The Disjointed Joint Status Report
2Digest
This episode of "Prosecuting Donald Trump" focuses on the latest developments in the legal cases against former President Donald Trump. The hosts discuss the superseding indictment in the January 6 case, which includes new charges and evidence. They also analyze Trump's attempt to remove his Manhattan criminal case to federal court, which was rejected by the court due to lack of consent from opposing counsel. The hosts delve into the legal strategies employed by both Trump and Special Counsel Jack Smith, highlighting the ongoing battle over immunity and the potential impact of the Supreme Court's decision on presidential immunity. They also discuss the latest developments in the cases, including the rejection of Trump's removal attempt and the DA's response to the motion. The episode concludes with a look ahead at the upcoming legal proceedings and the potential impact of the decisions made in court this week.
Outlines
Prosecuting Donald Trump: Legal Battles and Developments
This episode discusses the latest developments in the legal cases against Donald Trump, including the superseding indictment in the January 6 case, Trump's attempt to remove his Manhattan case to federal court, and the ongoing legal battles surrounding Special Counsel Jack Smith.
Legal Strategies and Immunity
The hosts discuss the legal strategies employed by Donald Trump and Special Counsel Jack Smith in the January 6 case. Trump's team seeks to delay the case and challenge Smith's appointment, while Smith aims to move forward with the immunity issue and present evidence.
Trump's Removal Attempt and Its Implications
The hosts analyze Trump's attempt to remove his Manhattan criminal case to federal court, which was rejected by the court due to lack of consent from opposing counsel. They discuss the arguments Trump presented for removal and the potential implications of the decision.
Latest Developments and Potential Impact
The hosts provide an update on the latest developments in the legal cases against Donald Trump, including the rejection of Trump's removal attempt and the DA's response to the motion. They discuss the potential impact of these developments on the upcoming sentencing date.
Looking Ahead: Upcoming Proceedings and Impact
The hosts conclude the episode by discussing the upcoming legal proceedings and the potential impact of the decisions made in court this week. They also highlight the importance of staying informed about the latest developments in the cases against Donald Trump.
Keywords
Superseding Indictment
A new indictment that replaces or adds to a previous indictment, often issued after new evidence is discovered or legal challenges are addressed.
Speedy Trial Act
A federal law that requires criminal trials to be held within a reasonable time after an indictment is filed.
Immunity
Legal protection from prosecution or civil liability, often granted to government officials for actions taken in their official capacity.
Official Acts
Actions taken by a government official in their official capacity, which may be subject to immunity from prosecution.
Presumptive Immunity
A type of immunity that is presumed to apply to certain actions of government officials, but can be rebutted by the government.
Removal
The process of transferring a case from one court to another, often from state court to federal court.
Federal Officer Removal
A specific type of removal that applies to cases involving federal officials who are accused of crimes related to their official duties.
Brady Information
Evidence that is favorable to the defendant and that the government is obligated to disclose under the Brady rule.
Discovery
The process by which parties in a legal case exchange information and evidence.
Obstruction of Justice
A crime that involves interfering with or hindering a legal proceeding or investigation.
Q&A
What are the key legal arguments being made by Donald Trump and Special Counsel Jack Smith in the January 6 case?
Trump's team is seeking to delay the case and challenge Smith's appointment, while Smith aims to move forward with the immunity issue and present evidence.
What is the significance of the Supreme Court's decision on presidential immunity in the context of the January 6 case?
The decision has created a new legal landscape for the case, requiring the court to determine whether the charges against Trump involve official acts and whether the government can rebut any presumption of immunity.
Why did Trump attempt to remove his Manhattan criminal case to federal court, and why was his attempt rejected?
Trump sought removal to delay the case and potentially obtain a more favorable judge. His attempt was rejected because he did not obtain consent from opposing counsel or permission from the court.
What are the potential implications of the upcoming legal proceedings in the cases against Donald Trump?
The decisions made in court this week could have a significant impact on the timing of the cases, the potential for dismissal of charges, and the likelihood of Trump facing sentencing.
Show Notes
Last Friday’s joint filing in the DC election interference case before Judge Chutkan highlighted the deep chasm between Special Counsel Jack Smith and Trump’s legal team when it comes to how to proceed after the immunity decision. MSNBC legal analysts Andrew Weissmann and Mary McCord give their unique perspective on what both sides offered up and which arguments hold merit. Then, they head to New York to detail the second effort by Trump’s legal team to remove the hush money case to federal court, weeks before his scheduled sentencing before Judge Merchan.
*** A note: Shortly after this episode was recorded, the federal judge denied leave to Mr. Trump to file removal papers after determining that no good cause for the late filing had been shown and removal to federal court was not warranted. Next stop: Trump can appeal that denial to the Second Circuit Court of Appeals.
Also to listeners: MSNBC Live Democracy 2024 is now sold out. Thank you for everyone who signed up to join us this weekend. And if you didn’t manage to grab a ticket, we’ll be posting selections of Saturday’s conversations as a podcast next week, so keep an eye out for that.
Table of contents
United States
