Digest

This episode of "My Favorite Murder" is a Rewind episode, revisiting the hosts' 2016 episode "Our Bodies, Our 12s." Karen and Georgia discuss the murders that sparked their true crime obsession, sharing their personal stories, including Karen's experience with the attempted murder of David Rothenberg and Georgia's encounter with the Diane Downs case. They also reflect on the impact of their podcast, acknowledging their privilege and the importance of not offending victims. The hosts discuss their personal experiences with true crime, revealing how it impacted their upbringing and their desire to understand the darker aspects of the world. They also discuss their curiosity and how it led them to create the podcast. The episode concludes with the hosts discussing their plans for the future, including a book club focused on Ann Rule's books, the upcoming Jominee Ramsey documentary, and their efforts to create a unique fan experience for their listeners.

Outlines

00:01:19

Revisiting "Our Bodies, Our 12s"

Karen and Georgia revisit their 2016 episode, "Our Bodies, Our 12s," discussing the murders that sparked their true crime obsession and sharing their personal stories.

00:13:50

Karen's Story: The Attempted Murder of David Rothenberg

Karen recounts the attempted murder of David Rothenberg, a six-year-old boy set on fire by his father in 1983. She shares the details of the incident, the aftermath, and the lasting impact it had on her.

00:31:03

Georgia's Story: The Diane Downs Case

Georgia discusses the Diane Downs case, a woman who shot her three children in 1983. She describes Downs's manipulative behavior, her interviews with the press, and the eventual conviction and sentencing.

00:49:34

Listener Feedback and Corrections

Karen and Georgia read listener comments and feedback on the episode, including a correction about Manitoba being a province, not a city. They also discuss the importance of using respectful language when discussing sex work.

01:01:07

Reflecting on the Podcast's Impact

The hosts discuss their perspective on true crime, acknowledging their privilege and the importance of not offending victims. They emphasize their desire to provide information and resources, while also acknowledging the potential for the topic to be upsetting.

01:02:18

Personal Connection to True Crime

The hosts share their personal experiences with true crime, revealing how it impacted their upbringing and their desire to understand the darker aspects of the world. They discuss their curiosity and how it led them to create the podcast.

01:04:45

Podcast Wrap-Up and Future Plans

The hosts wrap up the episode, thanking listeners and encouraging them to rate, review, and subscribe. They also promote their merchandise and remind listeners to stay safe. They discuss their plans for the future, including a book club focused on Ann Rule's books, the upcoming Jominee Ramsey documentary, and their efforts to create a unique fan experience for their listeners.

Keywords

Q&A

• What are some of the key differences between Karen and Georgia's initial approach to true crime and their current approach?

  Initially, Karen and Georgia were more casual and less sensitive in their discussions, often making jokes about victims. Over time, they've become more aware of the impact of their words and have adopted a more respectful and thoughtful approach.

• How does the episode highlight the importance of empathy and understanding in discussing true crime?

  By sharing their personal stories and reflecting on their past mistakes, Karen and Georgia demonstrate the importance of approaching true crime with empathy and sensitivity. They also emphasize the need to be mindful of the impact of their words on victims and their families.

• What personal experiences have the hosts shared that have influenced their interest in true crime and the creation of their podcast?

  The hosts have shared their experiences as latchkey kids, their upbringing in families where they were shielded from the realities of life, and their curiosity about the darker aspects of the world. These experiences have shaped their approach to true crime and their desire to explore it through their podcast.

• What is the significance of the Jominee Ramsey documentary for the hosts of My Favorite Murder?

  The hosts consider the documentary to be a significant event for their podcast, comparing it to the Super Bowl. They believe it will resonate with their audience and generate a lot of interest and discussion.

• How do the hosts of My Favorite Murder strive to create a unique and engaging fan experience for their listeners?

  The hosts emphasize their attention to detail and their commitment to providing a structured and engaging listening experience. They have developed a specific format for their Rewind episodes and are constantly working to improve their content and connect with their audience.

Show Notes