The Slate Culture Gift Guide
Digest
This podcast episode features a holiday gift guide where hosts Willa Paskin, Dana Stevens, and Chris Mulanfi discuss culture-related gifts, primarily around the $100 price point. They delve into the history and evolution of gift guides, from early 1900s advertisements to modern online formats influenced by affiliate marketing. The hosts express a mixed ambivalence towards gift guides, appreciating curated selections while acknowledging the overwhelming volume and capitalist undertones. They examine vintage gift guides from the 1910s and 1960s, noting surprising continuities with contemporary trends. Personal gift recommendations span music (The Beatles box set), movies (Criterion Collection, "Mad Men" Blu-ray), home goods (popcorn maker, blankets, decorative bowls, novelty candles), and books focusing on pop culture. Willa Paskin highlights a quirky cherry-shaped toilet cleaner as a unique aesthetic choice. The episode concludes with reflections on the joy of curated recommendations.
Outlines
Introduction to the Slate Culture Gift Guide
Hosts Willa Paskin, Dana Stevens, and Chris Mulanfi introduce the holiday gift guide, focusing on culture-related gifts around the $100 mark. They discuss the tradition and their personal approaches to gift-giving.
The Evolution and Ambivalence of Gift Guides
Willa Paskin shares her complex feelings about gift guides, appreciating well-curated ones while also feeling overwhelmed by the sheer volume and capitalist undertones. The hosts delve into the history of gift guides, tracing them back to early 1900s department store advertisements and discussing how the internet and affiliate links have changed their nature. Vintage examples from the 1910s and 1960s are examined, highlighting historical context and surprising similarities to modern guides.
Personal Gift Picks: Music, Movies, and Home Comforts
Chris Mulanfi shares his gift picks centered around music and pop culture, including a Beatles "Revolver" box set and the "Mad Men" Blu-ray set. Dana Stevens focuses on "Movie Night" essentials, recommending a popcorn bowl, gourmet popcorn, and a cozy blanket, along with a Criterion Collection box set. Willa Paskin suggests decorative bowls that mimic fruits and vegetables, and shares her quirky pick of a cherry-shaped toilet cleaner.
Final Recommendations and Reflections
Chris Mulanfi recommends a book on 1984's pop culture impact, "Can't Slow Down." The hosts reflect on the joy of curated recommendations and the cultural significance of thoughtful gift-giving.
Keywords
Gift Guide
A curated list of recommended products, often themed around holidays or specific interests, designed to help consumers with gift selection. Gift guides have evolved from print advertisements to online content, influenced by e-commerce and affiliate marketing.
Pop Culture
The set of practices, beliefs, and objects that are dominant or prevalent in a society at a given point in time. In this context, it refers to elements like music, television, and film that are widely shared and consumed.
French New Wave
A film movement that emerged in France in the late 1950s, characterized by its experimental style, auteur theory, and rejection of traditional filmmaking conventions. Directors like François Truffaut were key figures.
Beatles Box Set
A collection of music, often including remastered albums, outtakes, and bonus material, released by The Beatles or their record label. These sets are popular among fans for offering deeper insights into the band's creative process.
Criterion Collection
A curated collection of important classic and contemporary films, known for their high-quality restorations, special features, and scholarly essays. They are highly regarded by cinephiles for preserving and celebrating cinematic history.
Holiday Gift Guide
A specialized gift guide focused on the holiday season, offering suggestions for presents suitable for friends, family, and loved ones during festive periods.
Cultural Gifts
Presents that are related to or representative of a particular culture, art form, or intellectual pursuit, often chosen for their aesthetic, historical, or educational value.
Q&A
What is the main theme of the podcast episode?
The main theme is a holiday gift guide, where hosts Willa Paskin, Dana Stevens, and Chris Mulanfi share their curated picks for culture-related gifts, discussing their history, personal preferences, and the broader cultural significance of gift-giving.
What are some of the historical aspects of gift guides discussed?
The hosts trace gift guides back to early 1900s department store advertisements. They discuss how the internet, affiliate links, and the sheer volume of guides have changed their nature, leading to both appreciation and fatigue among consumers.
What types of gifts were recommended by the hosts?
Recommendations included music box sets (The Beatles), film box sets (Criterion Collection's "The Adventures of Antoine Doinel," "Mad Men" Blu-ray), home goods (popcorn maker, cozy blanket, decorative bowls, novelty candles, cherry-shaped toilet cleaner), and books ("Can't Slow Down").
What is Willa Paskin's perspective on gift guides?
Willa expresses ambivalence, enjoying well-curated guides but feeling overwhelmed by the abundance and the commercial aspect. She notes that she often uses gift guides for self-gifting rather than finding gifts for others.
Show Notes
Hark, the holiday season is upon us—and with it, the most solemn of festive traditions: a gift guide! In this video and podcast special, Slate hosts Dana Stevens, Chris Molanphy, and Willa Paskin beam in from their collective hearths to deliver unto the internet their favorite gifts for culture lovers. In addition to sharing gifts, they also discuss the cultural artifact that is the “holiday gift guide,” and its history going back to the early 20th century, up to the modern day. See the entirety of the 1910 gift guide Our Special Holiday Gift-Book from Greenhut-Siegel Cooper, and Esquire’s ultra-mod gift guide from 1961.
Check out our gift recommendations below:
Dana Stevens’ Cozy Movie Night-In:
The Salbree Collapsible Silicone Microwave Popcorn Popper & Amish Country Popcorn
The Adventures of Antoine Doinel, The Criterion Collection Box Set
Chris Molanphy’s Hit Parade Collection:
Willa Paskin’s Fruit-Themed Trompe-l'œil Housewares:
The Slate Culture Gift Guide is produced for Slate Studios by Benjamin Frisch and Micah Phillips, with Meryl Bezrutczyk and Andrew Harding.
Need to set up your Slate Plus feed? If you subscribed through Slate.com, check out our FAQ at slate.com/podcastfaqs for easy instructions. Members subscribed via Apple Podcasts get automatic access—no setup required.
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Table of contents
United States
