Amanda and Dayelle are heading back to middle school—scrunchies, friendship bracelets, and all—for a true coming-of-age classic: The Babysitters Club!

They’re diving into Kristy’s Great Idea, the very first book in Ann M. Martin’s iconic series, and comparing it to the 1995 cult-favorite movie. Expect real girl talk about everything from diabetes to divorces to the joys (and drama) of growing up in the '90s. AND should you watch it or read it? Or both? Grab your trapper keeper and join the club to find out.

“Watch It Or Read It” is a registered trademark of Gotham West Studios LLC. All rights reserved.