Pitchin’ Movies With The Sound Off

Welcome to the premiere episode of Pitchin’ Movies With The Sound Off, where hosts Marcus and Tra$h Dog do what Hollywood would never dare — pitch a movie about someone they barely know, based entirely on a YouTube video filmed in a basement.

This week’s cinematic masterpiece: How Gerald Died, the totally real and completely unnecessary biopic of Leo Sayer, the blue-eyed king of soul you might only know from An Extremely Goofy Movie.

Expect chaotic “research,” questionable casting, and a full-blown cinematic universe that starts (and probably ends) right here.

🎬 In This Episode

• 
  

  The heroic fire rescue that starts it all

  
  


• 
  

  Casting Hugh Grant, Jesse Eisenberg, and Joe Keery in roles they didn’t ask for

  
  


• 
  

  The “Beatles Scene” that could get us sued

  
  


• 
  

  Clown symbolism, character deaths, and unearned emotional payoffs

  
  

👕 Grab Some Totally Real Merch

👉 https://totallyrealbands.com

💰 Support the Show on Patreon

👉 https://www.patreon.com/cw/PitchinMoviesWithTheSoundOff

🎧 Follow for New Episodes Every Week

Early access, shoutouts, and behind-the-scenes chaos await our patrons.

🔖 Episode Chapters

00:00:00 Intro: “We did ourselves dirty”

00:00:18 The “elevator pitch” (and why it won’t be short)

00:00:36 Theme sting: “Mr. Boom, sound off”

00:00:48 “We’re rolling… but not really”

00:01:04 How the show will actually start

00:01:19 Welcome to Pitchin’ Movies With The Sound Off

00:02:01 Accountability, three cameras, and backyard chaos

00:02:16 The handshake: holding each other to the project

00:02:39 Why Episode 1 is hard (live research)

00:03:15 What this show does (and maybe with guests)

00:03:57 Hotline joke and bit

00:04:07 The movie: a Leo Sayer biopic

00:04:35 Songs we know (“You Make Me Feel Like Dancing,” “I Can Dance”)

00:05:12 Stop addressing camera → into story mode

00:06:59 Discovery by David Courtney & Adam Faith

00:08:12 Wikipedia and donations riff

00:10:01 Cameos & a music-universe idea (Beatles?)

00:12:17 Opening image of the film: the fire

00:13:03 Budget note for the explosion

00:14:01 Period piece vibes (1968)

00:15:10 Tone: thriller/dramedy structure

00:15:25 Favorite Goose (band) tangent

00:17:28 Where “Leo” comes from (name bit)

00:18:10 First flash-forward: studio with Daltrey

00:19:11 Metaphor: “Gerald” dies in the blast

00:20:07 “Sleazy” Courtney bit + disclaimer rule

00:22:02 Title locked: How Gerald Died

00:22:36 AD BREAK — TotallyRealBands.com (merch walkthrough)

00:24:58 Back to show; restating title & tone

00:26:11 Opening credits plan + “Give It All Away”

00:27:25 Roger walks in; accent soup

00:28:05 Casting Roger Daltrey → Hugh Grant

00:29:12 Clarifying: Leo Sayer is the subject

00:32:17 Casting Leo Sayer → Jesse Eisenberg

00:33:23 Setting the studio scene (three guys)

00:36:25 “Gerald doesn’t sell”—the name change

00:37:03 Internal monologue/narration idea

00:37:25 Back to the blaze; media montage concept

00:38:46 Rise montage → hits & stubble era

00:40:09 Beatles gag (all in unison)

00:41:41 Into the flames: saving residents

00:42:14 Pivot to the most important reveal

00:43:19 Adam Faith twist (supportive → smarmy)

00:44:32 The clown performance seed

00:45:18 Where the ending image comes from

00:46:08 Theme: once a hero, forever chasing it

00:47:06 Goofy Movie, finances, and managers

00:48:15 Casting Adam Faith → Joe Keery

00:50:07 Love interests: Janice & Donatella

00:52:02 Mistress casting vibe (Donna Pinciotti type)

00:52:36 Muppets beat → embracing the bit

00:53:10 Resolution shape

00:54:17 Budget/FX for the opener

00:55:14 Outro sting