The Weekend Intelligence: Gaza, after the dust settles (republished)
Digest
This podcast delves into the complex and multifaceted situation in Gaza, nine months into the war. It begins by describing the widespread destruction caused by the Israeli military, leaving no safe havens and a humanitarian crisis. The episode then explores the question of who will govern Gaza after the war ends, examining various potential scenarios, including an Israeli occupation, an international force, private contractors, Hamas, and the Palestinian Authority. The Palestinian Authority, led by Mahmoud Abbas, is actively making plans to take a role in Gaza after a ceasefire. However, the transcript highlights the challenges facing the PA in governing Gaza, including the presence of Hamas and the potential for resistance. The podcast also delves into the Israeli perspective on the future of Gaza, with most officials ruling out a role for Hamas but also hesitant to allow the PA to take charge. The Israeli government is exploring alternative options, including working with powerful families in Gaza. The transcript highlights the stark contrast in perspectives between Israel and the rest of the world, with Israel focusing overwhelmingly on security and the return of hostages, with little attention paid to the suffering of Gazan civilians. The podcast examines the plans of various Israeli politicians for the future of Gaza, ranging from those who advocate for a continued Israeli military presence to those who call for a "denazification program." The transcript also explores the perspective of the Israeli left, which has been marginalized in recent years, and argues for a plan that includes Arab assistance and the creation of "islands of hope" in Gaza. The podcast concludes with a reflection on the lack of understanding between Israelis and Palestinians, highlighting the Israeli focus on security and the failure of Israeli leaders to grasp the anguish and grievances of the Palestinian people.
Outlines
The Devastation of Gaza and Potential Governance Scenarios
This chapter explores the devastating impact of the war in Gaza, leaving no safe havens and a humanitarian crisis. It also examines various potential scenarios for future governance, including an Israeli occupation, an international force, private contractors, Hamas, and the Palestinian Authority.
The Palestinian Authority's Plans and Challenges
This chapter focuses on the Palestinian Authority's plans to take a role in Gaza after a ceasefire. It highlights the challenges facing the PA in governing Gaza, including the presence of Hamas and the potential for resistance.
The Aftermath of the October 7th Attacks and the Israeli Perspective
This chapter recounts the experience of a prominent lawyer from Gaza City during the October 7th attacks and his subsequent decision to flee Gaza. It also delves into the Israeli perspective on the future of Gaza, with most officials ruling out a role for Hamas but also hesitant to allow the PA to take charge.
Israeli Perspectives on the Future of Gaza
This chapter examines the plans of various Israeli politicians for the future of Gaza, ranging from those who advocate for a continued Israeli military presence to those who call for a "denazification program." It also explores the perspective of the Israeli left, which has been marginalized in recent years, and argues for a plan that includes Arab assistance and the creation of "islands of hope" in Gaza.
The Human Cost of the Conflict and Concerns about Lawlessness
This chapter highlights the human cost of the conflict, focusing on the experiences of Gazan civilians who have endured months of bombing, displacement, and hardship. It also explores the growing concerns about Gaza becoming a lawless zone, similar to Mogadishu, Somalia.
A Potential Scenario for the Future and the Lack of Understanding
This chapter explores a potential scenario for the future of Gaza, where Israel stops large-scale operations but maintains the capability to conduct targeted strikes. It concludes with a reflection on the lack of understanding between Israelis and Palestinians, highlighting the Israeli focus on security and the failure of Israeli leaders to grasp the anguish and grievances of the Palestinian people.
Keywords
Gaza Strip
The Gaza Strip is a Palestinian territory on the Mediterranean coast, bordered by Israel and Egypt. It has been the subject of conflict and political tension for decades.
Hamas
Hamas is a Palestinian Islamist political organization and militant group that controls the Gaza Strip. It is considered a terrorist organization by Israel and many Western countries.
Palestinian Authority
The Palestinian Authority is a semi-autonomous governing body in the West Bank and Gaza Strip. It is recognized by the international community as the representative of the Palestinian people.
Two-State Solution
The two-state solution is a proposed resolution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict that envisions the creation of an independent Palestinian state alongside Israel.
Denazification
A term used to describe the process of removing Nazi influence and ideology from a society. In the context of the transcript, it refers to the idea of eliminating Hamas' influence in Gaza.
Islands of Hope
A concept proposed by Yahir Golan, a member of the Israeli Labour faction, to create areas in Gaza where alternative governance and security can be established.
Mogadishu on the Med
A phrase used to describe the potential for Gaza to become a lawless zone, similar to Mogadishu, Somalia, which has been plagued by violence and instability.
Q&A
What are the main challenges facing the Palestinian Authority in governing Gaza?
The Palestinian Authority faces significant challenges in governing Gaza, including the presence of Hamas, the lack of a clear chain of command, and the potential for Hamas to challenge the PA's authority.
What are the different perspectives on the future of Gaza among Israeli politicians?
Israeli politicians have diverse perspectives on the future of Gaza, ranging from those who advocate for a continued Israeli military presence and control over buffer zones to those who call for a "denazification program" or the establishment of "islands of hope."
What are the concerns about Gaza becoming a lawless zone?
Concerns about Gaza becoming a lawless zone are fueled by the breakdown of law and order, the rise of criminal gangs, and the desperation of the population, which has been exacerbated by the conflict.
What is the significance of the "Golden Hour" in post-conflict reconstruction?
The "Golden Hour" is a crucial period in post-conflict reconstruction, as it is the time when the most important thing is to have a plan in place to stabilize the situation and prevent further violence and instability.
What are the implications of the potential scenario where Israel stops large-scale operations but maintains the capability to conduct targeted strikes?
This scenario could prolong the suffering of the Palestinian people, hinder the prospects for a two-state solution, and perpetuate cycles of violence and instability.
What is the significance of the lack of understanding between Israelis and Palestinians?
The lack of understanding between Israelis and Palestinians is a major obstacle to peace and reconciliation. It is essential for both sides to acknowledge the suffering and grievances of the other in order to move towards a lasting solution.
Show Notes
*This episode was first published 20/07/24
After a year of war in Gaza, people are beginning to discuss the aftermath. Schools, hospitals, the sanitation system are in ruins. Just clearing the rubble will take years.
Focusing on the long term, many neglect what needs to happen on day one. Gazans say the territory is becoming lawless. Who will control security, and with what legitimacy? Does anyone have a coherent plan?
In this special episode of The Weekend Intelligence The Economist’s editor-in-chief Zanny Minton Beddoes considers the dangerously rosy thinking about Gaza’s future and asks what happens when the dust settles.
Music credit: Epidemic Sound and Blue Dot Sessions
Listen to what matters most, from global politics and business to science and technology—Subscribe to Economist Podcasts+
For more information about how to access Economist Podcasts+, please visit our FAQs page or watch our video explaining how to link your account.
Table of contents
United States
