The Disappearance of Lonene Rogers
Digest
This episode details the disappearance of Lanine Rogers, a deaf woman in rural Pennsylvania, over four decades ago. Despite communication barriers and a harsh winter, her daughter Allison relentlessly pursued the truth, uncovering her father Bud Rogers' criminal history and eventually leading to his confession. The story highlights Lanine's determination, the challenges faced by the deaf community, and Allison's fight for justice through "Lonnie's Law" to bring transparency to cold cases. The narrative concludes with Bud's confession, offering closure to Allison and a call to action for victims of domestic violence.
Outlines
Introduction and Lanine Rogers' Disappearance
The episode begins with a trigger warning for domestic violence, child neglect, and homicide, providing the National Domestic Violence Hotline number. It then introduces the mystery of Lanine Rogers, a young mother who disappeared over four decades ago in Pennsylvania, leaving behind two children and a profound mystery in the isolated community of Hayfield Township.
Lanine's Early Life, Diagnosis, and Determination
Lanine Rogers was born in Ohio and diagnosed with profound deafness at a young age. Despite this, her parents chose not to institutionalize her, fostering her independence, compassion, and determination. Her love for dancing and strong will were significant, especially for a deaf woman in the 1950s and 60s. The family later moved to Meadville, Pennsylvania, and Lanine continued her education and work, demonstrating remarkable self-reliance.
Marriage, Family, and Marital Strife
Lanine met and married Clinton "Bud" Rogers, another deaf individual, through the Erie Silent Club, despite her mother's disapproval. They had two children, Allison and Aaron, and settled in Hayfield Township. However, their marriage deteriorated due to Bud's increasing criminal activity, leading to Lanine's separation from him.
Lanine's Disappearance and Initial Investigation
On January 6, 1981, after an argument with Bud, Lanine disappeared amidst harsh winter conditions. Bud took the children to a babysitter. Lanine's father discovered her absence, and the police investigation found an orderly home, but faced significant communication barriers interviewing the deaf Bud.
The Search, Children's Instability, and Neglect
Extensive search efforts for Lanine were hampered by weather, leaving many unanswered questions. The children, Allison and Aaron, endured years of instability, being moved between homes. Warning signs of neglect emerged, culminating in Bud abandoning 14-year-old Allison at a police station, leading to her eventual adoption.
Decades of Mystery and Allison's Renewed Investigation
Lanine's disappearance remained unsolved for decades, with her mother passing away without answers. In 2021, Allison decided to reopen the case, delving deeper into her investigation and uncovering Bud's extensive criminal history, including a prior sexual assault conviction.
Recovered Memories, Legal Battles, and Bud's Confession
Allison experienced recovered memories of the night her mother disappeared, fueling her belief that Bud was responsible. She also championed "Lonnie's Law" to grant families access to cold case files. In November 2025, Bud Rogers confessed to strangling Lanine and disposing of her body, leading to his arrest.
Closure, Advocacy, and Ongoing Legal Process
Bud's confession brought overwhelming emotions and a desire for closure for Allison. She continues her advocacy for victims of violence and unresolved cases, understanding the legal realities as the case moves through the court system. The episode concludes with a call to action, encouraging support for "Lonnie's Law" and remembering Lanine.
Keywords
Domestic Violence Hotline
A 24/7 resource providing confidential support and assistance to individuals experiencing domestic abuse. Offers crisis intervention, safety planning, and referrals to local resources.
Cold Case
An unsolved crime or disappearance that has gone cold due to lack of leads or evidence. These cases often remain open, with law enforcement periodically reviewing them for new information.
Missing Persons Investigation
The process undertaken by law enforcement to locate individuals who have disappeared under suspicious or unexplained circumstances. Involves gathering evidence, interviewing witnesses, and conducting searches.
Deaf Community
A social group of individuals who share the commonality of being deaf or hard of hearing. They often form social clubs and organizations to connect, share experiences, and build relationships.
Right to Know Law (RTKL)
Legislation that grants the public the right to access government records and information. This promotes transparency and accountability in government operations.
Lonnie's Law
A proposed law advocating for transparency in cold cases, allowing families to review investigative files after 20 years of no resolution.
True Crime Podcast
A podcast genre that focuses on real-life crime stories, often detailing investigations, trials, and the impact on victims and their families.
Q&A
What is the National Domestic Violence Hotline number?
The National Domestic Violence Hotline can be reached at 1-800-799-7233 or by texting START to 88788. They offer 24/7 support for those experiencing domestic abuse.
Why was it difficult for the police to interview Bud Rogers?
Bud Rogers is deaf, and the officers lacked a qualified interpreter, making effective communication impossible. This communication barrier significantly hindered the initial investigation.
What is "Lonnie's Law"?
"Lonnie's Law" is a proposed law advocating for transparency in cold cases. It would allow families to review investigative files after 20 years of no resolution, potentially generating new leads.
What evidence led investigators to believe Bud Rogers was involved in Lanine's disappearance?
Key factors include Lanine's plan to leave Bud, the blizzard conditions making it unlikely she left voluntarily, her essential items being left behind, Bud's nervous demeanor, and his extensive criminal history.
How did Allison Rogers finally get access to information about her mother's case?
After facing legal hurdles with RTKL requests, Allison continued to advocate. While she couldn't access the full files due to exemptions, investigators indicated they had enough evidence for a conviction, pending a body.
What was Bud Rogers' confession?
Bud Rogers confessed to strangling Lanine and disposing of her body in a dumpster.
Show Notes
Head to https://www.tryfum.com/SALAD to get your free gift with purchase, and start The Good Habit today!
This episode contains content related to domestic violence, child neglect, and homicide. Listener discretion is advised.
If you or someone you know is experiencing domestic abuse, help is available around the clock through the National Domestic Violence Hotline at 1-800-799-7233 or by texting START to 88788. You are not alone.
On the night of January 6th, 1981, Lonene Rogers finished her work shift, picked up her two young children from the babysitter, and came home to an argument with her estranged husband. By morning, she was gone. No footprints in the snow. No activity on her Social Security number. Her hearing aids, glasses, purse, and car were all still there.
Lonene was a profoundly deaf woman from northwestern Pennsylvania who refused to let her disability define her. She was strong-willed and warm, a devoted mother, and by early 1981 she was finally ready to leave a troubled marriage and build a new life. Instead, she vanished in the middle of a blizzard and was never seen again.
For 44 years, her disappearance went unsolved. Her parents died without answers. Her children grew up without her. And her husband, Clinton "Bud" Rogers, maintained the same story: he woke up and she was simply gone.
In this episode, we trace Lonene's life from her childhood in Youngstown, Ohio, through the marriage that her own family saw warning signs in from the start to the night she disappeared and the search that turned up nothing. We also follow her daughter Alison, who spent decades trying to distance herself from the tragedy before deciding, in 2021, to dedicate herself to finding the truth. Alison's fight took her through court battles, advocacy for a proposed new law called Lonnie's Law, and years of pressure on investigators and the public alike.
In November 2025, that fight finally produced a result. After more than four decades of silence, Bud Rogers confessed.
This is Lonene's story, and it is also the story of a daughter who refused to let her mother be forgotten.
Content warning: This episode contains descriptions of domestic violence, child neglect, and a murder confession.
If you are in the northwestern Pennsylvania area, Lonene's family invites you to join a peaceful gathering outside the Crawford County Courthouse at 903 Diamond Park Square in Meadville, PA on Monday, March 30, 2026, from 9 to 11 am. A hearing in her case will be taking place inside the courthouse that morning, and the community is gathering outside in her memory and in solidarity with victims of domestic violence and the missing and murdered.
She will never stand alone again. 💜
National Domestic Violence Hotline: 1-800-799-7233
Text START to 88788.
You are not alone.
Justice for Lonene Rogers Facebook Page: https://www.facebook.com/groups/285829136570490/
Sign the petition for Lonnie’s Law: https://c.org/mMwHNqtRGC
Alison's book, "A Daughter's Journey and Story of Resilience," is available on Amazon: https://a.co/d/0gWrklLE
Support Crime Salad: Merch
Crime Salad Ad-Free option: Patreon
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Table of contents
United States
