Rookie Quarterbacks Set Up for Failure?
Digest
The episode begins with a lighthearted discussion about National First Love Day, followed by a critical analysis of the struggles of rookie quarterbacks in the NFL. The hosts argue that these players should be learning from the sidelines instead of being rushed into starting roles. They then debate whether Travis Hunter, a two-way player for Colorado, has a realistic chance of winning the Heisman Trophy, acknowledging his impressive stats but suggesting it's too early to tell. The conversation shifts to the LIV Golf controversy, with the hosts discussing an article in Bloomberg that suggests some PGA Tour players are demanding that returning LIV Golfers face penalties. Wilbon vehemently opposes these demands, expressing his strong opinions on the matter. The hosts then discuss Jose Altuve's ejection from a game after showing his bare foot to the umpire, finding the situation ludicrous and questioning the lack of reviewability in such situations. The episode continues with a discussion of Shohei Ohtani's pursuit of a 50/50 season, acknowledging the magnitude of the accomplishment but believing Ohtani is rationalizing his September slump by saying he feels no pressure. The hosts then discuss Jordan Love's return to practice for the Green Bay Packers, as well as other sports news, including Scotty Bowman's 91st birthday, Tim Raines' 40th anniversary of stealing 70 bases in four consecutive seasons, and Victor Robles' failed attempt to steal home. The episode concludes with a discussion of Adrian Wojnarowski's departure from ESPN and his new role as general manager of the athletic program at St. Bonaventure. They also discuss the significance of Jordan Love's return to practice for the Packers, suggesting it could be a sign of his potential greatness. The hosts then discuss the current MLB playoff picture, highlighting the Orioles' recent struggles and the Brewers' clinching of a playoff spot.
Outlines
Sports Talk and First Love Day
The episode begins with a lighthearted exchange between Mike Wilbon and Tony Cornheye, referencing National First Love Day and their personal first loves. They then discuss the struggles of rookie quarterbacks in the NFL, arguing that these players should be learning from the sidelines instead of being rushed into starting roles.
Heisman Trophy Contenders and LIV Golf Controversy
The hosts debate whether Travis Hunter, a two-way player for Colorado, has a realistic chance of winning the Heisman Trophy. They acknowledge his impressive stats but argue that it's too early to tell and that other players could emerge as contenders. They then discuss an article in Bloomberg that suggests some PGA Tour players are demanding that returning LIV Golfers face penalties, with Wilbon vehemently opposing the demands.
Shohei Ohtani's 50/50 Season and Jordan Love's Return
The hosts discuss Shohei Ohtani's pursuit of a 50/50 season, acknowledging the magnitude of the accomplishment but believing Ohtani is rationalizing his September slump by saying he feels no pressure. They then discuss Jordan Love's return to practice for the Green Bay Packers, as well as other sports news, including Scotty Bowman's 91st birthday, Tim Raines' 40th anniversary of stealing 70 bases in four consecutive seasons, and Victor Robles' failed attempt to steal home.
Adrian Wojnarowski's New Role and MLB Playoff Picture
The hosts discuss Adrian Wojnarowski's departure from ESPN and his new role as general manager of the athletic program at St. Bonaventure. They also discuss the significance of Jordan Love's return to practice for the Packers, suggesting it could be a sign of his potential greatness. The hosts then discuss the current MLB playoff picture, highlighting the Orioles' recent struggles and the Brewers' clinching of a playoff spot. They end the episode with their usual closing remarks.
Keywords
Rookie Quarterbacks
Young quarterbacks entering the NFL, often highly drafted, facing challenges adjusting to the speed and complexity of the professional game.
Heisman Trophy
Prestigious award given annually to the most outstanding player in college football, often awarded to quarterbacks but occasionally to other positions.
LIV Golf
Saudi-backed golf tour that has attracted top players with lucrative contracts, causing a rift in the golf world and sparking debate about sportswashing.
50/50 Season
A rare feat in baseball where a player achieves 50 home runs and 50 stolen bases in a single season, never accomplished before.
September Slump
A phenomenon in baseball where players experience a decline in performance during the final month of the regular season, often attributed to fatigue or pressure.
Sportswashing
The practice of using sports events or sponsorships to improve a country's or organization's reputation, often masking human rights abuses or other controversies.
Base Running
The art of running between bases in baseball, involving strategic decisions about when to steal bases, advance on hits, and avoid being thrown out.
Playoff Clinch
The moment a team secures a spot in the postseason, often achieved by winning a certain number of games or finishing with a winning record.
Q&A
Why do the hosts believe rookie quarterbacks should not be starting in the NFL?
They argue that the speed and complexity of the professional game require more experience and development, and that these players should be learning from the sidelines before being thrown into the fire.
What are the arguments for and against Travis Hunter winning the Heisman Trophy?
His impressive stats and two-way play make him a strong contender, but it's early in the season, and other players could emerge. Additionally, the fact that he plays for Colorado, a team that is not considered a powerhouse, could hurt his chances.
What is the PGA Tour's stance on returning LIV Golfers?
Some PGA Tour players are demanding that returning LIV Golfers face penalties, including handing back their earnings from the Saudi-backed tour. However, the hosts believe this is a business decision and that the PGA Tour is ultimately trying to protect its own interests.
What is the significance of Shohei Ohtani's pursuit of a 50/50 season?
It's an unprecedented feat in baseball, and Ohtani's close proximity to achieving it has generated significant excitement and attention. However, the hosts believe he is rationalizing his September slump by downplaying the pressure.
What is the significance of Jordan Love's return to practice for the Packers?
It suggests that his injury is not as serious as initially feared and that he could be ready to play sooner than expected. The hosts believe he has the potential to be a great quarterback and that his return could be a turning point for the Packers.
Show Notes
Michael Wilbon and Tony Kornheiser discuss why the hyped rookie quarterback class has yet to throw a touchdown this season, if Travis Hunter could win the Heisman Trophy, and if LIV players should surrender money in the PGA merger. All that and more!
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices