DiscoverThe Indicator from Planet MoneyWant to get ahead in youth sports? Try staying back a year.
Want to get ahead in youth sports? Try staying back a year.

Want to get ahead in youth sports? Try staying back a year.

Update: 2024-09-03
Share

Digest

This podcast delves into the practice of "reclassing" in high school sports, where student athletes repeat a year to gain an advantage in athletic development and college recruitment. The episode begins by sharing a personal story of a stepson's decision to reclass, exploring the motivations and potential benefits, including improved athletic performance and college recruitment opportunities. It then highlights success stories of reclassing, showcasing how it can benefit student athletes, such as Sage Mateo and Elliott Kendo, who both reclassed to enhance their performance and secure lucrative brand deals. However, the episode also explores the financial and ethical implications of reclassing, revealing that it often involves attending expensive private schools, raising concerns about accessibility for underprivileged athletes. The episode discusses the competitive nature of college sports and the potential for reclassing to create an unfair advantage. From a business perspective, the episode examines reclassing as a strategic investment, highlighting the importance of planning and potential return on investment. Insights from a reclassing consultant and a college coach offer different perspectives on the benefits and drawbacks of this strategy. Finally, the episode explores the potential downsides of reclassing, emphasizing the importance of considering the long-term consequences. It highlights the emotional toll it can take on students, the pressure to succeed, and the possibility of disappointment if college aspirations don't materialize.

Outlines

00:00:13
Reclassing: A Personal Story and the Rise of a Trend

This episode explores the phenomenon of "reclassing" in high school sports, where student athletes repeat a year to gain an advantage in athletic development and college recruitment. The host shares her stepson's decision to reclass and explores the motivations and potential benefits, including improved athletic performance and college recruitment opportunities.

00:02:04
Success Stories and the Benefits of Reclassing

This episode highlights success stories of reclassing, showcasing how it can benefit student athletes. Examples include Sage Mateo, a basketball player who reclassed to improve his skills and attract college recruiters, and Elliott Kendo, a basketball player who reclassed twice to enhance his performance and secure lucrative brand deals.

00:05:01
The Costs and Controversies of Reclassing

This episode explores the financial and ethical implications of reclassing. It reveals that reclassing often involves attending expensive private schools, raising concerns about accessibility for underprivileged athletes. The episode also discusses the competitive nature of college sports and the potential for reclassing to create an unfair advantage.

00:06:52
Reclassing: A Business Decision and its Risks

This episode examines reclassing from a business perspective, highlighting the importance of strategic planning and potential return on investment. It features insights from a reclassing consultant and a college coach, who offer different perspectives on the benefits and drawbacks of this strategy. The episode also explores the potential downsides of reclassing, emphasizing the importance of considering the long-term consequences. It highlights the emotional toll it can take on students, the pressure to succeed, and the possibility of disappointment if college aspirations don't materialize.

Keywords

Reclassing


The practice of repeating a year of high school, particularly for student athletes, to gain an advantage in athletic development and college recruitment.

Student Athlete


An individual who participates in organized sports while attending school, often receiving scholarships or other benefits for their athletic abilities.

College Recruitment


The process by which colleges and universities identify and attract prospective student athletes to their athletic programs.

Private School


An independent educational institution that is not funded by the government and typically charges tuition fees.

Scholarship


Financial aid awarded to students based on academic merit, athletic ability, or other criteria, to help cover the cost of education.

Brand Deal


A commercial agreement between a company and an individual, typically a celebrity or athlete, to promote their products or services.

Q&A

  • What is reclassing and why do some student athletes choose to do it?

    Reclassing is when a student athlete repeats a year of high school, often to gain an advantage in athletic development and college recruitment. They may do this to improve their skills, get bigger and stronger, or increase their chances of attracting college coaches.

  • What are some of the potential benefits of reclassing?

    Reclassing can potentially lead to improved athletic performance, increased exposure to college recruiters, and a better chance of securing a scholarship or even a professional contract.

  • What are some of the drawbacks or criticisms of reclassing?

    Reclassing can be expensive, as it often involves attending private schools. It can also create an unfair advantage for those who can afford it, potentially excluding talented athletes from underprivileged backgrounds. Additionally, it can put pressure on students to succeed and may not always lead to the desired outcomes.

Show Notes

Reclassing, when a student repeats an academic year by choice, is a popular way for kids trying to land a spot in a top college athletics program. But it can also come with some heavy costs. Today on the show, we explore the reclassing phenomenon and pressures kids and their parents face in a competitive environment for young athletes.

Related episodes:
Should schools be paying their college athletes? (Apple / Spotify)
The monetization of college sports (Apple / Spotify)

For sponsor-free episodes of The Indicator from Planet Money, subscribe to Planet Money+ via Apple Podcasts or at plus.npr.org.

Music by
Drop Electric. Find us: TikTok, Instagram, Facebook, Newsletter.

Learn more about sponsor message choices: podcastchoices.com/adchoices

NPR Privacy Policy
Comments (1)

Jejj

Malcolm Gladwell wrote about the advantages of being the older individuals in a cohort and how they are often more successful. Even so, "reclassing" is an interesting rebrand of "being held back" and if the ONLY reason it's happening is to give a false athletic advantage that seems really short-sighted.

Sep 4th
Reply
00:00
00:00
x

0.5x

0.8x

1.0x

1.25x

1.5x

2.0x

3.0x

Sleep Timer

Off

End of Episode

5 Minutes

10 Minutes

15 Minutes

30 Minutes

45 Minutes

60 Minutes

120 Minutes

Want to get ahead in youth sports? Try staying back a year.

Want to get ahead in youth sports? Try staying back a year.