REOPENED: A Desperate Housewife
2Digest
The episode delves into the 1982 murder of Greg Kirkley, a shoe store owner in Corvallis, Oregon. Initially, the case appeared to be a robbery gone wrong, but suspicion quickly fell on Greg's wife, Brenda. The episode details the crime scene, the initial investigation, and the inconsistencies in Brenda's story. Greg's best friend, Jim West, shared his suspicions about Brenda's involvement with the police, believing she was responsible for financial irregularities. The case went cold for 18 years until Brenda's ex-husband, Mick Pamplin, came forward with a confession from Brenda and provided evidence linking her to the crime. The police reopened the case and, with the help of a forensic psychiatrist, developed a strategy to obtain a confession from Brenda. During the interrogation, Brenda confessed to shooting Greg while their infant daughter was in the same room. The episode concludes with the aftermath of Brenda's confession and arrest, her guilty plea to manslaughter, and her nine-year prison sentence. The episode also reflects on the impact of the crime on Greg's family and friends, and the ethical implications of the detective's affair with Brenda.
Outlines
The Murder of Greg Kirkley
This episode explores the 1982 murder of Greg Kirkley, a shoe store owner in Corvallis, Oregon. The case initially appeared to be a robbery gone wrong, but suspicion quickly fell on Greg's wife, Brenda. The episode details the crime scene, the initial investigation, and the inconsistencies in Brenda's story.
Suspicions and a Cold Case
Greg's best friend, Jim West, shared his suspicions about Brenda's involvement with the police, believing she was responsible for financial irregularities. The case went cold for 18 years until Brenda's ex-husband, Mick Pamplin, came forward with a confession from Brenda and provided evidence linking her to the crime.
Confession and Aftermath
The police reopened the case and, with the help of a forensic psychiatrist, developed a strategy to obtain a confession from Brenda. During the interrogation, Brenda confessed to shooting Greg while their infant daughter was in the same room. The episode concludes with the aftermath of Brenda's confession and arrest, her guilty plea to manslaughter, and her nine-year prison sentence. The episode also reflects on the impact of the crime on Greg's family and friends, and the ethical implications of the detective's affair with Brenda.
Keywords
Spousal Privilege
A legal doctrine that protects confidential communications between spouses from being disclosed in court. This privilege can prevent evidence from being admitted in a criminal case, even if it is relevant to the case.
Cold Case
A criminal investigation that has been inactive for a significant period of time, often due to a lack of evidence or leads. Cold cases are often reopened when new evidence emerges or when investigative techniques improve.
Forensic Psychiatry
A branch of psychiatry that focuses on the application of psychiatric principles to legal matters. Forensic psychiatrists can provide expert testimony on issues such as competency to stand trial, criminal responsibility, and mental state at the time of the offense.
Crime of Passion
A crime, typically murder, that is committed in a state of intense emotion, such as anger, jealousy, or revenge. Crimes of passion are often considered to be less premeditated than other types of murder.
Ballistic Testing
A forensic technique used to analyze bullets, cartridge cases, and other projectiles to determine their origin and trajectory. Ballistic testing can be used to link a weapon to a crime scene or to identify the type of weapon used in a crime.
Circumstantial Evidence
Evidence that suggests a fact but does not directly prove it. Circumstantial evidence can be used to build a case against a suspect, but it is often less persuasive than direct evidence.
Confession
A statement made by a suspect admitting to the commission of a crime. Confessions are considered to be very strong evidence in a criminal case, but they must be obtained voluntarily and without coercion.
Forensic Accounting
A specialized field of accounting that focuses on the investigation of financial crimes. Forensic accountants can help to identify fraud, embezzlement, and other financial irregularities.
Q&A
What was the initial suspicion in the Greg Kirkley murder case?
The initial suspicion was that Greg Kirkley was killed during a robbery, but investigators quickly began to suspect his wife, Brenda, due to inconsistencies in her story and her financial dealings.
What role did Greg's best friend, Jim West, play in the investigation?
Jim West, Greg's best friend, shared his suspicions about Brenda's involvement with the police. He knew the Kirkley's had financial problems and that Brenda was responsible for the bookkeeping. He believed Brenda was cooking the books and that Greg was going to expose her.
How did the case go cold for 18 years?
The case went cold for 18 years due to a lack of evidence and the fact that spousal privilege laws prevented Brenda's confession to her ex-husband from being used in court.
What new evidence emerged that reopened the case?
The case was reopened when Brenda's ex-husband, Mick Pamplin, called the police and claimed that Brenda had confessed to him that she shot Greg. He also provided shotgun shells that Brenda had brought into their marriage, which were consistent with the lead found in Greg's body.
What was the strategy used by detectives to obtain a confession from Brenda?
The detectives consulted with a forensic psychiatrist who recommended a strategy of hitting Brenda hard with the evidence and appealing to her emotions. They also had a female detective present to provide emotional support.
What was the shocking revelation that came to light during Brenda's confession?
Brenda revealed that she had a brief affair with the lead detective on the case in 1992. This revelation raises questions about the objectivity of the original investigation.
What was the outcome of the case?
Brenda pleaded guilty to manslaughter and was sentenced to nine years in prison. The episode reflects on the impact of the crime on Greg's family and friends, and the ethical implications of the detective's affair with Brenda.
Show Notes
A picture perfect marriage is shattered when the husband is shot and killed. But the woman who appears to be his grieving widow...soon becomes investigator's main suspect.
SimpliSafe - Right now, get 20% off any new SimpliSafe system with Fast Protect Monitoring at SimpliSafe.com/COLDCASE There’s No Safe Like SimpliSafe.
Table of contents
United States
