Sophomore Obsession (PODCAST EXCLUSIVE EPISODE)
5Digest
The podcast delves into the chilling true crime story of Brooke Baker, a 19-year-old journalism student at Vincennes University, who was found murdered in her apartment. The investigation, led by Detectives Greg Winkler and Bob Dunham, uncovers a web of potential suspects, including Brooke's boyfriend, Steve Hoffman, and her landlord, Mike Nardine. The case takes a significant turn when Brooke's journalism professor reveals she was working on a story about an alleged rape at a fraternity party, leading to threatening emails from fraternity members. Despite extensive investigation, the case goes cold for a year. Two years later, the detectives investigate the murder of another Vincennes University student, Erica Norman, who bears striking similarities to Brooke's case. The investigation leads them to Brian Jones, Steve's roommate, who had a history of obsessive behavior towards both women. Through meticulous investigation and DNA evidence, the detectives uncover Brian's involvement in both murders, revealing his motive as a result of rejection from both women. The podcast concludes with Brian Jones' conviction and a tribute to Brooke Baker's legacy as a journalist.
Outlines
The Murder of Brooke Baker
The podcast introduces the case of Brooke Baker, a 19-year-old journalism student at Vincennes University, who was found murdered in her apartment. The investigation begins with interviews of potential suspects, including Brooke's boyfriend, Steve Hoffman, and her landlord, Mike Nardine.
Brooke's Last Day and the Fraternity Story
The episode details Brooke's last day, including her work on a story for the university newspaper, her lunch date with Steve Hoffman, and her attendance at a party. The investigation reveals that Brooke was working on a story about an alleged rape at a fraternity party, leading to threatening emails from fraternity members.
The Murder of Erica Norman and the Connection
Almost two years after Brooke's murder, the detectives investigate a new crime scene that bears striking similarities to Brooke's murder. The victim is Erica Norman, another Vincennes University student. The investigation reveals that Erica had been with a man named Brian Jones on the night she disappeared.
Brian Jones: The Killer's Identity
The detectives learn that Brian Jones is a strong suspect in both murders. They realize that Brian is a strong suspect in both murders.
Brian Jones' Obsession and Conviction
The episode reveals that Brian Jones had developed an obsession with Brooke and Erica, both of whom he had met through Steve. He murdered them both after they rejected his advances. Brian Jones is found guilty of both murders and sentenced to life in prison.
Keywords
Cold Case
A criminal investigation that has been temporarily or indefinitely suspended due to a lack of leads or evidence.
DNA Evidence
Biological samples used to identify individuals or link them to a crime scene.
Sexual Assault
Any sexual act or contact without consent, including rape, sexual abuse, and sexual harassment.
Obsession
An intense and often unhealthy preoccupation with a person or object.
Frat Party
A social gathering hosted by a fraternity, often involving alcohol and music.
Murder Weapon
The object used to commit a murder, such as a knife, gun, or blunt object.
Q&A
What led police to discover the body of the young woman in the field?
Police officers were searching a field in Illinois for a missing person when they discovered the body.
What evidence was found at Brooke Baker's apartment that suggested a violent crime had taken place?
Police found blood spatter on the wall, multiple wounds on Brooke's body, and bruising on her inner thighs, suggesting a violent murder that followed a sexual assault.
Who were the main suspects in Brooke's murder?
The main suspects were Brooke's landlord, Mike Nardine, and two men she was seeing, Steve Hoffman and Tommy Williams.
What was the significance of the story Brooke was working on for the university newspaper?
Brooke was writing a story about an alleged rape at a fraternity party, which led to her receiving threatening emails from members of the fraternity.
How did the police finally identify Brian Jones as the killer?
Brian Jones' DNA matched the DNA found at both Brooke's and Erica's crime scenes.
What was Brian Jones' motive for murdering Brooke and Erica?
Brian Jones was obsessed with both women and murdered them after they rejected his advances.
Show Notes
On a hot summer day in Illinois, police officers made their way through a field out in the middle of nowhere. They pushed aside the tall grass, and they could see and hear flies buzzing all around them. Suddenly, the officer at the front of the group stopped, crouched down, and called back to the others – he had finally found the body. The other officers rushed to him, and they all stared down at the dead young woman. The cops knew something like this would leave people in the small town nearby in complete shock, but they had no idea what their discovery would lead to. Because this dead young woman in the field would soon help solve a murder that had taken place across the border in Indiana, and lead police to a killer who had been on the run for two years.
For 100s more stories like these, check out our main YouTube channel just called "MrBallen" -- https://www.youtube.com/c/MrBallen
If you want to reach out to me, contact me on Instagram, Twitter or any other major social media platform, my username on all of them is @mrballen
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Table of contents
United States
