What the Media Get Wrong About Immigration
1Digest
This episode of On the Media delves into the intricate world of immigration policy and the Israel-Palestine conflict. The first segment features an interview with Jonathan Blitzer, author of "Everyone Who Is Gone Is Here," who traces the roots of the immigration crisis at the U.S.-Mexico border back to the 1980s and the Cold War. Blitzer argues that the U.S. has consistently prioritized its geopolitical interests over the plight of refugees, creating a system that is both unjust and unsustainable. The second segment focuses on the use of terms like colonialism, decolonization, and liberation in the context of the Israel-Palestine conflict. Yad El-Baghdadi, a Palestinian human rights activist, emphasizes the importance of understanding the nuances of these terms and how their misuse can be detrimental to the pursuit of peace. El-Baghdadi argues that the South African model of decolonization, which emphasizes equality and coexistence, offers a more viable path forward than the Algerian model, which relies on military struggle. He also cautions against the dangers of a backward-looking movement that fixates on the past, arguing that a focus on the future is essential for achieving lasting peace.
Outlines
Immigration Policy: A History of Complicity
This Chapter explores the historical context of U.S. immigration policy, tracing its roots back to the 1980s and the Cold War. The chapter argues that the U.S. has consistently prioritized its geopolitical interests over the plight of refugees, creating a system that is both unjust and unsustainable. The chapter also examines the role of media narratives in shaping public perception of the immigration crisis.
Decolonization and the Israel-Palestine Conflict
This Chapter delves into the use of terms like colonialism, decolonization, and liberation in the context of the Israel-Palestine conflict. The chapter emphasizes the importance of understanding the nuances of these terms and how their misuse can be detrimental to the pursuit of peace. The chapter also explores the different models of decolonization, arguing that the South African model, which emphasizes equality and coexistence, offers a more viable path forward than the Algerian model, which relies on military struggle.
Keywords
Immigration Policy
Immigration policy refers to the set of laws, regulations, and practices that govern the movement of people into and out of a country. It encompasses various aspects, including visa requirements, asylum procedures, border control, and citizenship rights. Immigration policy is often a complex and contentious issue, as it involves balancing national security concerns, economic interests, and humanitarian considerations.
Israel-Palestine Conflict
The Israel-Palestine conflict is a long-standing and complex geopolitical dispute involving the competing claims of Israelis and Palestinians to the same territory. The conflict has its roots in the early 20th century, with the rise of Zionism and the establishment of the State of Israel in 1948. The conflict has been marked by violence, displacement, and political deadlock, with both sides having legitimate grievances and aspirations. The conflict continues to be a major source of instability in the Middle East and a significant challenge for international diplomacy.
Colonialism
Colonialism is a system of domination and control by one country over another, typically involving the establishment of settlements, the exploitation of resources, and the imposition of political and cultural structures. Colonialism has a long and complex history, with significant impacts on the societies and economies of colonized regions. The legacy of colonialism continues to shape global power dynamics and social inequalities.
Decolonization
Decolonization refers to the process of dismantling colonial structures and achieving independence from colonial rule. It involves the restoration of sovereignty, the dismantling of colonial institutions, and the reclaiming of cultural identity. Decolonization movements have been a major force in shaping the modern world, leading to the independence of many countries and the emergence of new political and economic orders.
Liberation
Liberation refers to the act of freeing oneself or others from oppression, domination, or confinement. It encompasses a wide range of struggles, including those against colonialism, racism, sexism, and other forms of injustice. Liberation movements often draw inspiration from principles of self-determination, human rights, and social justice.
South African Model
The South African model of decolonization refers to the transition from apartheid to a multiracial democracy in South Africa. This model involved dismantling the system of racial segregation and discrimination, establishing a new constitution that guaranteed equal rights for all citizens, and holding free and fair elections. The South African model is often cited as an example of a successful decolonization process that achieved a peaceful and democratic outcome.
Algerian Model
The Algerian model of decolonization refers to the struggle for independence from French colonial rule in Algeria. This model involved a protracted armed conflict, with the Algerian National Liberation Front (FLN) fighting against French forces. The Algerian model is often seen as an example of a decolonization process that was achieved through armed struggle and violence.
Nakba
The Nakba, meaning "catastrophe" in Arabic, refers to the displacement of hundreds of thousands of Palestinians from their homes during the 1948 Arab-Israeli War. The Nakba is a central event in Palestinian history and a source of ongoing trauma and grievance. The term Nakba is used to describe the loss of land, homes, and livelihoods, as well as the displacement and exile of Palestinians.
Hamas
Hamas is a Palestinian Islamist political and militant organization that controls the Gaza Strip. Hamas is considered a terrorist organization by Israel, the United States, and the European Union. Hamas has been involved in armed conflict with Israel, and its political goals include the establishment of an independent Palestinian state in all of historic Palestine.
Benjamin Netanyahu
Benjamin Netanyahu is an Israeli politician who has served as Prime Minister of Israel for a record 15 years, making him the longest-serving prime minister in Israeli history. Netanyahu is a controversial figure, known for his right-wing political views and his hawkish stance on the Israel-Palestine conflict. He has been a key figure in shaping Israeli policy towards the Palestinians, and his leadership has been marked by both successes and failures.
Q&A
What are the historical roots of the immigration crisis at the U.S.-Mexico border?
Jonathan Blitzer argues that the U.S. has a long history of prioritizing its geopolitical interests over the plight of refugees, dating back to the Cold War. The U.S. has often supported repressive regimes in Central America, creating a climate of violence and instability that has driven people to flee their homes and seek asylum in the U.S.
How does the media contribute to the misapprehension of the immigration crisis?
Blitzer argues that the media often focuses on the political dimensions of the immigration crisis, neglecting the broader historical and social factors that contribute to it. This focus on the "Washington dimensions" of the story leads to a simplistic understanding of the crisis, which fails to capture the complex realities of migration.
What are the different models of decolonization, and how do they apply to the Israel-Palestine conflict?
Yad El-Baghdadi identifies two main models of decolonization: the Algerian model, which relies on armed struggle, and the South African model, which emphasizes equality and coexistence. He argues that the South African model offers a more viable path forward for the Israel-Palestine conflict, as it acknowledges the demographic realities of the region and seeks to build a future based on shared citizenship and equal rights.
What are the dangers of a backward-looking movement in the context of the Israel-Palestine conflict?
El-Baghdadi argues that a focus on the past, particularly the Nakba, can be detrimental to the pursuit of peace. He believes that dwelling on the past can lead to a cycle of trauma and resentment, hindering the ability to imagine a shared future. He emphasizes the importance of moving forward and building a new reality based on equality and coexistence.
What is the role of the U.S. in the ongoing violence and instability in the Middle East?
The episode highlights the complex and often contradictory role of the U.S. in the Middle East. While the U.S. has often sought to promote peace and stability in the region, its policies have also contributed to violence and instability. The U.S. has a long history of supporting authoritarian regimes in the region, and its military interventions have often had unintended consequences. The episode suggests that the U.S. needs to re-evaluate its approach to the Middle East and adopt a more nuanced and less interventionist policy.
Show Notes
Immigration is one of the most important issues in this year’s presidential election. This week, On the Media traces how root causes of mass migration from Central America to the United States over the past decade stem back to the Cold War. Plus, a deep dive on terms like “colonialism” and “decolonization,” and what they mean in the context of Israel-Palestine.
[01:00 ] Host Brooke Gladstone speaks with Jonathan Blitzer, who covers immigration for The New Yorker and is author of the book, Everyone Who Is Gone Is Here, about how the root causes of mass migration from Central America to the United States over the past decade stem back to the Cold War. This interview originally aired on our February 2, 2024 show.
[15:30 ] Brooke continues her conversation with Jonathan Blitzer about how the past and future of Central America and the United States are inextricable, and the far-reaching consequences of Congress’ refusal to reform the immigration system since 1990. This interview originally aired on our February 2, 2024 show.
[30:58 ] Brooke Gladstone speaks with Iyad el-Baghdadi, a Palestinian human rights activist, writer, and co-author of The Middle East Crisis Factory, about the value of historical parallels to describe the conflict in Palestine, and why the precise meanings behind words like “decolonization” and “colonialism” are crucial. This interview originally aired on our March 8, 2024 show.
Further reading / listening:
On the Media is supported by listeners like you. Support OTM by donating today (https://pledge.wnyc.org/support/otm). Follow our show on Instagram, Twitter and Facebook @onthemedia, and share your thoughts with us by emailing onthemedia@wnyc.org.
Table of contents
United States
