Join Kathryn and Grace as they reveal themselves to be secret Rune defenders (okay, it’s not that they actually like him—they just think he’s fun on the show!), celebrate Sookie and Jackson finally getting together, and overall, just have a great time with S1E12 “Double Date.” They also figure out where else they’ve seen every minor character in the episode, debate whether double dates are ever a good idea (spoiler alert: almost never), and, perhaps most importantly, make a case for why Pop Tarts should be bigger. Plus: Kathryn dishes about Fugazi t-shirts, Grace finally gets to deliver one of her favorite lines, and the Puffs figure out which character is almost certainly a time-traveling serial killer.