The trade fraud detective
6Digest
David Rashid, an expert in auto parts manufacturing, is tasked with reviving Hues and Edelman, a struggling company facing fierce competition from Ching Dao Sun Song, a Chinese company selling power steering hoses at significantly lower prices. Despite tariffs imposed by the Trump administration on Chinese auto parts, Sun Song's prices remain low, prompting David to investigate. He discovers that Sun Song is importing hoses from Thailand, seemingly avoiding the tariffs. Suspecting trade fraud, David sends samples of Sun Song's hoses to forensic labs, confirming his suspicions that the hoses are actually made in China. With the help of a friend with military intelligence connections, David hires a private investigation firm to gather evidence of Sun Song's fraudulent activities. The investigators uncover a network of Thai companies, including Virion and Imperial Cable, involved in the scheme. David presents his evidence to the U.S. government, hoping to initiate legal action against Sun Song. However, his initial attempts to file a False Claims Act lawsuit and an e-allegation with Customs and Border Protection are unsuccessful. David's lawyers connect him with the Trade Fraud Task Force, a specialized unit within the Department of Justice. While initial communication with the Task Force is promising, it eventually stalls, leaving David frustrated and uncertain. David reaches out to his local congressman, who takes an interest in his case and writes a letter to the Department of Homeland Security accusing Sun Song of trade fraud. This intervention, along with David's persistent efforts, ultimately leads to government action. The Department of Homeland Security raids Sun Song's North American facilities in Ohio, seizing evidence as part of an ongoing investigation. This action marks a significant step towards holding Sun Song accountable for its alleged trade fraud. David's story highlights the challenges of enforcing trade laws in a globalized world. Tariffs, intended to protect American companies, are often circumvented through illegal and legal means. Chinese companies are increasingly setting up factories in other countries to avoid tariffs, making enforcement even more difficult.
Outlines
The Challenge of Global Competition
David Rashid, an auto parts factory expert, is tasked with reviving Hues and Edelman, a struggling company facing fierce competition from Ching Dao Sun Song, a Chinese company selling power steering hoses at significantly lower prices. Despite tariffs imposed by the Trump administration on Chinese auto parts, Sun Song's prices remain low, prompting David to investigate.
Uncovering the Deception
David discovers that Sun Song is importing hoses from Thailand, seemingly avoiding the tariffs. Suspecting trade fraud, David sends samples of Sun Song's hoses to forensic labs, confirming his suspicions that the hoses are actually made in China.
The Investigation and its Challenges
With the help of a friend with military intelligence connections, David hires a private investigation firm to gather evidence of Sun Song's fraudulent activities. The investigators uncover a network of Thai companies involved in the scheme. David presents his evidence to the U.S. government, hoping to initiate legal action against Sun Song, but faces bureaucratic hurdles and delays.
Justice Prevails
David's persistent efforts, including gathering evidence, filing lawsuits, and seeking congressional intervention, ultimately lead to government action. The Department of Homeland Security raids Sun Song's North American facilities in Ohio, seizing evidence as part of an ongoing investigation.
Keywords
Trade Fraud
The act of deceiving government authorities to avoid paying tariffs or other import duties on goods. This can involve misrepresenting the origin of goods, undervaluing them, or using other illegal methods to reduce import costs.
Transshipment
The practice of shipping goods through a third country to change their origin or avoid tariffs. While not inherently illegal, it becomes illegal when used to deceive customs authorities and evade import duties.
Forensic Analysis
The scientific examination of evidence to determine its origin, composition, and potential connection to a crime or fraud. In this case, forensic analysis of power steering hoses helped to prove that they were manufactured in China, despite being labeled as made in Thailand.
Tariff
A tax imposed by a government on imported goods. Tariffs are often used to protect domestic industries from foreign competition, but they can also lead to higher prices for consumers and create opportunities for trade fraud.
Globalized World
A world where economies are increasingly interconnected, with goods and services flowing freely across borders. This globalization has made it more challenging to enforce trade laws, as companies can easily shift production and trade routes to avoid tariffs and other regulations.
Chinese Trade Practices
The business practices of Chinese companies, which often involve aggressive competition and a willingness to exploit loopholes in international trade regulations.
Department of Homeland Security
The U.S. government agency responsible for protecting the country from terrorism and other threats, including those related to trade fraud.
Trade Fraud Task Force
A specialized unit within the Department of Justice that investigates and prosecutes cases of trade fraud.
Q&A
How did David Rashid discover that Sun Song was potentially engaging in trade fraud?
David noticed that Sun Song's prices remained low despite the imposition of tariffs on Chinese auto parts. He investigated further and found that Sun Song was importing hoses from Thailand, which led him to suspect that the hoses were actually made in China and being shipped through Thailand to avoid tariffs.
What evidence did David gather to support his claim of trade fraud?
David gathered both physical and financial evidence. He sent samples of Sun Song's hoses to forensic labs, which confirmed that the hoses labeled as made in Thailand were actually made in China. He also obtained financial records from confidential informants in Thailand, which showed that the Thai companies involved in the scheme were deeply intertwined and likely acting as fronts for Sun Song.
What challenges did David face in getting the U.S. government to take action against Sun Song?
David faced a number of challenges, including the sheer volume of imports coming into the U.S., the complexity of trade laws, and the fragmented nature of government agencies responsible for enforcing those laws. He also encountered bureaucratic delays and a lack of responsiveness from government officials.
What ultimately led to the government taking action against Sun Song?
It's difficult to say definitively what led to the government's raid on Sun Song's facilities. However, David's persistent efforts, including gathering evidence, filing lawsuits, and seeking congressional intervention, likely played a significant role. The congressman's letter to the Department of Homeland Security accusing Sun Song of trade fraud may have also contributed to the government's decision to investigate.
What are the implications of David's story for the effectiveness of tariffs in a globalized world?
David's story highlights the challenges of using tariffs to protect domestic industries in a globalized world. Companies can easily circumvent tariffs through illegal and legal means, such as transshipment and shifting production to other countries. This makes it difficult for governments to effectively enforce trade laws and protect domestic businesses from unfair competition.
Show Notes
Then, in 2018, the Trump administration threw companies like Rashid's a lifeline, by announcing tariffs on a range of Chinese goods, including some autoparts. Rashid thought the tariffs would finally force Sunsong to raise its prices, but, somehow, the company never did.
It was a mystery. And it led Rashid to take on a new role – amateur trade fraud investigator. How could his competitor, Sunsong, absorb that 25% tax without changing its prices? And why had all of Sunsong's steering hoses stopped coming from China and started coming from Thailand?
On today's episode, the wide gulf between how tariffs work in theory... and how they actually work in practice. And David Rashid's quest to figure out what, if anything, he could do about it. It's a quest that will involve international detectives, forensic chemists, and a friendship founded on a shared love for hummus.
This episode was hosted by Keith Romer and Jeff Guo. It was produced by Emma Peaslee and edited by Molly Messick. It was fact-checked by Sierra Juarez and engineered by Ko Takasugi-Czernowin. Alex Goldmark is our executive producer.
Help support Planet Money and hear our bonus episodes by subscribing to Planet Money+ in Apple Podcasts or at plus.npr.org/planetmoney.
Learn more about sponsor message choices: podcastchoices.com/adchoices
NPR Privacy Policy
Table of contents
United States
