SOLVED: The Talk Show Confession 2

Update: 2026-04-09

Digest

This episode details the tragic murder of Scott Amador, a consequence of his appearance on the Jenny Jones Show to reveal a secret crush on Jonathan Schmitz. The show's producers faced scrutiny for the segment's impact, which led to Schmitz feeling humiliated and ultimately purchasing a gun. Schmitz confronted and murdered Amador three days after the show. During Schmitz's trial, the controversial "gay panic defense" was employed. While a civil jury initially awarded damages to the Amador family, the Jenny Jones Show was ultimately protected by the First Amendment. Jonathan Schmitz was convicted of second-degree murder and later granted parole after serving 22 years, leaving lingering questions about media accountability.

Outlines

00:00:00

The Jenny Jones Show Murder: A Secret Crush's Fatal Outcome

This episode explores the murder of Scott Amador, which originated from an appearance on the Jenny Jones Show where he revealed a secret crush on Jonathan Schmitz. The show's producers faced questions about their responsibility, as the segment led to Schmitz feeling blindsided and humiliated. Following the taping, Schmitz's resentment grew, culminating in him purchasing a shotgun and fatally shooting Amador at his home.

00:17:36

Legal Ramifications and Media Scrutiny

After confessing to the murder, Jonathan Schmitz blamed the Jenny Jones show, shifting the focus to the program's role and initiating legal and cultural scrutiny. The subsequent trial became a media spectacle, featuring the controversial "gay panic defense." Despite Jenny Jones testifying to defend the show's format, Schmitz was convicted of second-degree murder.

00:29:05

Civil Lawsuit, Appeals, and Lingering Questions

The Amador family pursued a civil lawsuit against the Jenny Jones show for negligence, initially winning a substantial settlement. However, this verdict was overturned on appeal, with the show ultimately protected by the First Amendment. Legal scholars debated the show's moral responsibility, while Jenny Jones maintained Schmitz was solely accountable. Jonathan Schmitz was eventually granted parole after serving 22 years, leaving the question of accountability unresolved.

Keywords

Jenny Jones Show

A daytime talk show known for controversial segments, including one that led to a murder.

Gay Panic Defense

A legal strategy claiming temporary insanity due to homosexual advances, used in Jonathan Schmitz's trial.

Media Responsibility

Ethical obligations of media outlets regarding content and its societal impact, questioned in this case.

Secret Crushes

A theme on the Jenny Jones Show that revealed hidden romantic interests, often with dramatic consequences.

Murder Trial

The legal process for murder accusations, highlighted by the media circus and unique defense in this case.

First Amendment

Constitutional protection for freedom of speech and press, used to shield the Jenny Jones Show from liability.

Q&A

What was the Jenny Jones show episode about that led to the murder?
The episode involved Scott Amador revealing his secret crush on Jonathan Schmitz, who felt humiliated and misled by the show.
What was the "gay panic defense" used in Jonathan Schmitz's trial?
The defense argued that Schmitz's mental illness and public humiliation from the show led to extreme emotional disturbance, causing him to commit murder.
Was the Jenny Jones show held legally responsible for Scott Amador's death?
No, the show was ultimately protected by the First Amendment, despite an initial civil jury award to the Amador family.
What happened to Jonathan Schmitz after the murder?
Jonathan Schmitz was convicted of second-degree murder and later granted parole after serving 22 years.

Show Notes

Three days after the taping of The Jenny Jones Show, the tension that had lingered off camera turned deadly. What began as a daytime television surprise became a national tragedy, thrusting Scott Amedure and Jonathan Schmitz back into headlines under far darker circumstances. In Part 2, Murder: True Crime Stories examines the murder of Scott Amedure, the urgent investigation that followed, and the courtroom battle that put Schmitz on trial. Carter Roy breaks down the prosecution’s case, the defense’s argument that the televised reveal triggered overwhelming emotional distress, and the broader cultural attitudes toward sexuality that shaped public reaction. As the verdict was delivered, the case raised unsettling questions about media ethics, personal responsibility, and the limits of entertainment built on public confession. The fallout extended beyond the criminal trial, leading to a landmark civil lawsuit against The Jenny Jones Show and forcing a national reckoning over how far television should go in the pursuit of ratings.

Head over to our Murder True Crime Stories YouTube channel to WATCH our video episodes: https://www.youtube.com/@MurderTrueCrimeStories

If you’re new here, don’t forget to follow Murder True Crime Stories to never miss a case! For Ad-free listening and early access to episodes, subscribe to Crime House+ on Apple Podcasts. Murder True Crime Stories is a Crime House Original Podcast, powered by PAVE Studios

🎧 Need More to Binge?

Listen to other Crime House Originals Clues, Crimes Of…, Serial Killers & Murderous Minds, Crime House 24/7, and more wherever you get your podcasts!

Follow me on Social