In this episode of the Pew Culture Podcast, Colion Noir and Jake take on I, Robot — or should we say I COMMA Robot? From debating whether Will Smith was the best casting choice (spoiler: Bruce Willis and Denzel Washington were in the mix) to spiraling over the revelation that there’s an actual comma in the movie title, this one’s a wild ride.

The duo digs into the aesthetics, the deeper meaning (or lack of it), and how the title alone might’ve spoiled the movie. Expect heated debates, fanboy moments, and plenty of laughter as they break down one of the most misunderstood sci-fi titles of the 2000s.