Tech at Work: How to Get the Most Out of Digital Collaboration Tools
6Digest
This episode of the HBR Ideacast delves into the complexities of collaboration technologies in the modern workplace. The discussion begins with Professor Paul Lienardi, who highlights the challenges of remote work despite the plethora of available tools. He emphasizes the importance of matching tools to specific tasks and the need for clear guidelines to avoid overwhelming employees with too many choices. The episode then explores the issue of tool overload, with research revealing that employees spend significant time searching for information, deciding on tools, and switching between them. This leads to a debate about the merits of "bundle" versus "best of breed" approaches to technology, with the episode ultimately advocating for a more streamlined approach with fewer, well-mastered tools. The discussion then shifts to the evolution of collaboration tools, particularly Slack, and the challenges of information overload in a remote and hybrid work environment. The episode concludes with insights from Sandra Ma, a product team leader who shares her experience in addressing a Slack-related communication dilemma. She emphasizes the importance of establishing clear communication norms, using different tools for different purposes, and creating a single source of truth for project information. The episode highlights the need for leaders to be proactive in managing collaboration technologies, ensuring that tools are aligned with organizational culture and employee well-being.
Outlines
Introduction: The Challenges of Collaboration Technologies
This Chapter introduces the topic of collaboration technologies in the workplace and highlights the challenges of remote work despite the availability of numerous tools. It emphasizes the importance of matching tools to specific tasks and the need for clear guidelines to avoid overwhelming employees with too many choices.
The Overabundance of Tools and the Need for Streamlined Choices
This Chapter delves into the issue of tool overload, with research revealing that employees spend significant time searching for information, deciding on tools, and switching between them. It explores the debate about "bundle" versus "best of breed" approaches to technology, advocating for a more streamlined approach with fewer, well-mastered tools.
The Evolution of Collaboration Tools and the Challenges of Information Overload
This Chapter discusses the evolution of collaboration tools, particularly Slack, and the challenges of information overload in a remote and hybrid work environment. It explores the impact of increased content volume and the tendency for employees to focus on information from familiar sources, hindering access to new knowledge and information.
Video Conferencing: The Final Stage Before Virtual Reality?
This Chapter examines the use of video conferencing tools, acknowledging their benefits for synchronous activities but highlighting the potential for overuse and anxiety. It emphasizes the importance of judicious use and suggests that phone calls can be a more effective option for certain tasks.
Identifying When a Tool Isn't Working: The 80% Rule
This Chapter provides guidance on identifying when a collaboration tool is not working effectively. It suggests that if a single tool occupies more than 80% of a team's interaction, it may be an indication of overuse and a need for alternative tools.
Making the Case for Better Tools: Articulating the Needs and Breaking Down Barriers
This Chapter addresses the challenge of convincing leaders to invest in better collaboration tools. It emphasizes the importance of articulating the specific communication and collaboration breakdowns that are occurring and advocating for a more strategic approach to technology management.
Leadership Perspective: Asking the Right Questions
This Chapter provides guidance for leaders on making informed decisions about collaboration technologies. It suggests asking questions about the quantity of tools used, the types of activities requiring coordination, and the potential for employee exhaustion from tool usage.
The Future of Collaboration Tools: The Role of AI and Managing Social Dynamics
This Chapter explores the potential impact of AI on collaboration tools, suggesting that AI could help streamline information flow and provide cues for interaction. It also highlights the importance of managing social dynamics in remote and hybrid work environments, ensuring that all team members feel included and valued.
A Real-Life Collaboration Technology Dilemma: The Slack Overwhelm
This Chapter shifts from research to a real-life case study, featuring Sandra Ma, a product team leader who shares her experience in addressing a Slack-related communication dilemma. She emphasizes the importance of establishing clear communication norms, using different tools for different purposes, and creating a single source of truth for project information.
Addressing Concerns and Achieving Business Results
This Chapter explores the process of implementing new communication norms and addressing employee concerns. It highlights the importance of listening, understanding, and demonstrating the benefits of the new approach. The episode concludes with a discussion of the business results achieved through standardization, including increased efficiency, faster product launches, and improved employee morale.
Keywords
Collaboration Technologies
Collaboration technologies refer to the various digital tools and platforms used by individuals and teams to work together, communicate, share information, and complete tasks. These technologies encompass a wide range of applications, including instant messaging platforms (e.g., Slack, Microsoft Teams), video conferencing tools (e.g., Zoom, WebEx), project management software (e.g., Asana, Trello), document sharing platforms (e.g., Google Docs, Dropbox), and email.
Remote Work
Remote work refers to a work arrangement where employees perform their job duties from a location other than a traditional office setting, such as their home, a co-working space, or a remote office. It has become increasingly prevalent in recent years, driven by factors such as technological advancements, changing work preferences, and the COVID-19 pandemic. Remote work offers flexibility and autonomy for employees but also presents challenges related to communication, collaboration, and maintaining a sense of connection with colleagues.
Tool Overload
Tool overload refers to the situation where individuals or teams have access to an excessive number of digital tools and applications, leading to confusion, inefficiency, and potential overwhelm. This can occur in various contexts, including the workplace, personal life, and education. The abundance of choices can make it difficult to select the right tool for a specific task, leading to wasted time and effort. Tool overload can also contribute to information overload and digital exhaustion.
Bundle vs. Best of Breed
The "bundle vs. best of breed" debate refers to the choice between using a single suite of integrated tools (bundle) or selecting the best individual tools for specific tasks (best of breed). Bundle approaches offer simplicity and integration but may lack specialized features. Best of breed approaches provide specialized functionality but can lead to complexity and integration challenges. The optimal approach depends on the specific needs and preferences of the individual or team.
Information Overload
Information overload refers to the state of being overwhelmed by the excessive amount of information available, making it difficult to process, filter, and make sense of it. This can occur in various contexts, including the workplace, personal life, and online environments. Information overload can lead to stress, anxiety, and reduced productivity. Strategies for managing information overload include prioritizing information, using filtering tools, and setting limits on information consumption.
Slack
Slack is a popular instant messaging and collaboration platform widely used by businesses and organizations. It provides features for team communication, file sharing, project management, and integration with other applications. Slack has become a ubiquitous tool in the modern workplace, facilitating real-time communication and collaboration among team members.
Communication Norms
Communication norms refer to the established rules, guidelines, and expectations for communication within a group or organization. These norms can be explicit or implicit and influence how individuals interact, share information, and resolve conflicts. Effective communication norms promote clarity, consistency, and respect among team members, fostering a positive and productive work environment.
Single Source of Truth
A single source of truth refers to a centralized location or document that contains the most up-to-date and accurate information about a specific project, process, or topic. This approach helps to eliminate confusion, ensure consistency, and facilitate collaboration by providing a shared reference point for all team members. Examples of single sources of truth include project management software, shared spreadsheets, and knowledge bases.
Digital Exhaustion
Digital exhaustion refers to a state of mental and emotional fatigue caused by excessive use of digital technologies. It can manifest as feelings of overwhelm, stress, anxiety, and difficulty disconnecting from technology. Factors contributing to digital exhaustion include constant notifications, information overload, and the pressure to be constantly connected. Strategies for mitigating digital exhaustion include setting boundaries, taking breaks, and engaging in digital detox practices.
Gen AI
Gen AI, short for Generative AI, refers to a type of artificial intelligence that can create new content, such as text, images, audio, and video. It is based on machine learning algorithms that have been trained on massive datasets. Gen AI has the potential to revolutionize various industries, including content creation, design, and customer service. Examples of Gen AI applications include chatbots, image generators, and music composers.
Q&A
What are the key challenges of collaboration technologies in the workplace?
The key challenges include tool overload, difficulty choosing the right tools, information overload, and managing social dynamics in remote and hybrid work environments.
What are some strategies for managing tool overload?
Strategies include establishing clear communication norms, using different tools for different purposes, and creating a single source of truth for project information.
What is the 80% rule and how can it help identify tool overuse?
The 80% rule suggests that if a single tool occupies more than 80% of a team's interaction, it may be an indication of overuse and a need for alternative tools.
How can leaders make informed decisions about collaboration technologies?
Leaders should ask questions about the quantity of tools used, the types of activities requiring coordination, and the potential for employee exhaustion from tool usage.
What is the potential impact of AI on collaboration tools?
AI could help streamline information flow, provide cues for interaction, and potentially reduce information overload.
What are some key takeaways from Sandra Ma's experience in addressing a Slack-related communication dilemma?
Key takeaways include the importance of establishing clear communication norms, using different tools for different purposes, and creating a single source of truth for project information.
What are the benefits of standardizing communication approaches?
Benefits include increased efficiency, faster product launches, and improved employee morale.
What are the three key words to remember when implementing new communication norms?
The three key words are clarity, consistency, and connection.
What is digital exhaustion and how can it be mitigated?
Digital exhaustion is a state of mental and emotional fatigue caused by excessive use of digital technologies. It can be mitigated by setting boundaries, taking breaks, and engaging in digital detox practices.
What is the future of collaboration tools?
The future of collaboration tools is likely to involve increased integration with AI, more streamlined information flow, and a greater focus on managing social dynamics in remote and hybrid work environments.
Show Notes
Tools for collaborating online—email, instant messengers, videoconferencing apps, cloud storage, and so many others—have become the norm for most of us. But few leaders have taken the time to learn the best ways for their teams to use these ever-present tools.
Tech at Work is a four-part special series from HBR IdeaCast. Join senior tech editors Juan Martinez and Tom Stackpole for research, stories, and advice to make technology work for you and your team.
In this episode, they talk to researcher Paul Leonardi and organizational leader Sandra Ma. The experts explain how to best match collaboration tools with work tasks and how to know when a technology isn’t working for your team. They also discuss how leaders should go about selecting the most effective digital collaboration tools for their organizations.
Leonardi is the Duca Family Professor of Technology Management at the University of California, Santa Barbara.
Ma is the CEO and cofounder of Jovial, a company that helps teams improve their communication at work.
New episodes of Tech at Work publish in the HBR IdeaCast feed every other Thursday from May 2, after the regular Tuesday episode. Please let us know what you think of the series and which technology topics you want us to cover at ideacast@hbr.org.
Further reading:
Table of contents
United States
