newsrooms: Hell Gate, a local New York publication, and Defector, a national outlet focused on sports and culture.
Inspired by Defector and Hell Gate, more worked-owned outlets have come on the scene — including 404 Media, known for its mix of fun internet coverage and hard-nosed investigations. In this week’s midweek podcast, Micah speaks to 404 co-founder Samantha Cole about the challenges they have faced since they started their own outlet. Plus, what their success can teach us about the future of news.
On the Media is supported by listeners like you. Support OTM by donating today (https://pledge.wnyc.org/support/otm). Follow our show on Instagram, Twitter and Facebook @onthemedia, and share your thoughts with us by emailing onthemedia@wnyc.org.
Table of contents
United States
