Digest

This episode of "Rewind with Karen and Georgia" takes listeners on a journey through the early days of "My Favorite Murder." The hosts revisit episode four, discussing their initial foray into podcasting, their lack of monetization, and the profound impact the show has had on their lives. They delve into chilling stories, including the Staten Island urban legend of "Cropsy" and the real-life serial killer Andre Rand, who was connected to the Willow Brook mental hospital. Karen shares her favorite murder story, the case of Michelle Wallace, a 25-year-old photographer murdered in 1974. The story involves a hitchhiking encounter, a chilling photo, and the eventual capture of the killer, Roy Melonson, who was convicted of multiple murders. The episode introduces a new segment where listeners can share their hometown murder stories. The first story comes from E. Allen, who recounts the abduction and murder of Adam Walsh in 1981. The story highlights the intense media coverage and the ongoing mystery surrounding the case. The conversation then shifts to the Adam Walsh case and its connection to Jeffrey Dahmer. The hosts discuss similarities between the descriptions of the perpetrators in both cases, including the use of a blue van and the victim's missing front teeth. They also mention the theory that the boy found in the canal might not have been Adam Walsh. The hosts encourage listeners to submit their hometown stories, even if they don't involve murder, as long as they are creepy or unusual. They also remind listeners to rate, review, and subscribe to the podcast. The hosts jokingly declare their podcast a feminist movement, emphasizing the importance of supporting women in podcasting. They discuss the challenges of being women in a male-dominated industry and the importance of breaking down stereotypes. The hosts share their final thoughts on the episode, including a humorous plea not to be murdered. They also discuss the unexpected success of their podcast and the challenges of navigating social media in relation to their content. The hosts discuss the unique relationship between podcasts and social media, highlighting how content can be distorted and misinterpreted online. They emphasize the importance of staying true to their authentic selves and not trying to please everyone. The hosts reflect on their journey as podcasters, acknowledging that they have learned a lot through trial and error. They discuss the importance of embracing criticism and using it as an opportunity for growth. The hosts celebrate the power of podcasting as a platform for authentic conversations and diverse voices. They contrast it with traditional media, which they see as more controlled and less genuine. The hosts share some alternate title options for their podcast, including "GoForth and Murder" and "The '80s Need to Go to Prison." They also discuss the significance of their podcast couch and its connection to their content. The hosts conclude the episode by reiterating the core theme of their podcast: looking back at past events and reflecting on their significance. They emphasize the importance of acknowledging the past and learning from it.

Outlines

00:00:58

Rewinding to Episode Four: A Look Back at the Early Days of My Favorite Murder

Karen and Georgia revisit episode four of their podcast, "My Favorite Murder," which aired on February 11th, 2016. They discuss their early days as podcasters, their lack of monetization, and the impact of the show on their lives. They also share a chilling story about the Staten Island urban legend of "Cropsy" and the real-life serial killer Andre Rand who was connected to the Willow Brook mental hospital.

00:26:40

True Crime Stories: Michelle Wallace and Roy Melonson

Karen shares her favorite murder story, the case of Michelle Wallace, a 25-year-old photographer who was murdered in 1974. The story involves a hitchhiking encounter, a chilling photo, and the eventual capture of the killer, Roy Melonson, who was convicted of multiple murders.

00:42:03

Listener Hometown Story: The Adam Walsh Case

Karen and Georgia introduce a new segment where listeners can share their hometown murder stories. The first story comes from E. Allen, who recounts the abduction and murder of Adam Walsh in 1981. The story highlights the intense media coverage and the ongoing mystery surrounding the case.

00:48:14

Adam Walsh Case and Jeffrey Dahmer: Similarities and Theories

The conversation starts with a discussion about the Adam Walsh case and its connection to Jeffrey Dahmer. The hosts discuss the similarities between the descriptions of the perpetrator in both cases, including the use of a blue van and the victim's missing front teeth. They also mention the theory that the boy found in the canal might not have been Adam Walsh.

00:49:41

Home Town Stories and Podcast Reviews

The hosts encourage listeners to submit their hometown stories, even if they don't involve murder, as long as they are creepy or unusual. They also remind listeners to rate, review, and subscribe to the podcast.

00:50:12

Feminist Podcast Movement and Industry Challenges

The hosts jokingly declare their podcast a feminist movement, emphasizing the importance of supporting women in podcasting. They also discuss the challenges of being women in a male-dominated industry and the importance of breaking down stereotypes.

00:50:48

Final Thoughts, Podcast Success, and Social Media Challenges

The hosts share their final thoughts on the episode, including a humorous plea not to be murdered. They also discuss the unexpected success of their podcast and the challenges of navigating social media in relation to their content.

00:53:24

Learning from Mistakes and Embracing Criticism

The hosts reflect on their journey as podcasters, acknowledging that they have learned a lot through trial and error. They discuss the importance of embracing criticism and using it as an opportunity for growth.

00:55:14

The Power of Podcasting and its Authenticity

The hosts celebrate the power of podcasting as a platform for authentic conversations and diverse voices. They contrast it with traditional media, which they see as more controlled and less genuine.

Keywords

Q&A

• What is the main theme of this episode of "Rewind with Karen and Georgia"?

  The episode focuses on revisiting early episodes of "My Favorite Murder" and reflecting on the podcast's impact on the hosts' lives and the true crime community.

• What is the story of "Cropsy" and how is it connected to Andre Rand?

  "Cropsy" is an urban legend about a mentally ill patient who escaped from Willow Brook mental hospital and abducts children. Andre Rand, a convicted sex offender who worked at the hospital, was linked to the disappearances and murders of several children, making the legend a chilling reflection of reality.

• How was the murder of Michelle Wallace solved?

  The case was solved through DNA evidence that linked Roy Melonson, a convicted rapist, to the crime. Melonson was found guilty in 1993, 19 years after Michelle's murder.

• What is the significance of the Adam Walsh case?

  The abduction and murder of Adam Walsh in 1981 sparked national attention and led to the creation of the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children. The case continues to be a chilling reminder of the dangers children face.

• What are some of the similarities between the Adam Walsh case and the Jeffrey Dahmer case?

  Both cases involved a perpetrator who used a blue van and targeted young, blonde boys. Additionally, both victims were missing their front teeth.

• Why do the hosts encourage listeners to submit their hometown stories?

  They believe that even stories that don't involve murder can be interesting and creepy, especially if they involve unusual or unsettling events.

• What is the hosts' perspective on the role of women in podcasting?

  They believe that women are underrepresented in podcasting and that it's important to support women in this industry. They also see their podcast as a feminist movement, challenging stereotypes and advocating for equality.

• How do the hosts view the relationship between podcasts and social media?

  They acknowledge that social media can distort and misinterpret podcast content, but they believe it's important to stay true to their authentic selves and not try to please everyone online.

• What is the hosts' approach to criticism?

  They believe that criticism can be valuable for growth and that it's important to learn from mistakes. They also see criticism as a sign that they are doing something right and that they are making an impact.

Show Notes