In this special one-off episode we step back in time to unravel one of the oldest and most perplexing missing child cases in American history. This episode delves into the mysterious vanishing of nine-year-old Catherine Winters from New Castle, Indiana, in 1913, a case that has captivated and baffled investigators for over a century.

The episode begins with an overview of the historical context of New Castle in the early 20th century, setting the stage for the fateful day of Catherine's disappearance. We explore the events leading up to the day she went missing, piecing together the last known movements and sightings of the young girl. The narrative unfolds through a blend of historical records, eyewitness accounts, and expert interviews, painting a vivid picture of the community's shock and the extensive search efforts that ensued.

As the investigation of Catherine's disappearance unfolds, we examine the various theories and suspects that emerged over the years. The episode delves into the challenges faced by law enforcement at the time, the limitations of early 20th-century investigative techniques, and the impact of sensational media coverage on public perception and the course of the investigation.

We also bring to light the emotional toll on Catherine's family and the New Castle community, who never ceased in their quest for answers. The episode features interviews with historians, descendants of those involved in the case, and law enforcement experts who provide insights into why the mystery of Catherine Winters has endured for so long and what it reveals about the evolution of missing persons investigations.

Listeners are invited to join this historical journey at itsfoulplay.com, where the conversation continues with additional resources and discussions on the case. "The Lost Girl of New Castle – Catherine Winters' 1913 Disappearance" is not just a retelling of a cold case; it's an exploration of the enduring quest for truth and the timeless nature of hope in the face of the unknown. Join us as we step back in time to uncover the story of Catherine Winters, the lost girl of New Castle.


Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/foul-play-crime-series/donations

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands