DiscoverWayne Brady's What If?! with Jonathan MangumWhat If Nicole Byer Was Our Guest?!
What If Nicole Byer Was Our Guest?!

What If Nicole Byer Was Our Guest?!

Update: 2025-04-03
Share

Digest

This episode of the "What If" podcast features comedian Nicole Byer. The show begins with introductions and a playful musical interlude. Nicole discusses her career journey, transitioning from acting school to improv and stand-up comedy, highlighting her unique comedic style and quick wit. A fictional segment imagines Nicole's career as a singer, followed by a discussion of her podcast, "Why Won't You Date Me?", which focuses on dating and relationships. The hosts and Nicole then delve into a fictional dating app called "Deal With It," where matches lead to immediate marriage. Nicole shares dating app advice, emphasizing authenticity. The episode concludes with hilarious improvised scenes, including a church scene and a job interview, showcasing Nicole's comedic talent and improvisational skills.

Outlines

00:00:00
Introduction & Anytime Fitness; Nicole Byer's Arrival & Career

The podcast opens with an Anytime Fitness advertisement, followed by introductions of Wayne Brady and Jonathan Mangum, who welcome Nicole Byer. They discuss Nicole's comedic journey from acting school to her current success in stand-up and podcasting, highlighting her unique style and quick wit.

00:03:44
Nicole Byer's Comedy & "Why Won't You Date Me?" Podcast

A deep dive into Nicole's comedic style and her podcast, "Why Won't You Date Me?". The discussion covers her approach to comedy, relatable experiences, and advice on navigating the dating world.

00:08:32
Fictional Scenarios: Musical Career & "Deal With It" Dating App

This section features humorous fictional scenarios: Nicole's imagined career as a singer and the introduction of the fictional dating app "Deal With It," where matches result in immediate marriage.

00:25:40
Dating Advice & Improvised Scenes

Nicole offers advice on dating app etiquette, followed by improvised comedic scenes, including a church scene and a job interview, showcasing her improvisational skills and quick wit.

00:32:34
Improvised Church & Job Interview Scenes

The episode concludes with two extended improvised scenes: a humorous church scene discussing sins and relationships, and a job interview where Nicole showcases her quick wit and linguistic skills.

Keywords

Anytime Fitness


A global fitness franchise offering 24/7 access to gyms, equipment, and coaching.

Improvisation (Improv)


A spontaneous form of theatre relying on quick thinking, listening, and collaboration.

Nicole Byer


Stand-up comedian, actress, and podcast host known for witty and relatable humor.

Dating Apps


Mobile applications facilitating romantic connections (e.g., Tinder, Bumble).

Dating Advice


Tips and strategies for successful dating and navigating relationships.

Podcast


An audio program typically downloaded and listened to online.

Comedy


The art of making people laugh; Nicole Byer's style is witty and relatable.

"Why Won't You Date Me?"


Nicole Byer's podcast exploring dating and relationships.

Q&A

  • What is Nicole Byer's approach to comedy?

    Nicole's comedy is characterized by her relatable, witty observations on life, relationships, and dating, using improvisation and a quick-witted style.

  • What is the premise of Nicole Byer's podcast, "Why Won't You Date Me?"

    The podcast explores the complexities of dating and relationships, featuring candid conversations about dating mishaps and relationship dynamics.

  • What is the fictional "Deal With It" dating app?

    "Deal With It" is a humorous, fictional dating app where matching users are legally bound to date and marry.

  • What dating app advice does Nicole offer?

    Nicole suggests focusing on authenticity when interacting on dating apps, engaging with specific details from a potential partner's profile.

  • What is the overall tone and style of the "What If" podcast?

    The podcast is highly improvisational, humorous, and conversational, blending scripted elements with spontaneous interactions and comedic sketches.

Show Notes

Nicole Byer (Nailed It!) joins Wayne and Jonathan to experiment with autotune, dole out dating advice, and hit that high note from Wicked!


Watch this episode on Youtube!


Follow Nicole Byer on Instagram

Follow Wayne Brady on Instagram and TikTok

Follow Jonathan Mangum on Instagram and TikTok


This is a Headgum podcast. Follow Headgum on TwitterInstagram, and Tiktok. Advertise on What If?! via Gumball.fm

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Comments 
00:00
00:00
x

0.5x

0.8x

1.0x

1.25x

1.5x

2.0x

3.0x

Sleep Timer

Off

End of Episode

5 Minutes

10 Minutes

15 Minutes

30 Minutes

45 Minutes

60 Minutes

120 Minutes

What If Nicole Byer Was Our Guest?!

What If Nicole Byer Was Our Guest?!