Digest

This podcast delves into the perplexing case of Bob Gill, a successful bar owner in Columbus, Ohio, who vanished in September 1994. His van was found abandoned miles away, and his body was later discovered in a rural pasture, dressed in black clothing and carrying burglary tools. The podcast explores Bob's rise to success, his troubled final months, and the circumstances surrounding his disappearance. It examines the initial investigation, the bizarre details of his death, and the subsequent events that unfolded. The podcast introduces Marty McNamy, Bob's business partner, who became the sole owner of the bars after Bob's death. In August 1995, Marty claimed he was kidnapped, robbed, and tied to a tree by two men, one of whom he identified as Monroe Liggett. However, the discovery of Monroe Liggett's burned body in the basement of Marty's home revealed that he had been stabbed to death, making his death a homicide. The podcast explores the unanswered questions surrounding the case, including the identity of the second man involved in Marty's alleged kidnapping and the possibility that Marty fabricated his story. It also details Marty's criminal history, including his indictment for tax and mail fraud, as well as conspiracy and money laundering. The podcast leaves listeners with a sense of intrigue and unanswered questions, highlighting the complexities of the case and the lingering mysteries surrounding Bob Gill's death.

Outlines

00:00:13

The Mysterious Death of Bob Gill and the Unraveling of a Business Partnership

This chapter introduces the case of Bob Gill, a successful bar owner in Columbus, Ohio, who mysteriously disappeared in September 1994. His van was found abandoned 80 miles away, and his body was later discovered in a rural pasture, dressed in black clothing and carrying burglary tools. The chapter also introduces Marty McNamy, Bob's business partner, who became the sole owner of the bars after Bob's death.

00:04:18

Bob Gill's Rise to Success and the Troubled Events Leading to His Disappearance

This chapter delves into Bob Gill's early life and his entrepreneurial journey. He started his career by taking over a struggling bar, the Outer Inn, and turned it into a thriving business. He later expanded his ventures by acquiring a restaurant and transforming it into a popular sports bar. The chapter also explores the events leading up to Bob's disappearance, including a sexual harassment lawsuit filed against him and the annulment of his second marriage.

00:14:35

The Disappearance and the Initial Investigation

This chapter details the circumstances surrounding Bob's disappearance. He was last seen on September 25th or 26th, 1994. His van was found abandoned in Gernsey County, Ohio, and his body was discovered in a nearby cow pasture. The chapter focuses on the initial investigation into Bob's death, including the discovery of a nine-millimeter shell casing in his van and a loaded handgun on his body.

00:30:59

The Bizarre Circumstances of Bob's Death and the Unanswered Questions

This chapter examines the unusual details surrounding Bob's death. He was found dressed in black clothing, wearing a ski mask, and carrying burglary tools. The lack of signs of a struggle and the fact that he was shot in the head led investigators to believe he was killed where he was found. The chapter also explores the unanswered questions surrounding the case, including the identity of the second man involved in Marty's alleged kidnapping and the possibility that Marty fabricated his story.

00:45:45

Marty McNamy's Story and the Discovery of Monroe Liggett's Body

This chapter introduces Marty McNamy's story about his alleged kidnapping, robbery, and assault by two men, one of whom he identified as Monroe Liggett. The chapter reveals the discovery of Monroe Liggett's burned body in the basement of Marty's home and the subsequent investigation that revealed he had been stabbed to death.

00:54:06

Marty McNamy's Criminal Past and the Aftermath

This chapter details Marty McNamy's criminal history, including his indictment for tax and mail fraud, as well as conspiracy and money laundering. He admitted to skimming receipts from the bars and destroying records. The chapter also discusses the aftermath of the case, including Marty's sentence and the lingering mysteries surrounding Bob Gill's death.

Keywords

Q&A

• What were the unusual circumstances surrounding Bob Gill's death?

  Bob Gill was found dead in a rural pasture, dressed in black clothing and carrying burglary tools. He had been shot in the head, and there were no signs of a struggle. The location of his body and the items found on him raised questions about whether he was the victim or the perpetrator of a crime.

• What was Marty McNamy's story about his kidnapping?

  Marty McNamy claimed he was kidnapped, robbed, and tied to a tree by two men, one of whom he identified as Monroe Liggett. He said the men doused him with gasoline and robbed him of $5,000 cash.

• What was the outcome of the investigation into Monroe Liggett's death?

  An autopsy revealed that Monroe Liggett had been stabbed to death, making his death a homicide. The identity of the second man, known only as Carl, remains unknown.

• What was Marty McNamy's criminal history?

  Marty McNamy was later indicted for tax and mail fraud, as well as conspiracy and money laundering. He admitted to skimming receipts from the bars and destroying records. He was sentenced to 36 months in prison and ordered to pay over $500,000 in restitution.

• What are some of the unanswered questions surrounding the case?

  The identity of the second man, known only as Carl, remains unknown. The possibility that Marty fabricated his story about the kidnapping is also discussed. The motive for Bob Gill's murder remains unclear.

Show Notes