DiscoverProperty and Freedom PodcastPFP293 | Benjamin Marks, On H.L. Mencken as a Libertarian Model (PFS 2012)
PFP293 | Benjamin Marks, On H.L. Mencken as a Libertarian Model (PFS 2012)

PFP293 | Benjamin Marks, On H.L. Mencken as a Libertarian Model (PFS 2012)

Update: 2025-05-26
Share

Description

Property and Freedom Podcast, Episode 293.


Benjamin Marks (Australia), On H.L. Mencken as a Libertarian Model.


This lecture is from the 2012 meeting of the Property and Freedom Society. PFS 2012 Playlist. Text of article on which the speech was based is below; docx; pdf. Speech. Transcript also below.


Grok summary of article: H.L. Mencken’s conservatism, as explored in Benjamin Marks’ essay, is a defining trait that sets him apart as a libertarian thinker who held low expectations for societal reform. Unlike typical conservatism, Mencken’s brand is rooted in a deep skepticism of government and religion, viewing them as historically optimistic overreaches that clash with true conservative doubt. He saw many societal problems as insoluble or unlikely to be addressed due to human folly, yet found entertainment in the pretentiousness of events and the futility of reform efforts. His libertarianism was not driven by a desire to convert others but by a commitment to truth, expressed through sharp, clear prose that prioritized self-expression over activism.



Mencken’s approach was neither nihilistic nor despairing; he embraced the world’s flaws with a light-hearted cynicism, finding joy in critiquing its absurdities without expecting change. He believed people’s gullibility and resistance to reason made libertarian ideals unattainable in the near term, a view reinforced by his observations of failed revolutions and reforms that often worsened conditions. Marks argues that Mencken’s consistent, principled stance—free of moral indignation—offers libertarians a radical perspective: not as a competing utopianism, but as a clear-eyed rejection of romantic solutions. His influence, though significant in literature and culture, never popularized libertarianism, underscoring his realism about human nature and societal inertia.


Grok summary of transcript:


Two-Paragraph Summary for Show Notes

0:009:00 The speaker begins by expressing gratitude for being invited to the Property and Freedom Society conference, acknowledging the late Neville Kennard, fervent supporter who passed away in June. Kennard, despite his frail condition, remained passionate about libertarianism, wearing Rothbard “Enemy of the State” shirt during the <span cla
Comments 
In Channel
loading
00:00
00:00
1.0x

0.5x

0.8x

1.0x

1.25x

1.5x

2.0x

3.0x

Sleep Timer

Off

End of Episode

5 Minutes

10 Minutes

15 Minutes

30 Minutes

45 Minutes

60 Minutes

120 Minutes

PFP293 | Benjamin Marks, On H.L. Mencken as a Libertarian Model (PFS 2012)

PFP293 | Benjamin Marks, On H.L. Mencken as a Libertarian Model (PFS 2012)

The Property and Freedom Society