Have you every heard this question?

“Can someone with no project management background successfully run a PMO?”

Half of all PMOs fail within three years, at least that’s what some studies claim. Many of those failures could be traced back to leadership. But what kind of leadership matters most?

In this PM Debate throwback, Mary Elizabeth and I went head-to-head on one of the most controversial questions in our field:

“An organization that appoints a PMO leader with no experience in project management and no track record in PMOs is doomed to fail.”

Mary Elizabeth argued for the motion, experience is essential.I argued against, leadership, influence, and organizational fit matter more.

We explored:

* Whether industry and cultural understanding can compensate for limited PM knowledge

* The difference between technical expertise and leadership capability

* Why some PMOs thrive under unconventional leaders while others collapse under experts

It’s a conversation that’s just as relevant today, especially as PMOs evolve to balance firefighting and foundation-building.

🎧 Listen to the full episode: PM Debate Podcast – “An Inexperienced PMO Leader Is Doomed to Fail”

#CtrlAltPMO #PMODebate #Leadership #ProjectManagement #PMOPodcast #RapidStartPMO

Thanks for reading Project Management Matters! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit philipdiab.substack.com