Summer School 2: The golden ages of labor and looms
10Digest
This episode of Planet Money Summer School delves into the history of labor, focusing on two pivotal moments: the Black Death and the Luddite movement. The Black Death, a devastating pandemic in the 14th century, decimated Europe's population, leading to a significant labor shortage. This shortage empowered surviving workers, who were able to negotiate higher wages and better working conditions. However, this shift in power was met with resistance from the ruling class, who attempted to control wages and restrict worker mobility through legislation. The episode then explores the Luddite movement, a rebellion against the introduction of machinery in the textile industry during the Industrial Revolution. The Luddites, fearing job displacement, sought to destroy the machines that threatened their livelihoods. While their efforts were ultimately unsuccessful, the Luddite movement highlights the anxieties and challenges associated with technological advancements and their impact on the workforce. The episode concludes by emphasizing the cyclical nature of power dynamics between labor and employers, highlighting the importance of understanding these historical patterns to navigate the challenges of the modern economy.
Outlines
Introduction
This Chapter introduces Planet Money Summer School, a series exploring the economic history of the world. The episode focuses on the rise of the worker and the challenges faced by workers in the economy, particularly in relation to AI and automation.
The Black Death and Labor Power
This Chapter examines the economic impact of the Black Death, a devastating pandemic that swept through Europe in the 14th century. The plague's impact on labor supply led to a surge in worker power, resulting in higher wages and improved working conditions. However, this shift in power was met with resistance from the ruling class, who attempted to control wages and restrict worker mobility through legislation.
The Luddite Movement
This Chapter explores the Luddite movement, a rebellion against the introduction of machinery in the textile industry during the Industrial Revolution. The Luddites, fearing job displacement, sought to destroy the machines that threatened their livelihoods. While their efforts were ultimately unsuccessful, the Luddite movement highlights the anxieties and challenges associated with technological advancements and their impact on the workforce.
Lessons from History
This Chapter reflects on the lessons learned from the Black Death and the Luddite movement, emphasizing the cyclical nature of power dynamics between labor and employers. The episode highlights the importance of understanding these historical patterns to navigate the challenges of the modern economy.
Keywords
Black Death
The Black Death, also known as the Bubonic Plague, was a devastating pandemic that swept through Europe and Asia in the mid-14th century. It is estimated to have killed 30 to 50% of Europe's population, causing widespread social and economic upheaval. The plague was caused by the bacterium Yersinia pestis, which was transmitted by fleas living on rats. The Black Death had a profound impact on European society, leading to labor shortages, social unrest, and changes in economic structures.
Luddites
The Luddites were a group of English textile workers who protested against the introduction of new machinery in the early 19th century. They believed that these machines were displacing skilled workers and causing unemployment. The Luddites engaged in acts of sabotage, destroying machines in factories. The movement was named after Ned Ludd, a mythical figure who is said to have destroyed a stocking frame in the late 18th century. The Luddites were ultimately unsuccessful in their efforts to stop the mechanization of the textile industry, but their story serves as a reminder of the anxieties and challenges associated with technological advancements and their impact on the workforce.
Labor Supply and Demand
Labor supply and demand are fundamental economic concepts that explain the relationship between the availability of workers and the demand for their services. The price of labor, or wages, is determined by the interaction of these forces. When labor supply is low and demand is high, wages tend to rise. Conversely, when labor supply is high and demand is low, wages tend to fall. The Black Death and the Luddite movement provide historical examples of how shifts in labor supply and demand can dramatically alter the balance of power between workers and employers.
Capital-Labor Substitution
Capital-labor substitution refers to the process by which capital, in the form of machinery and technology, replaces labor in the production process. This substitution can occur when labor becomes more expensive or when technological advancements make capital more efficient. The Luddite movement is a classic example of capital-labor substitution, as the introduction of new machinery in the textile industry led to the displacement of skilled workers.
Industrial Revolution
The Industrial Revolution was a period of rapid technological advancement and economic growth that began in Great Britain in the late 18th century and spread to other parts of the world. The Industrial Revolution was characterized by the introduction of new machines, factories, and power sources, such as the steam engine. It led to significant changes in the way goods were produced and consumed, and it had a profound impact on society, leading to urbanization, population growth, and the rise of a new industrial working class. The Luddite movement arose in the context of the Industrial Revolution, as workers sought to resist the changes that were transforming their lives and livelihoods.
Q&A
How did the Black Death impact the balance of power between workers and employers?
The Black Death caused a significant labor shortage, giving surviving workers more bargaining power. They were able to negotiate higher wages and better working conditions, leading to a temporary period of reduced inequality.
What were the Luddites' motivations for protesting against new machinery?
The Luddites feared that the introduction of new machinery would displace skilled workers and cause unemployment. They believed that these machines were threatening their livelihoods and sought to destroy them to protect their jobs.
What lessons can we learn from the Black Death and the Luddite movement about the relationship between labor and employers?
These historical events highlight the cyclical nature of power dynamics between labor and employers. Shifts in labor supply and demand can dramatically alter the balance of power, and technological advancements can create both opportunities and challenges for workers. Understanding these historical patterns is crucial for navigating the complexities of the modern economy.
What are some examples of how the relationship between labor and employers is changing in the modern economy?
The rise of automation and AI is raising concerns about job displacement, similar to the anxieties of the Luddites. However, there is also a growing movement for worker organization and unionization, particularly in sectors like technology, retail, and education.
What are some of the key takeaways from this episode of Planet Money Summer School?
The episode emphasizes the importance of understanding the historical context of labor relations, the impact of technological advancements on the workforce, and the cyclical nature of power dynamics between workers and employers. It also highlights the need for ongoing dialogue and action to ensure that the benefits of economic progress are shared equitably.
Show Notes
We travel to Sicily, Italy in the year 1347, where the bubonic plague is about to strike. The horror known as the Black Death will remake European society in countless ways, but we'll focus on one silver lining: how economic conditions shifted for workers.
Then we head about 500 years into the future, to an English factory at the dawn of the Industrial Revolution, where textile workers take up arms against the machines taking their jobs and show how rapidly labor supply and demand can change. This is the famed tale of the Luddites, now a byword for knee jerk anti-technology, but the true story has nuance and a desperate but rational violent rebellion.
This series is hosted by Robert Smith and produced by Audrey Dilling. Our project manager is Devin Mellor. This episode was edited by Planet Money Executive Producer Alex Goldmark and fact-checked by Sofia Shchukina.
Help support Planet Money and hear our bonus episodes by subscribing to Planet Money+ in Apple Podcasts or at plus.npr.org/planetmoney.
Learn more about sponsor message choices: podcastchoices.com/adchoices
NPR Privacy Policy
Table of contents
United States
labor power!